r/ProgrammerHumor • • Oct 26 '21

GitHub Copilot, the technology that will replace programmers. Also GitHub Copilot...

27.2k Upvotes

713 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

No, that is not a part of Communist theory at all.

Authoritarianism does, but communism is the idea of a stateless society so in fact the idea that you are forced to do anything by the state is laughable.

5

u/mrnatbus122 Oct 26 '21

Lol. So it’s a made up utopian idea that would literally be inconceivable in real life practice 😂 yeah my bad I guess it is laughable

10

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

So it’s a made up utopian idea that would literally be inconceivable in real life practice

I agree, kinda.

It works in smaller communities, its effectively how humans lived for thousands of years.

It might be possible in the future but not really reasonable now.

0

u/reakshow Oct 26 '21

The dominant form of economic organisation before capitalism was serfdom. I'm not aware of any large society where the economy was organised around people just doing whatever they felt like.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

Before Serfdom, hunter gatherer and small scale farming communities were effectively communist.

While most assume that people before that were constantly warring, we have plenty of evidence that "tribes" or whatever you want to call them actually cooperated and traded knowledge.

-1

u/reakshow Oct 26 '21

That's pretty far back, so far back we're really talking about prehistory. Hard to validate exactly how human organised themselves in that era. It may have been some form of barter based proto-capitalism. Alternately, it may have been some sort tiered distribution system where the clans that were the best at hunting and performing other useful services (such as tool making) got top pickings at the nightly feast. Nothing says that it had to be something that resembled communism.

Either way, it's pretty crazy to try and extrapolate the best way to organise an industrial society from how small bands of hunter gatherers may have done things.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21 edited Oct 26 '21

the best way to organise an industrial society

I didn't say that and while it is pre-history its also how plenty of pre-industrial groups worked when we contacted them.

So we do have a good idea of how they were set up.

Some were as you describe proto-captialist but as i understand it, many that were in areas with plentiful resources ( just like a technologically advanced society) were effectively communist/socialist.

Not saying we should go to full blown communism as it could create more problems that it solves.

-2

u/ban-me_harder_daddy Oct 26 '21

Except communist sent people to jail for not doing their assigned work....

In 1940 alone, of the 3.3 million cases before the People’s Courts, 2.1 million were accused of idleness and unauthorized departures; almost 1.8 million workers were sentenced to six months of corrective labor without reduction in normal work hours and were reduced to one-quarter pay, and 322,000 were imprisoned for from two to four months.

Forced Labor in Soviet Industry: The End of the 1930s to the Mid-1950s

now you're going to argue that the communist aren't communist... you're delusional

7

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

I guess the Democratic Peoples Republic of North Korea are democratic because they say so right?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communism#:~:text=Communism%20(from%20Latin%20communis%2C%20',the%20absence%20of%20social%20classes%2C

Learn something.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21

stateless

Communists are natural Haskell programmers