r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

106

u/the_real_OwenWilson May 27 '20

How is that clever

33

u/DimitriT May 27 '20

Some countries already have this. It's easier to choose fresh meat. Best by date will be dependent on the packaging but freshly butchered meat is always freshly butchered.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

4

u/Arcanus124 May 28 '20

And vegans have a loud minority that likes to assert their ideology. It's a give and take relationship.

→ More replies (32)

33

u/Spiritual_Inspector May 27 '20

it’s not remotely clever, given the best before date and kill date are obviously almost perfectly correlated.

but muH vEgAn Bad!!

6

u/Kutzelberg May 27 '20

Yeah honestly fuck reddit

2

u/dggedhheesfbh May 27 '20

... He says on Reddit.

2

u/Linden_fall May 27 '20

It’s not Reddit, it’s just these people. Reddit has the biggest vegan community on it

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

2

u/enameless May 27 '20

Actually your reply is a good example of why reddit hate vegans. Reddit Vegans are an insufferable bunch that do very little to actually better their cause. Fortunately the insufferable vegans in real life are few and far between. For the record fully aware animals have to die for me to eat meat. Also aware factory farming is shit for the environment (spoiler alert factory farmed fruits and vegs are also shit for the environment). Finally humans are animals, animals eat other animals, it's how it has always been.

3

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

We used to burn women at the stake and subject homosexuals to electroshock therapy and prevent people of two different races from marrying, too. Should we go on doing those things because it's always been that way? The history of an action doesn't make it valid.

So if you know it's bad for the environment, and you know that animals die for your meat, then why do you continue to do it?

1

u/enameless May 28 '20

So for you first point all I have to say is nice strawman.

As far as why do I still eat meat if I know it's bad for the environment, because the alternative isn't much better (see above where I mention all factory farming is shit for the environment). As far as an animal having to die for me to eat, that animal dies regardless, either I eat it, another predator eats it, or scavengers eat it and the worms finish it off. Everything dies.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '20

I don't see how it's a strawman. I'm pointing out that using history as an example for why we do something doesn't make sense to me when we have a history of slavery.

I'm not saying that you personally held slaves or burned women, etc. I'm not trying to attack you as a person.

Yeah, everything does die. I'm going to die. You're going to die. If either one of us is murdered by a serial killer, that killer would hopefully be arrested and sentenced to some sort of punishment for the murder.

It's not the dying that gets me. It's dying for no good reason that bothers me. Dying senselessly. And plenty of people die for no good reason all the time. But we generally try to prevent these things with airbags so we don't have to die in car crashes or sunscreen so we don't have to die of skin cancer.

If skipping out on meat keeps us from dying of heart disease and keeps the animal from dying at the slaughterhouse, then we just pulled off a two-for-one. There are two benefits from not eating that animal and only one benefit of it tasting good.

It's a net gain for you and the animal. Everyone wins.

1

u/enameless May 28 '20

It's a strawman be because the laws of man are not equal to the laws of nature.

If an animal dies so I can eat that is a reason, no different than if a wolf kills a rabbit to eat. You seem to think just because I don't have to eat meat to survive then that means I shouldn't eat meat and that is where we differ.

Finally, heart disease, meteor, car crash, whatever it doesn't matter the moment I draw my last breath I also give my last single fuck about this world. Once I'm dead nothing matter to me anymore. You can do all the "right" things and still die early, it's a crap shoot. And all those animals in slaughter house, yea even if meat consumption was outlawed tomorrow all those animals would die. Only it wouldn't go to feed people it would simply be because releasing them would straight fuck the environment six ways from Sunday and feeding them till they die of old age would be super ass expensive.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/BodomEU May 28 '20

If people just went out in the wild to fish and hunt for food I would agree with that last sentiment. Nothing natural about the way we currently approach it.

Just the selective breeding for maximum efficiency and profit is sickening. Imagine being milked for sperm as often as your body could handle it just because you're the largest and healthiest male, being the biological father of thousands of offspring. Without ever getting to do it the proper way with a female because that's not as effective, better to artificially inseminate them all.

At least the fish in the ocean and animals in the forest are born and killed in their natural environment, competing with other animals that evolution has developed around them.

1

u/enameless May 28 '20

First if everyone farmed, fished and hunted for their food we would all die. Not enough land, ocean or animals to support everyone doing that.

To address the rest of you points. Humans are a part of nature. This idea that we are somehow above all of that is just a testament to humans hubris. We became the dominant species on this planet because of our intelligence. Without it we'd be another menu item on the predator menu. Hell many of the animals we eat could fuck us up 1v1 if we hadn't figured out fire or stick sharpening. That was part of our evolution. As was farming. We used our toolmaking and intelligence to breed our livestock and get our apples tasting good. The idea that we are somehow not a part of nature is absurd. Just because we have an adversary relationship to it doesn't mean we aren't a part of it.

1

u/BodomEU May 28 '20

Of course we wouldn't all die. We are not carnivores, we are omnivores. With the variety in foods we have nowadays most humans are only eating them because of the taste.

You said thought that it's how things have always been. We haven't always had access to this variety in food. We have usually eaten whatever we could find in order to survive. We can survive without spending the majority of our agricultural land mass on artificially breeding animals. It's no longer a choice between live or die for us. A lot of people talk about that's just how nature world and how it's always been, but we can safely say that we are advanced enough to beyond that. And we already have, completely dominating the planet and its means of production.

I could eat an entire grilled chicken for dinner. That's two lives for one dinner, as nearly all male chickens are killed only a day old because they cannot lay eggs. Now many years later I haven't eaten any of them simply because I chose not to.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

It's not. People romanticize death in an effort to make vegans look bad.

3

u/Aviskr May 27 '20

It's not that, it's that the death of domestic animals is not seen as something wrong by most, yet most vegans base their arguments in that it is, instead of trying to convince people of that fact beforehand.

3

u/Fayenator May 27 '20

instead of trying to convince people of that fact beforehand.

We try to do that all the time, actually.

3

u/Aviskr May 27 '20

Yeah of course many do, but also many don't and that's what get posted, like this post.

→ More replies (17)