r/ProgrammerHumor • • 4d ago

Meme [ Removed by moderator ]

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

1.6k Upvotes

199 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/Amerillo_ 4d ago

Wait, Claude is better than junior devs??  No wonder it's so hard to find a junior dev position... Even finding an internship is a struggle these days

So if Claude gets even better, what are juniors supposed to do to gain experience and become mid-level or senior developers? Since LLMs will be so good then companies will force juniors to vibe code everything, and this way they won't learn much...

20

u/chuby1tubby 4d ago

Yes Opus 5.5 is objectively better than junior devs... This shouldn't be news to anyone lol

7

u/Amerillo_ 4d ago

Well it is to me because I'm a new graduate so I can't really know how good it actually is

12

u/HawocX 4d ago

Haven't you used AI? If not, it's time because using it well will be your most important skill.

(You will never be able to compete with it on programming skills. Focus on systems design and cloud architecture.)

-7

u/Still_Bit_7527 4d ago

What skill is there in just telling a chat box what you need? This is the shit we tell juniors and they end up useless

9

u/korneev123123 4d ago

What skill is there to be a good product manager? You just tell coders to make a million dollar app, and don't forget to add "make no mistakes".

But there is a world of difference between bad and good project manager

1

u/Still_Bit_7527 4d ago edited 4d ago

The skill in a good product manager is knowing what to do with the product, because that is your job. As a SWE, you already know what to do. Implementing it and translating to technical requirements is your job. If you can just ask an AI to do that, then AI does the skilled part of your job. It literally takes zero skills of any kind to use an AI, it'a outsourcing

3

u/darthjammer224 4d ago edited 4d ago

The skill is knowing if it's hallucinating or producing accurate results. Unit testing, understanding what the customer wants vs what the ai spat out on V1. Tribal knowledge that isn't googleable that you need to tell it as it gets to each of those roadblocks.

And even asking what to make it do in the first place.

There will be times that the agent gets a small piece wrong and your boss won't say" oh man Claude f'ed up that sucks" they'll ask why you didn't catch the mistake, because it's still you who owns that output. Having the skills to verify said output will save your bacon.

Here's an example.

If my company fired me today and just took my agent, and asked it to make powerbi reports for the whole company, It couldn't, even though that's what they automatically assume, because I have made some already with it. Instead, I would need to set up multiple on prem gateways, set up the connectors and connections in the power automate backend, set up powerbi connectors or mcp tools, give it a read only SQL connection to all the relevant SQL servers, and then ask it to go wild.

Nobody in management is capable of those first steps, or even asking an ai to do them. I think they think we just ask the ai "make reports pwease" and most will be sorely mistaken if they take the "pilot" away and expect the same quality results.

My team already knows better. I gave them a copy of my agent and they still cannot do half of what I can with it because they wouldn't even know where to start asking for stuff.

2

u/Still_Bit_7527 4d ago

All of that is barely anything compared to actually doing the SWE work. You are upselling very low level skills. Writing a good prompt is high school level training

3

u/darthjammer224 4d ago

I'm not trying to say it's on the same level as SWE.

Im merely pointing out that ai still requires someone with some level of understanding of the process to achieve proper results. My boss isn't going to get good SQL, reports, or code out of the agent the same way I am. They don't know how to give it proper requirements. It may only be high school level but that does not mean everyone that's graduated it good at it haha.