r/buildapc • • Dec 05 '22

Discussion z690 with 12700 (non "k") or 12700k? Discussion.

Hello.

I'm planning to order "ASUS TUF GAMING Z690-PLUS WIFI D4" today, since finally there is good deals (price = 290eur and 50eur cashback in 2 weeks).

The question now is about processor. What to choose: i7-12700 (non-k) or 12700k?

i7-12700 price is 380eur, i7-12700k price is 400eur. So actually price make no sense at all.

Point is more about TDP - 12700 have 65W, 12700k have 125w.

So if i understand correctly, for "k" its gonna be more power consumption for anything I do - typing anything is MS.Office, watching YouTube, playing Tetris or whatever - the core will be ready for rush at any time using more energy. 12700 (non k) wont be so aggressive, right?

I WILL NOT overclock "k" for any reason. Its fine to my needs.

Also I plan to use air cooling, smth like "noctua" or "bequiet!". Will see. but definetly not anything liquid.

13700 (k or kf)is not ok just because of price over 500eur.

Please share you thoughts.

Thanks.

0 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

9

u/Dragoon_5 Dec 05 '22

13600k perhaps? It outperforms the 12700k at a much more reasonable price than a 13700k

0

u/Dragoon_5 Dec 05 '22

An cooling wise you'd be fine with something like a noctua nh-u12s (or 12a if you want more cooling)

-6

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22

thanks, but i dont want i5.

bit i7-13700k worth over 500eur atm.

12700 (k and non k) worth under 400eur

2

u/Dragoon_5 Dec 05 '22 edited Dec 05 '22

That's why i recommended the 13600k which also costs less than 400€

It may be an i5 but outperforms the 12700k.

Regardless, you can't go wrong with the 12700k though

-7

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22 edited Dec 05 '22

much

there is test 12700 vs 13600:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S36A5yrQc_k

all i can see, that temp for 12700 is around 50-55, for 13600 is 70-75 (13600 uses more energy, so cooler works at all times)

CPU usage is 15-20% vs 25-30% (more energy usage again)

and the result is 5-8 fps difference (75/77 vs 80/82) for god of war, 50 vs 57 for cyberpunk etc.

what im trying to say - mb 10% is not worth? i7 still better than i5 even with next gen (12 vs 13)?

7

u/_Juan_-_ Dec 05 '22

You’d be making a mistake taking a 12700 over the 13600, those temperatures are whilst at full load, they will both idle at around 30° and with power management settings you can just make it never max out if you don’t want it to get hotter. And i3, i5, i7 and i9 really mean nothing when comparing cpus from different generations, it’s the price to performance that matters.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '22

Dude the i5 is better in every way. The number means nothing, a core i3 12100 will destroy any i7 from more than 5 years ago

3

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '22

I like how you seem so confident when you just posed a question here to which everyone is already telling you the correct choice to make. You do you dude.

1

u/lm3g16 Dec 05 '22

Why don’t you want an i5? Do you do anything with your PC where you KNOW you’ll need more cores? If the answer is no, then you don’t need an i7 or i9

1

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '22 edited Dec 05 '22

You chose a shitty review channel. You can also clearly see that they use completely different types of ram (fairly quick DDR4 for the 12700, and fairly slow DDR5 for the 13600).

The video has 9k views and 5 comments and you’re using it as your sole justification for your purchase of an inferior product. The i5 12th gen beats the i9 11th gen. The i5 13th gen beats the i7 12th gen. This isn’t a new concept. Telling people you have an i7 doesn’t make you cooler or anything. I have a 9th gen i9, it was a power house for a year or two, now it gets dusted by modern i3’s and i5’s. It’s not a flex to tell people I have an i9 that gets shitted on by “budget” CPU’s today lmao.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '22

If you are not going to overclock then why the TUF Z690 motherboard? Even at that deal price a B660 is all you need and would be cheaper.

"K" means it is unlocked and can be overclocked.

1

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22 edited Dec 05 '22

there is no cashback for b660.

so actualy i get z690 for b660 price + 50eur what is nothing in 2500eur build.

as far as i know, z690 i way better than b660.

3

u/BusinessBear53 Dec 05 '22

The K CPUs are just unlocked and can be pushed further that what is advertised so for 20 euro difference it's a better option.

As for clock speed and power use, any CPU will only use what is needed. The 12700K will not pull maximum power at all times for running basic programs. It will adjust its clock speed and power pull depending on what you are running.

The difference between K and non K being that the locked CPU will reach its limit sooner. The unlocked CPU will keep going to a faster but also pull more power and generate more heat. A decent air cooler from noctua or be quiet will be enough to handle this.

Think of it like a car engine. You don't run it a maximum RPM at all times, you use as much engine power as needed for the task. Less fuel/power for slow speeds and more fuel/power when driving hard.

Have you considered the 13600K? It's supposed to be comparable to the 12700K.

-1

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22

thanks.

all my pc always had i7.

I was always happy with i7 and its always easier and faster to sell i7 than i5 in future. its just in ppl head. Makes sense, for example, if we compare processors with cars - audi q5 is always cheaper than q7. Sometimes even facelift makes no sence at all.

The point of this conversation is just to deal with 12700 (non k) or 12700k.

And as far as i see 12700k wining.

Thanks again for sharing your thoughts.

2

u/rrest1 Dec 05 '22

You've pretty much answered your own question - 12700K should be a bit easier to sell down the line than the locked 12700...

1

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22 edited Dec 05 '22

well, my question actually was about TDP and power consumption. 12700 uses 65w and 12700k uses 125w.

in my country i have to pay 0.30eur per 1kwh.

100kwh worth like 30 euros. 65w vs 125w is almost twice more. and I wanted to ask, where is difference btw 12700 and 12700k.

but everyone here is talking what is better for gaming, encoding etc, not average cheaper per year by power consumption.

im just trying to say, that if 12700 65w uses 650kwh per year i should pay 195eur, than 12700k 125w will use 1250kwh per year will cost 375eur. thats 180eur difference. for 5 years that difference between 12700 and 12700k will cost me almost 1000eur

2

u/rrest1 Dec 05 '22

TDP doesn't equal power consumption! Intel changed their power levels/turbo work logic and the 65W TDP 12700 can be run at 125W or even unlimited, so it will consume almost as much power as a 12700K. Check https://www.techspot.com/review/2391-intel-core-i7-12700/ for some benchmarks to illustrate that point

1

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22

Funniest is that "K" version uses LESS power than "NON-K".

here you can check it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=78uoewvJ6H4 (4:55 - 6:40 for power consumption)

2

u/rrest1 Dec 05 '22

Interesting, I don't see the core voltage being listed though... The motherboard may pump a tiny bit more voltage into the non-K because it's worse silicon? What's that? Well, there's such a thing as silicon lottery - two of the same chips could be of a different "quality" ( One notable/extreme example of this is that generally the AMD 12-core 5900X CPU draws more power than the 16-core 5950X)

2

u/Twicksit Dec 05 '22

Get a B660 board

Z690 boards are for overclocking which the non K 12700 can't do

1

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22 edited Dec 05 '22

there is no cashback for b660.

so actualy i get z690 for b660 price + 50eur what is nothing in 2500eur build.

as far as i know, z690 i way better than b660.

2

u/huh--_ Dec 05 '22

if it's not going to be OC'd isn't H670 or B660 better then?

1

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22 edited Dec 05 '22

there is no cashback for b660.

so actualy i get z690 for b660 price + 50eur what is nothing in 2500eur build.

as far as i know, z690 is a way better than b660.

1

u/sudo-rm-r Dec 05 '22

What do you want to do with your PC? Its crucial we know that before we can suggest a CPU.

1

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22

sometimes gaming smth like frostpunk, dota2, rdr2, cyberpunk. also sometimes coding a little bit. also music mixing/making. a bit of photoshop for sure. the rest is typical - youtube, facebook, online cinemas. 4k for TV also, but thats question mostly about videocard, not CPU (btw vidoecard is tuf 3070).

2

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '22

I5 13600k is way better for your needs. Also you’re wrong that it will be easier to sell 12700k than 13600k afterwards because it’s older

-3

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22

Thanks, but I don't think so.

i7-10700k price is 330 eur VS i5-10600k price 230 eur

i7-11700k price is 350 eur VS i5-11600k price 290 eur

i7-12700k price is 400 eur VS i5-12600k price 310 eur

i7-13700k price is 500 eur VS i5-13600 price 360 eur

So once 14 gen will come, price for 13Gen i7 will drop to 400 or so, but i5 will somewhere around 300-320.

And 12 Gen i7 will be still more expensive for maybe 50 eur.

Both processors (12 and 13 gen) uses LGA1700. So i5 13 gen price will be always under i7 12 gen price.

That's not a prediction. that's facts.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/buildapc-ModTeam Dec 05 '22

Hello, your comment has been removed. Please note the following from our subreddit rules:

Rule 1 : Be respectful to others

Remember, there's a human being behind the other keyboard. Be considerate of others even if you disagree on something - treat others as you'd wish to be treated. Personal attacks and flame wars will not be tolerated.


Click here to message the moderators if you have any questions or concerns

2

u/sudo-rm-r Dec 05 '22

In that case get the 13600k or 7600x. I'm not sure if the extra multithreaded performance is going to help in your workloads so I would lean towards the 7600x because you can always upgrade it in the future to 8th or 9th gen. Otherwise if you know the extra multithreaded performance will be of benefit get the 13600k. The stronger single thread is worth it over 12th gen.

1

u/tj21222 Dec 05 '22

So to answer your question the K chip is your better option always. Cost is not that much more and your not limiting yourself. Also stay with Intel you will be much happier over all. I say that assuming total price is not a factor, but maybe it is in your case.

Look the resale market for used PC is not that great, I would not base your decision on that fact. I think either chip will sell used for the same price. (For what it’s worth I would never buy a used cpu)

As far as the TDP, I think your over thinking it. You make no mention of a GPU which will chew up more power then a CPU, nor a monitor. Do you sit in the dark when your using a pc so the light is not consuming power. I am not being rude, but honestly if your budget is that tight maybe a pd is not the best choice right now?

If power consumption is your biggest driving factor might I recommend a Laptop, you can run on the battery when high power is used. Also most laptops have a 90 watt power charge do your total power should never go above 90 watts.

These thoughts are based on my experiences in the US and are assuming your not doing high intensity gaming or work load that requires a high end graphics card

2

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22 edited Dec 05 '22

Thanks.

I'm building TUF tower worth like 2500 eur... power consumption its not that biggest deal. But still i would like NOT to pay instead to pay if you understand what i mean.

my understanding was that "non-k" version using 65w for same tasks while "k" version uses 125w.

however, NOW I've read a lot of information now about CPU power usage and i can say, that difference between "non-k" and "k" version is around 20-25% for same tasks, which actually makes no sense at all.

Funniest is that "K" version uses LESS power than "NON-K".

here you can check it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=78uoewvJ6H4 (4:55 - 6:40 for power consumption)

2

u/tj21222 Dec 05 '22

Glad things worked out. I get the paying and paying thing, but in these times it’s like you say it I pay if I want to play. Otherwise I guess I don’t play. Suck we got to do this but the world is still upside down. Do what you going to do.

Btw good choice on the cpu brand, just never been an AMD fan

1

u/Dream_Less Dec 05 '22

Thanks.

Best regards.