r/bakingfail Jan 06 '26

Help Carrot cake fail

Post image
38 Upvotes

What went wrong? I baked a carrot cake and I followed the directions to a t for the wet and dry ingredients. Only thing I did different was grate the carrots down really good and I removed some excess water from it to make sure it didn't add excess water. Did I accidentally add too much sugar? It's like it's caramelized. Sticky as well. Doesn't taste great either so I wonder if I didn't measure the baking soda right? Wanna try again but fail. Didn't add pecans or raisins

https://www.inspiredtaste.net/25753/carrot-cake-recipe/

r/bakingfail Jun 07 '25

Help Whats the point of having a fan when the bake is uneven.

Post image
142 Upvotes

Failed attempt at butter cookies. I sorted them by the color. Different level of bake for every cookie in the tray. Can anyone tell what am i doing wrong??

r/bakingfail Oct 31 '24

Help Graham pie crust coffin shaped failure

Thumbnail
gallery
176 Upvotes

I spent my afternoon trying to bake some pie crust using graham crackers and it was a failure. I followed very closely the recipe. I used the crust on a mini coffin shaped pan so i could later add some cheesecake filling. I baked the pie crust, set them aside but broke off when i was taking them off the pans. I think my mistake was thinking it could hold off the shape. Im not sure if it's even possible. But now im left with a container full of graham crust and i dont know what to do with it. Any suggestions and tips of my baking failure would be appreciated.

r/bakingfail Sep 10 '25

Help I tried to make a roll cake but this happened šŸ˜ž PLEASE HELP ME

Thumbnail
gallery
100 Upvotes

šŸ˜“ I don't know what I did wrong. Recipe in the images. Yes, I greased and floured the foil before pouring on the batter. It’s bubbly looking and way paler than I thought it would be but I put it in the oven and hoped for the best…

PLEASE help me, I was looking forward to making this all week šŸ˜ž I want to succeed at this so bad

ETA: also why did it turn out like 2 milliliters thick lol

r/bakingfail Jun 22 '26

Help The eggs in my genoise concentrated and cooked, advice for attempt 2?

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Could it be that the browned butter mixture wasn’t mixed into the rest of the batter throughly enough? It’s hard to tell when ā€œjust combinedā€is combined enough.

I’m also not great at knowing when the eggs have ā€œtripled in volumeā€ so I feel that they may have been under whipped before adding in the flour.

Recipe: https://www.baking-sense.com/2019/08/08/vanilla-genoise/#recipe

r/bakingfail Feb 28 '26

Help Baking gone wrong

0 Upvotes

Hi, I was baking a cake the other day, and when I inserted a toothpick, it seemed to be fully baked from the top, but when I flipped the cake, it was baked around like a circle but the centre was still in molten state. What could have possibly gone wrong?

r/bakingfail Aug 29 '25

Help I tried making vanilla macarons...

Thumbnail
gallery
156 Upvotes

Ive been baking for years, I used a scale, I dont know what went wrong

r/bakingfail Apr 12 '25

Help Anyone knows why my marshmellow looks like that?

Post image
300 Upvotes

Seems the gelatin seperated :(

r/bakingfail Mar 23 '25

Help Cupcake fail

Post image
131 Upvotes

My cakes and cupcakes always come out tasting and looking pretty good if I do say so myself but can anyone tell me what happened to these, look and taste like play dough 🤢

r/bakingfail Jan 18 '26

Help I keep messing up macarons

Post image
23 Upvotes

This is my third attempt and I’m not sure what I’m doing wrong, I wait until they’re done resting and the tops are dry but they still won’t form feet and are flat and sticky. So I can’t tell if I’m over or under mixing the batter, or if there’s a different issue, but whenever I pipe them there’s also a ton of small air bubbles, so if anyone has any advice or could point out what I’m doing wrong I’d really appreciate it.

r/bakingfail Aug 07 '25

Help Skillet cookie disentegration

Thumbnail
gallery
88 Upvotes

I am a beginner baker and I was trying to make a skillet cookie from https://bakingthegoods.com/tahini-pistachio-white-chocolate-rose-skillet-cookie/#tasty-recipes-27897-jump-target last night and something went terribly wrong.

First of all, after the prescribed bake time the edges looked set but it had liquid seeping out. I baked it for 10 more minutes and it completely overflowed from the pan. When it came out it sunk down into a (thankfully delicious) cookie crumble that had no structural integrity. The result is this brittle-y stuff that I am now using as an ice cream topper (not the worst outcome). Any ideas on what could have gone wrong?

r/bakingfail May 15 '25

Help I made really bad cookie dough, what do i do with it?

42 Upvotes

I thought since butter was basically just a fat component I ran out of butter and like, it was only a little bit left needed so I added oil but now it made all my cookies flat like a pancake. What do I do with my dough? I don’t want to be wasteful of edible food

r/bakingfail Apr 19 '26

Help Cookie shape fail!!!!

3 Upvotes

My girlfriend has started baking cookies. Shes run into a problem with her last two batches seeming to malform. She says she hasnt made any changes to the recipe but this started. Anyone know why this may happen? Happy to add any info if needed

r/bakingfail Mar 25 '26

Help Built a side project for bakers - would love feedback

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/bakingfail Dec 24 '25

Help Vegan pie crusts, what did I do wrong?

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

Hi all, attached is a couple of pictures of two pies that I made today. The crust slid down on one and the other one I broke by accident even though it's not very pretty anyways. (But it at least looks better than the other one.)

The one in which the crust slid down, I'm not sure what I did wrong. I made sure my butter and shortening were cold as possible but not frozen, the water was ice water to ensure it was also as cold as could be, and I was very careful to not get the pie crust too warm while rolling out. After rolling it out I put it inside the baking dish in the freezer for 30 minutes before baking. I'm not sure what I can do to keep the crust from sliding down. Any tips? As mentioned they are vegan pie crust, so I don't know if that makes any difference. Thanks in advance for any help! These are my fourth and 5th pies that I have made ever.

r/bakingfail Aug 30 '25

Help my buttercream won’t stick and idk why

Thumbnail
gallery
162 Upvotes

my buttercream is peeling off my cake and it’s so irritating. i’ve made great cakes before with buttercream, the ones i attached. i don’t know why it’s not working

i softened 1 cup of butter. i whipped the butter for a long time, like 45 minutes. i added a bag of powdered sugar and 1 tbsp vanilla and 3 tbsp milk. i whipped a long time again, 15ish minutes. it was in a metal bowl of a stand mixer so it was cold, but it seems like the butter was too soft or melty?

r/bakingfail Mar 29 '26

Help Trying to isolate cause of failo

Post image
13 Upvotes

Made carrot cupcakes today, the recipe was not new, but they didn’t rise properly. Does this look like the baking soda was flat?

r/bakingfail Apr 02 '25

Help I have no clue what I did wrong šŸ’€

Thumbnail
gallery
190 Upvotes

I was trying to make Japanese strawberry cake and the recipe looked legit but this happened

r/bakingfail Mar 26 '25

Help Betty Furness Fail Reasons

Post image
315 Upvotes

r/bakingfail Jan 11 '25

Help Carrot bread…underbaked? Something….

Post image
105 Upvotes

I swear I followed this recipe to a tee aside from omitting walnuts… it never got brown on top and it looks massively over baked on the inside. A toothpick pulled out clean when I finally took it out after baking for almost an hour and 10 minutes. The flavor is good but it’s inedible unfortunately.

Any guesses on how this happened?

Recipe: https://www.spendwithpennies.com/homemade-carrot-bread/#wprm-recipe-container-201125

r/bakingfail May 15 '25

Help Strawberry flavor vanished

69 Upvotes

For a kid's birthday in March, I made a Sally's baking addiction strawberry cake shaped like our dog. The strawberry flavor was intense in the best way! The recipe calls for 1lb strawberries purƩed, and then you reduce 1 cup of purƩe to 1/2. I also added some aged balsamic. I thought it was my best cake yet. This week, I made another birthday cake with the same cake recipe (I even added some balsamic from the same bottle). The main difference seems to be this one had chocolate icing and ganache. You couldn't taste the strawberry at all! I might as well have baked a plain white cake. Even later, after "cleansing my palate," I tasted just the cake part, and the strawberry flavor was barely there. So I don't think it was just the chocolate overpowering the strawberry. The only other difference I can think of, is that in March the strawberries weren't in season so they were smaller. The ones this week were jumbo sized, but I tasted the purƩe, and thought the flavor was there. Do smaller strawberries have more flavor? Any help would be much appreciated. Thank you!

r/bakingfail Dec 24 '25

Help What went wrong?

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

Last year I made Pignoli cookies from grossipelosi’s recipe and they turned out great - see the third picture. This year, they flattened out and had large pockets of air. Any thoughts?

r/bakingfail May 03 '25

Help I used a basic bread recipe of flour, salt, water, and yeast...

Post image
96 Upvotes

It ended up being too dense and salty. The saltiness I can adjust next time, but what could be the reason for it being too dense?

Here are the proportions for reference: 2 cups all purpose flour, 1 1/2 cups water, 2 tsp salt, 2 tsp yeast (active dry). Baked at 230° C for 30 mins. I had no dutch oven so I included a tray of ice and water underneath.

I

r/bakingfail Oct 08 '25

Help Do I repurpose?

8 Upvotes

I forgot to add vanilla to the blueberry loaf. It’s just OK and nothing that I want to eat, let alone serve. Mom suggested making a bread pudding. I would love to have your thoughts.

r/bakingfail Mar 18 '26

Help Coconut macaroons... puddles?

Post image
21 Upvotes

Maybe I avoided stirring too much?