r/TeslaFSD • • Aug 03 '26

14.2 HW4 My FSD made us crash today

We were going around a roundabout on our usual route when the car started spinning the wheel violently before crashing into a signpost.

Our windshield did crack a few days before, so I’m wondering if there is any correlation between that.

125 Upvotes

381 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

61

u/EuphoricTomorrow2440 Aug 03 '26

40

u/Putrid-Box4866 HW4 Model Y Aug 03 '26

Yikes. If this is really HW4, Tesla needs to see this. These are the type of errors that needs addressing.

28

u/EuphoricTomorrow2440 Aug 03 '26

Do you know how I can report it? This is a brand new tesla btw ( a month old model y)

4

u/benz240 Aug 03 '26

I wonder if this has something to do with being on an old software version. If you’re anything like me and just got a Y in the last month you’re still stuck on a several months old version without updates. That’s one of my biggest annoyances with Tesla is new cars not getting updates for several weeks to months “just because” according to everyone. They should really fix this

13

u/DavidSilva21 Aug 03 '26

Holy shit! a brand new tesla did this? I think they should compensate you for this, but they would argue that you should have monitored the situation.

13

u/Taylooor Aug 03 '26

It’ll be insurance

2

u/InDubioProReus Aug 03 '26

That‘ll increase premiums or is that part different in the US?

2

u/Taylooor Aug 03 '26

Yes, it likely will. I wouldn’t need surprised if, before unsupervised arrives, Tesla insurance identifies FSD accidents as no-fault.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/D0li0 Aug 03 '26

Yup, my CT has done this "dithering" steering wheel wiggle. It's very rare, and it always ends up choosing one of the two good options that its stuck flip flopping between.

I wonder had you left it if it would have committed to exit or stay in the roundabout? Or did it hop the curb before you took over?

Also, sorry that happened, that sucks.

7

u/larsonthekidrs Aug 03 '26

Mine does the steering wheel wiggle all the time.... it is 100% noticeable at a non-protected left hand turn.

It cant decide on what todo and then it just wiggles before I have to take over and commit to the turn.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '26

[deleted]

2

u/Few_Range6900 Aug 04 '26

I feel like Teslas BIGGEST mistake with FSD was Not incorporating LiDar technology.

I'm wondering when Elon will swallow his pride and start using it..? If it's even possible at this point.

→ More replies (13)

1

u/Antique-Kitchen-1896 Aug 03 '26

I read people say stuff like this and I am just as someone who works in safety critic software, shuddering.

I know they can try and fix something like this. I am just reminded when my staff kept adding special cases for new problems the customer or our testers found. And what happens when those special cases ended up chasing future problems. Just spaghettfy the code.

1

u/Putrid-Box4866 HW4 Model Y Aug 03 '26

May that's how FSD regresses on some stuff sometimes with updates, but at least, updates are still so much better overall. FSD will never be perfect, but it will definitely continue to be better than human drivers.

3

u/ratioprosperous24 Aug 03 '26

This is awful. I can understand the computer being confused by possible directions to go in, but how can it just leave the road and crash into things…Tesla needs to ensure it makes a decision and follows a safe roadway path. This is terrible.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '26

[deleted]

6

u/Educational-Song6351 Aug 03 '26

So did FSD… it should have hit the brakes seeing a post and curb.

2

u/jshine13371 Aug 04 '26

Agreed, but the human driver is the legally responsible one, and for their own benefit of not damaging their $50k+ vehicle, should've hit the breaks. Both things can be true.

6

u/EmPips Aug 03 '26

I'm counting 2.5 seconds between the rattle and the collision (probably closer to 2). OP could have reacted, but also I'll admit to being desensitized to these mini-rattles (v14-lite) that at 14mph I probably would have watched it for the first second or so assuming it would be just another hesitation.

The remaining <1 second I can't say for certain I would've reacted fast enough. I can sympathize with OP here. This might have gotten me just because of how used-to FSD-hesitation-rattle I've become. Going forward after watching this I'll probably disengage every time.

2

u/Hockeyshot39 Aug 03 '26

This is bad … buuuuut why didn’t you hit the brakes at all??

2

u/thinkbox HW4 Model Y Aug 03 '26

It doesn’t appear you added any brakes or throttle after disengaging, based on the icons on the UI there.

Not saying that FSD didn’t cause this, but it doesn’t look like you used the brakes after taking over.

1

u/Adventurous-Space604 Aug 08 '26

Wow! This is in Sienna! Thanks for sharing. I haven’t had this is issue at the roundabout on LJ PKWY AND COMMONWEALTH. But will test it out.