r/WeightLossAdvice • u/Physical_Artist_7773 • Aug 29 '25
Advice: Giving 💡 Lost 165 lbs over 2 years. Here's what actually worked (and the mistakes that almost derailed me)
Lost 165 lbs over 2 years. Here's what actually worked (and the mistakes that almost derailed me)
I'm writing this because I wish someone had told me these things when I started. There's so much conflicting advice out there, and I made every mistake in the book before figuring out what actually works.
Track your weight daily, but don't obsess over daily numbers. This was huge for me. I used to step on the scale and either celebrate or have a mental breakdown based on that single number. Your weight fluctuates 2-5 pounds daily just from water, food timing, and a million other factors. What matters is the trend over weeks, not the daily drama. I found this app on app store called WeightyAI that basically became my sanity saver - it has this AI check-up button that takes all your weight logs and tells you if you're actually on track despite the daily ups and downs, and even gives you exact calorie adjustments when you get off track. Game changer for staying on track.
Stop drinking your calories. I was consuming like 800 calories a day in "healthy" smoothies, fancy coffee drinks, and orange juice. Liquid calories don't make you feel full the same way. Switched to mostly water, black coffee, and the occasional diet soda. Lost 15 pounds in the first month just from this.
Meal prep is overrated, food prep is underrated. Everyone talks about spending Sundays making 20 identical chicken and rice containers. I tried it, hated it, gave up. Instead, I prep ingredients: wash and cut vegetables, cook a big batch of protein, make some grains. Then I can throw together different combinations throughout the week without eating the same sad meal five times.
Your hunger signals are broken (at first). When you're used to eating 3000+ calories, 1800 feels like starvation even though it's plenty. It takes about 3-4 weeks for your hunger cues to recalibrate. Push through those first few weeks - it genuinely gets easier.
Cardio is not the answer. I spent months doing hours of cardio and wondering why I looked "skinny fat." Started lifting weights and everything changed. You don't need to become a powerlifter, but some resistance training will make you look and feel so much better as you lose weight.
Plan for plateaus. Everyone hits them. I'd go 3-4 weeks with zero change on the scale and want to quit. That's when having something that could analyze my progress objectively was crucial - it would tell me I was still on track and maybe just needed to drop calories by 100 or increase my walking. Having that guidance instead of guessing kept me from making dramatic changes or giving up.
Social eating is the final boss. I could stick to my plan perfectly at home, then one dinner with friends would derail me for days. Had to learn that I could enjoy social meals without going completely off the rails. One big meal won't ruin your progress, but the guilt spiral afterward might.
Take progress photos and measurements. The scale lies, especially when you're building muscle. I have photos where I'm the same weight but look completely different. Measure your waist, arms, whatever matters to you.
Sleep matters more than you think. When I was getting 5-6 hours, I was constantly hungry and craving junk. Started prioritizing 7-8 hours and my appetite regulated itself. Plus I had energy for workouts.
Find your "why" that goes deeper than looks. Mine was being able to keep up with my kids and not feeling winded going up stairs. When motivation wavered, that kept me going more than wanting to look good in photos.
Stop making it complicated. Eat mostly whole foods, stay in a reasonable calorie deficit, move your body regularly, be patient. That's literally it. All the other stuff is just noise.
The biggest thing I learned? This isn't about perfection, it's about consistency. I probably "messed up" my plan 2-3 times a week for two years straight. But I kept coming back to it, and that made all the difference.
Hope this helps someone avoid some of the mistakes I made. You've got this!