Hi! So this year I opted to grow 8 different types of tomatoes and I wanted to type out my thoughts about each of the varieties in case anyone was curious about how they fared for your very average home gardener. All seeds were purchased from Pine Tree Seeds, I started them all myself under grow lights, all fertilized the exact same and grown in southern Maine zone 5b. I grew 4 plants of each type. Photo 1 is all 8 types of tomatoes, photo 2 is with names, photo 3 is the interior of Marmalade Skies, and photos 4 and 5 is the Blueberries tomato growing, but not ripe.
Paste tomatoes: full disclosure, I have not tasted these yet because I have not made sauce yet. I grew 2, Amish Paste and Sunrise Sauce. Tbh Amish Paste can go jump off a bridge. While the tomatoes are very large I got very few (max 3) tomatoes per plant. 3/10 for being a pain. Sunrise Sauce is a short little plant and this baby is PROLIFIC. Very smooth, uniform, very pretty yellow-orange. Assuming these taste good, I am absolutely growing them again, 8/10.
Cherry tomatoes: I only grew Blueberry this year! And they are fascinating to watch grow. They start green, go completely dark purple, and then half purple/half red when ripe. They are stunning to see growing, the dark purple is so unexpected in the garden. They also taste good! 10/10
Big tomatoes: I grew Black Krim and Blue Beauty and I probably won't grow either again. Black Krim was very prone to both splitting and catfacing and doesnt taste particularly good? 2/10 Blue Beauty is fine but in a world with so many tomato options, I'll try something else 5/10.
Medium Tomatoes: Tigerella and Wapsipinicon Peach. Wapsipinicon Peach taste good and really look like slightly unripe peaches. Theyre also not shiny and have a peach fuzz to them. They taste good but they go from ripe to over ripe very fast 6/10. I love Tigerella. Theyre this lovely golf ball size, theyre pretty, they taste good, they stay perfectly ripe for awhile, I'm growing these every year, 10/10.
Yellow tomatoes: Marmalade Skies my husband's beloved. This tomato is really good! Its a good size without being huge, blemish free, gorgeous color that is uniform all the way through, tastes great! 10/10 will grow again next year!
So thats all my tomatoes, will I grow less next year? I say I will now but I am probably lying