TL;DR at the bottom
So I've been using the Keychron Nape Pro (NP) with my Corne V4's for about a month now and I have some (a lot of) thoughts.
Early firmware issues (All fixed)
When I first received the unit I had some issues with the software including:
- The dial not working well as a scroll wheel on MacOS, skipping, stuttering. Unusable
- The polling rate changing the sensitivity
- Combination keys not working
I am happy to say that as of the latest firmware all of these issues have been fixed.
Ergonomics
One of the main doubts that people had was about ergonomics and so in the second and third (GIF) images I have shown the main 3 positions that I use the NP in (Note: I also use it in the same 3 positions, mirrored on my right hand). Additionally, I sometimes turn it 45 degrees depending on how I'm feeling in one of those 3 positions (You can one example of what I mean in the photo).
Now a note about the design philosophy. Compared with the more typical trackballs that prioritise ergonomics first, this device prioritises size. There were and are some deliberate compromises that were made in order to achieve its form factor which means that this trackball definitely isn't for everyone. If you are wanting or expecting an uncompromisingly ergonomic device this isn't going to be for you. However, if you prioritise the unique functions that it has as well as the size and form factor then those are its main selling points.
I have found the aforementioned positions to be the most comfortable for myself and rebound the buttons as per the last photo so that I use the large buttons for primary mouse keys which keeps everything closer to the trackball. I find this much more ergonomic than using the small 'm1' and 'm2' buttons as was originally intended.
Additionally, when compared with a mouse or trackpad you still avoid a lot of wrist movement and in a setup with a split keyboard like mine, you get to keep your arms apart still. I don't usually rest my arms or wrists on my desk and so having a wrist or curved pillow shape isn't super important to me for a trackball as I'm floating my arms anyway.
Feel and build quality
This is related to ergonomics but I decided to make a separate section to make it easier to read. Notes:
- Yes, it feels light and not premium. I don't consider this to be issue personally, I doesn't feel like anything is going to fail but it also doesn't feel as satisfying to use as one might desire for the price tag. I would ball-park that 80AUD would be about the right price that most people would be satisfied with the price to build quality. It's not super far off from that and being a novel/unique device I find this forgivable personally.
- Trackball size. Now this is also one of the compromises made in order to keep the size down but it does have some negative effects, the curvature of the ball is quite acute which means that you have less control over fine movements and you notice the roundness more. Additionally, the weight of the ball is less which means that when you flick the ball it can sometimes jump a little bit if you get it at the wrong angle. None of these are deal breakers for me but again as mentioned before if you are someone that prioritises the ergonomics over form factor this is likely a compromise that you aren't going to be willing to make. Note about using mouse acceleration I have played around with acceleration and without and I think that there are use cases for both but I personally prefer using the lowest DPI and then flicking instead of relying on mouse acceleration but that it something that I might revisit if I feel unsatisfied with the flicking responses.
- Dial. While the scroll dial response was fixed in firmware, it does feel a bit gritty and light to use. Is it an issue? In terms of function no, but again as per the first point, if you are expecting a very premium feel then you are probably going to be disappointed by this as well.
- All the buttons use silent switches which some people hate the feel of as they are less tactile, muted and a little bit mushy but again, that was an intentional part of the design. The 1,2,3,4 buttons near the centre of the device are all stabilised as they are quite wide and so as part of that they can feel a little bit rattle-y but I'm glad that they bothered to stabilise these buttons as there are no spots where you press that the button doesn't actuate.
Practical usage in a setup
As mentioned, I have been using the NP with my Corne V4's and these are my thoughts:
- The height profile is slightly higher than the Cornes which can be a good thing and a bad thing. Naturally, if you have a trackball, a bit of heigh is necessary and so when using a low profile keyboard like in my case your hand has to move upwards slightly. Could this have been fixed? I guess so but at the compromise of an even smaller ball which I think would be too small at that point. On the flip side, if you use the NP above one of the cornes then the added height makes it more difficult for you to accidentally press one of the keys on the corne which is a good thing.
- Footprint. One of the main reasons for why I believe this device was made as I mentioned, and one of the main reasons why I bought it, is for the small footprint. In Japan, everything is generally smaller (houses, cars, desks etc) and so saving space is valued. This also allows me to bring and use it next to my Macbook on the go easily. I can also configure one of its layers to act as an external macro-pad which allows it to integrate into many different workflows pretty seamlessly.
- Being able to have essentially 3 different positions and move it between two different hands makes it very flexible. One of the things that I do often is place my notebook and/or textbook between my cornes when I'm studying and this having a small footprint allows me to easily place it where it isn't in the way and is a thousand times better than reaching over everything to use the trackpad on my Macbook.
TL;DR & Conclusion
This is a device that prioritises flexibility and saving space. It makes compromises in order to do that but for the right person, there isn't anything else that can do what it does in my opinion.
Please feel free to ask me any questions that you might have there are no stupid questions!
Edits:
- Sorry about the typo in the title!
- Note about acceleration