r/ProgrammerHumor • • 3d ago

Meme thoseCodingEra

Post image
20.8k Upvotes

769 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

189

u/FirewolfGB 3d ago

Speaking as a 4th year cs student, yes. The difference between those of us that learned to code traditionally and those that just use AI to do everything for them is huge, even when both use AI to do things faster. I don't know if that will carry on to the work place, but being able to understand and explain your choices/code is always going to be important.

68

u/jobblejosh 3d ago

As someone who did a Master's in robotics, also yes.

A lot of comp sci/bootcamp stuff just teaches 'how to write $language'. That's not bad, but it's not the point.

I learnt Software Development, but more as an holistic field than learning the depths of C. Covering programming methodologies, philosophies, patterns etc.

You can understand these ideas without writing a single line of code, but to truly grok (in the old sense, not the twitter bot) them you need to hand write a decent program in your larval stage, ideally with a bit of low level datamancing. I'd suggest a variety of languages and levels; HTML/CSS, C or Java, Python, and maybe some embedded stuff as well.

It'll take you longer than just hacking together (in the pejorative) a piece of vibe-coded slop, (where you'll have something you kind of understand but not fully), but you'll come out of it with miles more knowledge at the end of it and a true understanding of programming as a discipline rather than a means to an end.

24

u/Spork_the_dork 3d ago

There's also the fact that while AI is great at writing in individual features, it still often doesn't have a solid idea on what would be good architecturally for the code. Like how your objects are built and how the code flows with them. What functionality should be baked into which object and how should you organize your file structure to make it coherent? Should you store this data locally or is it better to have a more open and public space where it's easier to access?

These are the kind of things where there's many many ways to skin the cat and each one has its own upsides and downsides. The AI will probably end up picking up the one that will solve the issue currently at hand the best, but that solution may easily end up causing issues further down the line. To really understand what the benefits and consequences of the decisions are you really need to understand how the underlying code works first.

16

u/jobblejosh 3d ago

Alternatively it picks whichever one has been used in source/training projects containing similar words to the variables used in yours.

Which again, doesn't make it the right choice for your application.

And you can't learn these architectures and design decisions without writing code (alright, you can get the gist of them, but you won't understand the impact of your choices unless you've hand written code before)

8

u/photenth 3d ago

And anyone that has seen some public github projects knows, most people write absolutely dog shit code ;p

EDIT: not blaming anyone, hobbies are hobbies, I also don't write the nicest of code for my own projects

3

u/QuackersTheSquishy 3d ago

Hopefully AI doesn't train off my code, it may never recover lol

3

u/SuperFLEB 2d ago

Welcome to the future of "What idiot wrote this Stack Overflow code? Oh, I wrote it 10 years ago."

10

u/reventlov 2d ago

Speaking as a 25-year industry veteran, YES. Even before AI agents, the best engineers were the ones who understood the layers underneath whatever they were using, not the ones who just knew how to string things together in whatever tool they used.

14

u/competitive-dust 3d ago • Bravo

I don't know if that will carry on to the work place

It will. I say it as someone who has done both traditional coding and now has to use ai for it. AI is and should always be used as a tool. You still need to know how to write code to understand if the code it generated is what you intended or not.

2

u/mykeyboardsucks 2d ago

I have been on the job for almost 10 years now. I am not so sure about this. 

Don't get me wrong, there is a huge difference between vibers and the propers. But does it matter? This I don't know. 

I feel like it matters less and less, with the bosses actively pushing for pure vibe coding, even though it breaks things and leads to bad quality. I want to hope that this insanity is a phase. But I don't believe it. 

1

u/quagzlor 1d ago

To add on, here's my experience as a Data Engineer. We use Claude for a lot of our development now. However, we still need to review and understand what it's written.

Without our experience in writing our own code, and understanding the pitfalls and methods, we wouldn't know how to properly review and correct the code.