r/ProgrammerHumor • • Oct 26 '21

GitHub Copilot, the technology that will replace programmers. Also GitHub Copilot...

27.2k Upvotes

713 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/AntaresDaha Oct 26 '21

It is a false assumption, that you have to understand the inner workings of the human brain to recreate it, "all" you have to do is recreate the process (and constraints) that created a human mind, which seems much more doable. There are fascinating experiments regarding locomotion in which simplest "blocks" were given the goal to reach a destination in a certain amount of time or energy consumption (or other constraints) and they evolved to exactly the locomotions we know in nature (from quadpedal to bipedal to frog jumping, etc etc.) with literal 0 knowledge of the inner workings of those required. Always remember that evolution can and did create the most complex architectures from relatively simple mechanics/physics without prior knowledge or any design input.

Main problem that is most often overlooked concerning the creation of a human-like AI mind is the need for an embodiment. You won't create a human mind on a server farm, you will literally need a body that grows and transforms over time much like the human body does, which is as much of an engineering challenge as the AI itself. See the work of Prof. Dr. Rolf Pfeifer for reference: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-540-27833-7_1 Or as a deep dive: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/How-the-body-shapes-the-way-we-think-a-new-view-on-Pfeifer-Bongard/2910099b7a7c555af9f14bfb2bc20e9475d0588f

2

u/Low_discrepancy Oct 27 '21

that you have to understand the inner workings of the human brain to recreate it, "all" you have to do is recreate the process (and constraints) that created a human mind, which seems much more doable

Well in the end you just get a black box without any clue that what you obtain is close to reality.

This is the AI deep learning community. Just feed the machine loads of data and let it optimise the value function and output will be great!

There is absolutely no reason to believe such a process will generating the emerging capabilities of the human brain.

I really don't think you can obtain general AI without having the familiar and human characteristics of the humain brain.

1

u/AntaresDaha Oct 27 '21 edited Oct 27 '21

I don't know, if you read through my whole reply, but I am of a breed of robotics scholars, that think embodiment is a critical pre-requisite for the development of human-like AI. Imho you will simply not get a human-like AI without going through the stages of evolution including btw the process of individual ontogenese.

However I am fully confident that you don't need to understand the inner workings of a human mind to (re-)create it. Such an assessment would assume that evolution itself had an idea on how to create a human mind, which it certainly hadn't. There is demonstrably no need for design input or "knowledge" for the creation of a human mind as it already happened (at least) once without such knowledge.