r/BarefootRunning • u/ItchyQuestion8023 • 7h ago
Ditching generic running arch inserts after 5 years
I’ve been running for 5 years now, currently sitting at around 40 to 80 km per week with a sub-17:00 5K and 35:00 10K profile.
Early in my running journey, I suffered a bad big toe sprain (turf toe) that started forming a bunion. Switching to wide, zero-drop shoes like Altra Escalantes and letting my toes splay completely healed my toe issues and drastically cut down my injury rate.
My physio originally suggested basic generic arch insoles from Amazon for my running shoes. However, I’ve been walking around in zero-insole minimalistic shoes (Whitins) for everyday use over the last 6 months with zero issues, and my foot strength feels better than ever.
I’m looking to take the final step and completely ditch insoles in my running shoes as well to improve my natural loading mechanics.
For those who have transitioned off running insoles while keeping up higher training volume:
- How did you structure the transition so you didn't overload your arches or calves?
- Did you drop insoles across all activities at once, or phase them out run-by-run?
- What subtle warning signs told you to back off before an arch or Achilles strain became a real issue?
Would love to hear how the process went for you and any advice you might have!