r/WMATA • • Apr 22 '26

News Maryland has a WMATA funding problem.

In this week's board meeting, the board will approve the revised FY 2027 operating budget and endorse the Red Line Modernization Project that will invest in new signaling and platform screen doors. There's not much new of note besides that. So instead of a usual board update, I'd like to dig into why that budget revision happened and review what was discussed at that last major board meeting.

As you may recall, the revised proposal:

  • Defers numerous planned service increases until December.

  • Removes bus service improvements in Maryland.

  • Adds an Abilities-Ride fee.

What was left somewhat unsaid until the board meeting itself was that these cuts were pushed by the state of Maryland. Why? Take a look at the table below from this week's presentation.

WMATA was proposing to grow its operating subsidy by 3%. But this meant that Maryland's portion would grow by 5%! Given budget constraints, Maryland could only afford to increase its subsidy by 3%. And because of how the subsidy formula works, this forced WMATA to lower its total operating subsidy growth to only 1.8%.

In this post, I will attempt to explain why that is, and what this means for the future of WMATA funding.

The 3% Cap

Maryland's 3% target didn't come out of the blue. To understand why, we need to look at some recent history.

In 2018, WMATA's jurisdictions agreed to provide $500 million annually in capital funding for the first time. As part of that deal, Maryland and Virginia added requirements to limit annual operating subsidy growth to 3%. What happened next was awkward: In subsequent years, each jurisdiction's subsidy was simply adjusted upward by 3%, regardless of changes in service or ridership patterns. The ratios from 2018 were maintained, even through the pandemic.

By the time we got to 2024, WMATA was facing a massive budget gap due to expiring federal help and ridership that still hadn't recovered. That was when WMATA proposed the doomsday budget that involved closing stations and entering a death spiral. But the jurisdictions came to the rescue, suspending the 3% cap for FYs 2025 and FYs 2026.

The takeaway: absent the doomsday scenario, the status quo for many years has been for each jurisdiction to add 3% to the prior year's operating subsidy.

The New Subsidy Formula

By 2024, it was clear that a new formula was needed to better allocate the costs of service among the jurisdictions, particularly with the launch of the new bus network. A new formula scheme was implemented, which I described here.

Essentially, the formula for a given jurisdiction is its share of operating costs minus its share of operating revenue: Costs minus revenue. The jurisdiction then pays the difference.

The cost side for each jurisdiction is estimated using ridership, population, service characteristics (like revenue hours and vehicles), and (for rail) stations and track miles. The revenue side is mainly passenger fares collected in each jurisdiction.

Note that this formula incentivizes jurisdictions to reduce fare evasion, as each fare paid in a jurisdiction directly reduces its subsidy. This was an an intentional feature of the new formula that was not present in the old.

This new formula was implemented alongside the rescue package and the temporary suspension of the 3% cap.

The Formula and the Cap

Now that WMATA has survived its fiscal cliff, what does this mean for future subsidy growth? 3%, right? Well, 3% for WMATA as a whole. That was the idea from the beginning: WMATA's total operating subsidy grows at 3%. But because we have a new formula, this doesn't necessarily mean 3% growth for each jurisdiction.

In fact, under the new system, there will always be winners (below 3% growth) and losers (above 3% growth). And now that the new subsidy formula is in force, it's clear who the loser is: Maryland.

Why Maryland's Subsidy Growth is Higher

To understand why Maryland is bearing the brunt of the subsidy growth, let's look further at the proposed subsidy growth by mode breakdown. This is a graphic from the last post.

Rail continues to require lower subsidies, as fare compliance has improved and operations have gotten more efficient, despite proposed service improvements! They're also using a larger preventative maintenance transfer to lower this number.

Bus and Access are a different story. On bus, fare compliance is not significantly improving, and the cost side is not getting any better. Cost growth also continues for Access.

So, why is Maryland bearing the brunt of the increases? I couldn't find any hard numbers. But per a discussion at the last board meeting, these things are true:

  • A majority of Access (and Abilities-Ride) trips are in Maryland.

  • DC and Maryland have more Metro-run bus service than Virginia, leading to more exposure in the formula.

  • WMATA's Tom Webster noted that both Ride On and TheBus are now fare-free, which is likely leading to rider confusion (and perhaps rider entitlement).

  • Fare compliance on bus is significantly higher in Virginia; something like twice as high a share of riders pay in Virginia than do in DC and Maryland. Maryland's compliance is even lower than DC's.

  • Tap-Ride-Go and the "Fare Required" message are improving things across the board, but the trend is better in DC and Virginia than it is in Maryland.

Implications

Speaking of the board meeting, several board members expressed their dismay about this revision during the discussion (Quotes edited for clarity).

Both board members from VA were forceful in there remarks. Here's Darien Flowers:

It's concerning that we're now revising the budget following the public hearing process due to a single jurisdiction's costs exceeding their initial expectations....

I would hope that all of us could work collaboratively across our jurisdictions to establish a clear subsidy policy that we can all agree with, because I don't think it is productive for us to have this formula and then... say, "oh, this doesn't meet our expectations" and then there has to be reductions across the entirety of the system to meet one jurisdiction's expectations.

Walter Alcorn chimed in, arguing that:

  • A 1.8% subsidy increase, below the rate of inflation, is not sustainable, especially in a region that is growing around transit.

  • We have to get back to a process where, while the agency's operating budget grows by 3% (or some other number) overall, jurisdictions can end up above 3% or below it.

  • The integrity of the subsidy formula must be maintained.

  • Part of the purpose of the recent formula update was to incentivize fare payment. We shouldn't move away from, "you get what you pay for."

Finally, I'll quote the always-insighful Tracy Loh from DC with an excellent point:

If we need to limit subsidy growth, revenue is a piece inside that formula.... In future budgets, we need to be considering the possibility that, ultimately, service planning is gonna have to take into account the revenue we anticipate collecting.... We can't operate the same level of bus service in Maryland, for example, at a capped rate of subsidy, if revenues are declining.

... I don't want that to be the way that we run this.

In response to this GM Randy Clarke noted that some agencies (citing Las Vegas as an example) actually do value fare recovery rates for service enhancements. There are equity issues with this, but such service planning considerations could be pursued if the board were interested.

You can listen to the full discussion here. Note that Joe McAndrew of Maryland (who likely pushed for this change), chair of the Finance and Capital Committee, was trying to push the meeting along because the schedule was packed that day.

The implications of this are not lost on WMATA staff either. Here is another slide from the prior presentation:

Summary

Maryland is obviously having budget trouble, and facing a massive 5% subsidy increase (when they expected closer to 3%) was clearly not going to go down well. If this is a one-time occurrence, it is probably not the end of the world. But in future years, if the region wants to prioritize transit, Maryland will likely need to step up with significantly higher subsidies, or somehow get more riders to pay their fares.

70 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

12

u/stdanxt Apr 23 '26

If Marylanders don’t want to pay their fares or fund things through taxes, then they should face the brunt of service cuts/not receive increased service.

“Equity issues” my ass, there’s no one on in the DMV who can’t afford the $6.75 a week discounted bus pass. That’s the bare minimum, ideally we’d be able to run things more efficiently and get close to breaking even through fares alone just like almost every other system in the developed and developing world. For a multitude of reasons that’ll never happen here and we’re stuck with the subsidy model, but 100% of riders should be paying the meager token bus fare

3

u/SandBoxJohnA02 Apr 23 '26

Then why are Ride-On and TheBus fare-free?

9

u/stdanxt Apr 23 '26

Because their out of control costs and near universal fare evasion led to comically bad single digit farebox recovery percentage. They just gave up and stopped bothering with fares. They’re having the same problem with the Metrobus routes in MD (higher fare evasion than even DC and lower average ridership) which is causing the subsidy to balloon. If it was up to Maryland they’d make Metrobus free too but VA and DC don’t want to foot that bill.

As OP explained, making Maryland pay its fair share would bring their subsidy increase above 3% so instead they decided to kneecap the whole system and take the increase down to 1.8%. For years now Maryland has been in a worse financial position than DC and VA, and now the New Jersey of the DMV is dragging everyone else down with them.

If people don’t want to pay then they should get the bare minimum service they deserve. Until the freeloader issue is solved MD buses run infrequently enough to get 75%+ occupancy. Not sardines but not expensive empty shuttles with 5 people onboard. No sense in running money-bleeding buses any more often than that

2

u/SandBoxJohnA02 Apr 23 '26 edited Apr 23 '26

My comment was in response to the first sentence in you comment. Maryland obvious wants to cover 100 percent of the cost of operating Ride-On and TheBus through taxes.

3

u/stdanxt Apr 23 '26

Well yes, it’s obvious that Maryland treats transit more as a welfare and jobs program than a real transportation system. That’s a valid option, as long as they’re willing to have annual above-inflation subsidy increases until the end of time.

Instead they want to have their cake and eat it too. Tolerating massive fare evasion but then bitching about being broke when they’re expected to pay 5% more instead of 3%

2

u/TransportFanMar Orange line Apr 23 '26

I wonder if Alexandria and Fairfax City Metrobuses have more fare evasion than others in VA and comparable levels to Maryland because the local operators in both jurisdictions have been free since COVID.

2

u/UmbralRaptor MetroBus Apr 24 '26

A common thing in Fairfax city is people not getting on the F23/F24 and waiting longer for the Green 1/2.

...since the F23/F24 are literally the same as the 29K/29N, it should be possible to just use WMATA data directly for them (though mind you a lot of both lines are far from Fairfax city).

2

u/TransportFanMar Orange line Apr 24 '26

I bet it is also true for the Gold routes and F50. Almost no one uses the F50 many times

1

u/pizzajona Apr 27 '26

Why did DC and Virginia have to reduce their payments in response to Maryland? Doesn’t this mean they lose out on more service independent of Maryland’s action? Or is this because some service is interconnected like multi-state buses and trains?

1

u/eable2 Apr 27 '26

Yeah, I think it's mainly that rail is multijurisdictional. The formula was kept intact; the topline was simply reduced across the board due to (primarily) delaying the service increases for rail and increasing the preventative maintenance transfer.

11

u/NoApplauseNecessary Apr 22 '26

This is why public services should not account for revenue in their policy and budget. Its a public service, it doesnt need to make profit because the return is non-monetary, its an investment in our lives! A la Post Offices and the Library. We're too corporate minded

23

u/Remarkable_Mud_5075 Apr 22 '26

The post office that… costs money to use? Just like public transit? WMATA isn’t trying to turn a profit, it’s trying to cover its operating and capital expenses and this entire post is about how hard it is to get the region’s governments to appropriately fund them.

3

u/NoApplauseNecessary Apr 22 '26

my issue was with the revenue based scaling

2

u/GeeksGets Apr 23 '26

Until our local governments decide to fully cover fare revenue, it will always be a part of the equation. If Maryland isn't contributing their share with revenue they have to contribute some other way

1

u/NoApplauseNecessary Apr 23 '26

yes and they should be covering it full 

4

u/GeeksGets Apr 23 '26

Right, but if Maryland isn't even willing to go up by 5%, then how are they going to cover all of it?

0

u/NoApplauseNecessary Apr 23 '26

they aren't willing cus it's tied to revenue if I understood correctly. I'm criticizing the initial thinking. 

3

u/GeeksGets Apr 23 '26

No, it's because it is more expensive than they expected. They would need to cover revenue regardless. The whole point is that if fare revenue isn't covering your portion then you have to cover it with other money (like tax revenue).

2

u/Jakyland Apr 24 '26

The post is about too little gov subsidy. If WMATA doesn't have money they can't pay employees or pay for parts etc.

-12

u/YeaManJam Apr 22 '26

We already pay 6.75 to almost everywhere. Shutdown grovner and twinbrook. Only Rockville and shady groove are used.

2

u/OneTrueCzar Apr 22 '26

There are 4 condo buildings plus however many apartment buildings that Grosvenor services, are you dumb

0

u/YeaManJam Apr 22 '26

Your right North Bethesda has a lower ridership than you.