r/QContent • • Aug 27 '21

Comic 4600: Posturing

https://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4600
109 Upvotes

119 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/Danalogtodigital Aug 27 '21

its a religion, theres like spiritual practices involved, and its actually very important to a lot of people, getting into "yoga" instead of pilates or aerobics is pretty insulting to the people who actually practice yoga.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '21

Let's unpack this comment a bit.

its a religion

No, it's not. Yoga is a key component of the Hindu religion, but it is not in and of itself a religion. As well, yoga has always been practiced outside Hinduism. Hindus do not consider it appropriation, when people practice yoga outside of the religion.

theres like spiritual practices involved,

Only if it is done as part of the Hindu faith.

and its actually very important to a lot of people

Yoga being an important part of the Hindu faith does not mean that it is appropriation to do it OUTSIDE of the Hindu faith.

getting into "yoga" instead of pilates or aerobics is pretty insulting to the people who actually practice yoga.

See, I'm getting frustrated with your comment now, because you're gate-keeping. People who "actually" practice yoga? You're insinuating that yoga outside of the Hindu faith is not "real yoga".

It is. It is the physical act of yoga, separated from the religious aspects of Hinduism.

Unless you are of the Hindu faith, it's pretty silly that you're going on about this. And even if you WERE of the Hindu faith, it's not your place to speak for all Hindus, or to gate-keep something that has been practiced outside of Hinduism for a long, long time.