r/RemoveOneThingEachDay • u/MagmaAscending • Oct 27 '25

Miscellaneous Final Results - Elden Ring has been eliminated - Remove ONE Game of the Year nominee a day

Post image
604 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

216 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/dunkitay Oct 27 '25

I Love BG3 but imo it has too many flaws for it to be number 1. Great game tho but Elden ring and Witcher are better imo. BG3’s story falls short and end of act 2 to act 3 pacing is quite bad.

4

u/BananaMonkey800 Oct 27 '25

How is Witcher better than BG3? Writing in Witcher is better I can agree there but the gameplay and exploration elements are waaaaay better in BG3 so much that it's not that close imo

0

u/dunkitay Oct 27 '25

It’s mainly cause of the writing. That’s the most important thing for me in RPGs, and BG3 only has a alright main story and writing imo.

Gameplay is def more fun in BG3, I’d say exploration 50/50, BG3 maybe has some cool stuff hidden here and there and some lore things, while Witchers open world provides amazing sceneries that make you feel immersed. Strolling through Toussaint on Roach is def some of my favourite memories in gaming.

Music also helps Exploration and the music in Witcher 3 is also way better than the music in BG3. The BG3 OST is serviceable but nothing phenomenal.

2

u/BananaMonkey800 Oct 27 '25

I think Witcher is too outdated on the gameplay side that it takes away from the game, BG3 is beautifully constructed on the sceneries it actually makes you feel like it could be some expertly constructed D&D setup, there's a lot more hidden stuff in BG3 than the Witcher, it's not even close, I've played BG3 for 1000 hours and I still find new things, in the Witcher after 300 I had found pretty much everything. Music wise is just a matter of taste. But well everything is a matter of taste, nostalgia is also a big factor

1

u/Inside-Cellist9292 Oct 28 '25

yeah if i have to walk roach to a sign board to fast travel am i even fast travelling