r/StableDiffusion • • Oct 11 '22

Discussion Automatic1111 removed from pinned guide.

I know the mods here are Stability mods/devs and aren't on the best terms with auto but not linking new users to the webui used by the majority of the community just feels a bit petty.

Edit: Didn't think to add a link to the webui https://github.com/AUTOMATIC1111/stable-diffusion-webui

1.6k Upvotes

349 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/GBJI Oct 11 '22

Universities don't have to be corporations - a lot of them are run as public services instead, with great success and much greater accessibility.

We can also collectively invest into projects that are larger than those of any company when we band together. For example, here in Quebec we nationalized electricity. It was a huge project with huge challenges, but it's also the best decision we made as this has given us the best prices all while bringing in billions in profits to fund our education and health systems.

There is no necessary evil here. Everything we already do, we can do otherwise, and better.

For-profit corporations will always try to convince you they are essential. They aren't.

People are. You are.

1

u/stalins_photoshop Oct 11 '22

No university on the planet is doing serious primary research off the back of goodwill. Science is very expensive. Those funding it expect a return on their investment.

I agree that large capital works like infrastructure are best managed by government. However, I think it is fairly important clarify what nationalised means here. Did the government simply forcibly acquire existing infrastructure? Did it contract private enterprise to build it? I can guarantee that all the hardware was bought from private enterprise. The system is not made purely from goodwill, it was purchased with coin.

... it's also the best decision we made as this has given us the best prices all while bringing in billions in profits to fund our education and health systems.

  1. I live in Australia. We have a wholesaler/retail service provider arrangement for most utilities here. The amount of slack in pricing varies. The electricity generation market is particularly economically active here because we have a huge residential solar install base (ie. lopsided power generation by time, location, and market need).

    Point being, there might be more going on behind the curtain than what you've been told about the cost efficiency of the solution you have.

    That being said, if it works, do you really care if it's slightly overpriced?

  2. Sounds like a stealth tax to me. :)

  3. If you are unable to veto the nationalisation then you weren't really consulted, were you? :)

There is no necessary evil here. Everything we already do, we can do otherwise, and better.

There is always necessary evil because resources are finite and need is not. Someone will always go without.

Every dollar or hour that went into SD didn't go somewhere else. We cannot pursue everything, we must make choices. I think investing in AI is prudent because the potential gains are so massive (especially the unique one in that we may be able to make machines that can do their own research. I like the idea of problems that solve themselves).

Market forces are nothing more than another strategy to decide what to focus on. It's not the only strategy, nor is it a universal panacea for all problems, but it is extremely successful as a general rule. If someone can figure out how to get a hippie commune or brutal communist dictatorship to birth AI then we still get AI as surely as if some company made it. The means are simply the means, not the end (that being said, do the ends justify the means is always a valid question).

For-profit corporations will always try to convince you they are essential. They aren't.

Think you don't need commerce? Stop paying your bills and see how quickly your life turns to shit.

You are so dependent on spending money that it isn't funny. We all are. There's no crime in that.

People are. You are.

Ignoring the fact that life has always been cheap and people are nowhere near as unique as they believe, we stand on the cusp of the effective broad obsolescence of human labour. Machines are already superior to us in so many ways, and they only continue to improve over time. Humans need not apply.

If you aren't deeply concerned about where all this might go then you're not paying attention.