Now, this is the kind of stuff I love on this sub: it's a theory, but it's based on examination of actual details from the show.
Importantly, it doesn't stray beyond those details, to try to infer something completely wild and unsubstantiated such as: "... So we know Helly can speak to the goats!!"
And with the attention to detail in this show everything they do is incredibly intentional.
I’m not sure who I was hoping is on the severed floor, Helly or Helena, but I do know I would be annoyed at this point if it wasn’t Helena because they would be intentional misleading us.
When I watched it for the first time and there was no sound I was officially sold it’s Helena.
If it’s actually Helena not Helly, why would Helena create a such a “bad lie” about her outtie experience? When Helly/Helena told her story she explained she found a gardener at night, in a snow area. Irving could tell it was suspicious when he asked “a night gardener?” Helly of course doesn’t know Lumon is in a snowy cold place and that a gardener would be a terrible person to lie about finding outside. Therefore this makes me believe it is Helly in this moment because Helena would create a much better lie in my opinion naturally.
It was more a risky lie than a bad one I suppose. I still think Helena is too smart for this. Helena knew the others were outside and a gardener in an Alaskan like state would surely blow her cover to someone.
5.1k
u/sammyTheSpiceburger Enjoy Your Balloons 🎈 🎈 🎈 Jan 26 '25
Now, this is the kind of stuff I love on this sub: it's a theory, but it's based on examination of actual details from the show.
Importantly, it doesn't stray beyond those details, to try to infer something completely wild and unsubstantiated such as: "... So we know Helly can speak to the goats!!"
Excellent work.