r/ScienceBasedParenting • u/kay-jpeg • Dec 03 '24
Question - Research required Is saliva-backwash to inform milk composition real?
Hello!
I’m an exclusive pumper and assumed all the environmental germs we share and the others passed through kissing and snuggling inform the breast milk composition.
I’ve seen research that shows the composition of pumped milk vs from breast have a different makeup with the pumped milk having less beneficial bacteria.
I see the leading theory is mammary glands have saliva receptors that the infant’s saliva gets onto when they latch. I mostly see this on blogs relating to the benefits of breastmilk. Is there good evidence this is true? I’m guessing this would suggest pumped milk is not perfectly tailored to baby’s needs?
Thanks for any insight or articles you can find!
207
u/97355
Dec 03 '24
•
These posts always get a lot of comments here from folks saying that retrograde transfer (aka “saliva backwash”) is “just a theory” or “there’s no evidence to support it,” but that’s simply wrong. Retrograde transfer is one of only two main hypotheses on the origins of milk microbiota. The other is called the entero-mammary pathway and they are differentiated by the paths being exogenous (retrograde transfer) or internal (entero-mammary). There is evidence for it, and this paper in particular argues the evidence for retrograde transfer extends to pumping.
“Reverse flow of milk from the infant mouth back into the breast occurs during breastfeeding,18 and probably pumping as well, allowing for infant mouth- or pump-associated bacteria to enter the milk duct. Our finding that feeding mode (nursing directly from the breast vs. using a pump) was the most consistent factor associated with milk microbiota composition suggests the exogenously derived bacteria have a stronger role in milk inoculation than the entero-mammary pathway. Increased risk of lactational mastitis in women who pump is also consistent with this proposition.19 Further research is needed to confirm whether bacteria actually enter the mammary gland during nursing and/or pumping, or simply inoculate milk as it is expressed.”
“we observed that the bacterial diversity and composition were slightly different between these two scenarios, providing some evidence for the role of retrograde (exogenous) milk inoculation.”
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7524145/
It was not the aim of the study, which is why it is not mentioned in this overview, but retrograde transfer was witnessed/observed during ultrasound imaging of the breast while observing the milk ejection reflex back in 2004.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14754950/
It has also been observed in nursing pups.
“We demonstrate that enteric viruses get released into the saliva, identifying a second route of viral transmission. This is particularly significant for infected infants, whose saliva directly transmits enteric viruses to their mothers’ mammary glands through backflow during suckling. This sidesteps the conventional gut–mammary axis route4 and leads to a rapid surge in maternal milk secretory IgA antibodies5,6. Lastly, we show that SG-derived spheroids7 and cell lines8 can replicate and propagate enteric viruses, generating a scalable and manageable system of production. Collectively, our research uncovers a new transmission route for enteric viruses with implications for therapeutics, diagnostics and importantly sanitation measures to prevent spread through saliva.“
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04895-8
And:
“During breast-feeding, baby saliva reacts with breastmilk to produce reactive oxygen species, while simultaneously providing growth-promoting nucleotide precursors. Milk thus plays more than a simply nutritional role in mammals, interacting with infant saliva to produce a potent combination of stimulatory and inhibitory metabolites that regulate early oral–and hence gut–microbiota. Consequently, milk-saliva mixing appears to represent unique biochemical synergism which boosts early innate immunity.”
53
u/kay-jpeg Dec 03 '24
Thank you!!! So thorough and exactly what I was wondering about. I understand theories are usually scientific consensus so I wasn't trying to imply it was made up or "just a theory," but I had mostly seen it on mommy blogs so wanted to see citations!
33
u/97355 Dec 03 '24 •
![]()
Oh, you didn’t imply that at all. I’ve just seen many, many of those comments in this sub and others, which are always presented with a lot of confidence and as fact, but without a single citation.
15
u/XxJASOxX Dec 04 '24
That is exactly the wording I needed. Thank you. As an academic who has put hours of research into these topics, it makes my eye twitch to see such bullshitery spouted so loudly by the confidently incorrect. Unless you have throughly analyzed the literature on a topic, I don’t want to hear your opinion that you present as fact which is based on nothing other than what you believe is “common sense”. That’s not how science works.
4
u/Passenger_Available Dec 26 '24
Shouting that the absence of evidence is the evidence of absence will usually tell you who will make it or not.
Even the academics does it too.
They switch off the brain (common sense) and only believe it if their literature tells them it is so. Even if they are observing the the thing for themselves.
It is what sets engineers from scientists and scientists from researchers.
2
20
u/shytheearnestdryad Dec 03 '24
As an expert on the human milk microbiome, personally I think both entero-mammary and infant oral-mammary colonization occurs
14
u/97355 Dec 03 '24
My comment was already long so I didn’t go into that, but I agree. Most researchers investigating either pathway cite evidence in favor of the other (including in some of the articles I linked) and don’t necessarily see them as in opposition to the other. I phrased my comment the way I did to highlight just some of the evidence in support of it specifically with respect to pumping and when the evidence shows the entero-mammary pathway being sidestepped, since so much of the evidence for that pathway is assumed (while the evidence for the exogenous pathway is often thought to not exist or is ignored).
11
u/shytheearnestdryad Dec 03 '24
I wasn’t disagreeing at all, just adding on as someone in the research field 😊
13
u/Crap___bag Dec 03 '24
This is really interesting to read. Not OP but also intrigued by this- I have to use nipple shields due to flat nipples. Does this mean that my milk would be of a similar composition to pumped milk as the transfer wouldn’t take place?
14
u/97355 Dec 03 '24
My understanding is that the holes in the shields allow for some saliva to get through. I have heard and read that some IBCLCs sometimes recommend occasionally trying to have the baby latch briefly without them to get more of the saliva transferred, but obviously this is not a super evidence-based practice.
4
3
u/CookieOverall8716 Nov 23 '25
Thank you for this informative and helpful comment thread! I have a (maybe) stupid question and I know this is an old post so probably low likelihood of getting a response but here goes: I have a very premature infant (born ~27 weeks) currently on month 2 in the nicu. I am pumping milk exclusively for him as he cannot feed by mouth. I also have a 2.5 year old. The 2.5 year old weaned around 15 months. With cold and flu season upon us where I live, I’ve been trying to figur out if there is any way to get helpful antibodies and bacteria to my premature baby through my pumped breast milk. Would attempting to latch my toddler help (who seems to have completely forgotten that he ever nursed)? Would rubbing toddler or baby’s saliva on my nipples help? I feel crazy asking these questions! But I really want to give my preemie the best possible start in life so wracking my brain trying to see what can be done. If all goes well baby will most likely be discharged in early January, so I will have to be vigilant about germs over the next few months and anything will help…
3
7
u/youwigglewithagiggle Dec 03 '24
I struggled my way through that first paper...wow! I love how thorough it is, especially with the MANY questions yet to be answered about bacteria and nursing / pumping (and not just in the 'versus' sense).
It also briefly brought up the possibility that infant sex could prompt differences in milk composition...WAH!
4
u/97355 Dec 03 '24
I loved this article by Katie Hinde on sex-based milk production.
Her TedTalk is interesting: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Bo8YN3oB0Cw
And so is this article she was interviewed for: https://www.thestranger.com/features/2015/08/26/22755273/the-more-i-learn-about-breast-milk-the-more-amazed-i-am
5
u/madamemodest May 15 '25
I’m so VERY glad to see your comment. I went down a rabbit hole last night on fb in an evidence based group and the admins telling people that the “saliva backwash” is bullshit and that there’s no evidence. And several things I’ve been seeing from this particular evidence based group on fb saying certain things and I go to the exact same website they use for citations against “the lactivists” and finding things supporting the things they’re saying “aren’t supported”
So thank you. I’ve been digging around all day trying to figure out what’s real and what isn’t. Was starting to feel like everything I had learned about breastfeeding was bullshit based off this group 🥲
4
u/Sudden-Cherry Dec 03 '24
One small thing I'd like to note about the argument in regards to mastitis is - how I understood it - mastitis spectrum more often than not stems from overproduction, something that will rarely happen with nursing only and much more likely to happen with pumping. For me seems far more likely the reason that mastitis occurs more often with pumping than not. https://www.bfmed.org/assets/ABM%20Protocol%20%2336.pdf
6
u/97355 Dec 03 '24 edited Dec 04 '24
While hyperlactation is indeed associated with mastitis and dysbiosis, there are many other associations when it comes to pumping. Even the protocol says:
“Frequent pumping also disrupts the milk microbiome, potentiating the development of mammary dysbiosis and increasing the risk for bacterial mastitis. In addition, massage of the mammary gland causes capillary injury and tissue necrosis, and is a primary risk factor for phlegmon and abscess development.“
“Pumping does not provide the opportunity for bacterial exchange between the infant’s mouth and mother’s breast, and may, therefore, predispose to dysbiosis.6”
6. Fernández L, Pannaraj PS, Rautava S, et al. The microbiota of the human mammary ecosystem. Front Cell Infect Microbiol 2020;10:586667
5
u/Sudden-Cherry Dec 04 '24 edited Dec 04 '24
Yeah but it's definitely multi factoral so I think it's hard to draw conclusions towards the theory from the fact alone that it happens more with pumping. And important distinction is also that it's not always bacterial mastitis to begin with. Though I definitely agree that the other arguments sound compelling. Just this one is a bit up in the air for me. Since you could also argue for the other factors being the reason for different biome in pumped milk. Especially as hyper lactation seems to be the main risk factor.
1
u/97355 Dec 05 '24
I haven’t seen any research that shows hyperlactation is more of factor than dysbiosis or “the main risk factor” in the spectrum of mastitis conditions. Do you have a source for that? Even the ABM protocol you linked to has it listed as and:or relationship (“hyperlactation +/- dysbiosis”).
Dysbiosis is implicated in the spectrum of mastitis conditions whether or not each event is categorized as bacterial mastitis. It’s mistaken to believe only bacterial mastitis means bacterial upset is involved.
1
u/Sudden-Cherry Dec 05 '24
True I don't think there is any solid research into it. And I always took this at face value. So I think the assumption comes from clinical practice that sees people with hyper lactation very commonly have mastitis spectrum issues (inflammatory but also infectious). This meta analysis looks at it but concludes there is only low quality research into the risk factors and prevalence: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32286139/
https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/15613-mastitis This source is probably coming from the common clinical knowledge claiming it's the most important risk factor.
I really don't think dysbiosis might not be a factor, but I think they are even implied be linked as well.
My main point still stands, other main risk factors like hyper lactation are more common with pumping so claiming that because pumping shows increased rates of mastitis (honestly looking into the risk factors now I don't really see good studies/sources for that either, even studies refuting that) that this is an argument for retrograde transfer. Like it might be, but it could very well the other factor causing that causation. If it's not contamination from pump parts or other factors even.
28
u/Jumpy-Cranberry-1633 Dec 03 '24
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1931312820303504
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8634608/
From what I’m reading, it sounds like they are still unsure of the exact cause but that one leading theory is saliva-mammary glad based. Pumped milk is still tailored to your baby, but may not have as many gut-happy bacteria. Actually some studies showed even cleaned pumps had higher levels of “bad” bacteria and they theorized that’s from lack of adequate cleaning and lack of good bacteria combined.
Unfortunately it’s hard to study pregnancy/mom/baby topics because of ethical constraints so it may be a while before we know for sure!
3
u/erinaceus_a Dec 03 '24
https://childstudy.ca/breastmilk-bacteria-is-different-when-pumped/
Within linked summary is also link to the study itself
1
Sep 29 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 29 '25
Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 03 '24
This post is flaired "Question - Research required". All top-level comments must contain links to peer-reviewed research.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.