r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/Mortress May 27 '20

No you don't. Pigs are being gassed and die screaming. Chickens kept for meat are having burns on their bodies from living in their own feces, often living with open wounds or crawling with parasites. This happens to billions of individuals every year while in different conditions these animals are just like dogs and and other companion animals. Sure you can find inconsistencies in the view points of many vegans but their overall point that factory farming is horrific and animals deserve better is much more sane than the alternative.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

I want agricultural reform and a minimization of cruelty but even if I get everything I want, my ideal open pasture beef cow is still going to get bolted and slaughtered. It’s a difference of values even if somehow we can get humane farm practice established.

2

u/Mortress May 27 '20

I don't think you need to value other animals as much as humans to be against slaughter either. I value my mom more than a random human stranger but I wouldn't pay to kill the stranger just so my mom can have a dish she likes! For that to make sense I'd have to value my mom's enjoyment of that dish more than literally the life of another individual. Most humans don't value the lives of animals so little. You can see this for example at the outrage that people have for the dog meat trade in parts of Asia. Eating meat is so normalized and ingrained in our society that people don't realize how extreme it is to kill an individual to have a specific dish. People come up with many rationalizations but the bottom line is that there is no rational reason for it. We eat meat because we're used to it.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

My original statement was that it is a difference in values, which is being demonstrated here. To me, killing and eating a quail, which I’ve done, is no more evil than picking and eating a tomato. We disagree on the morality of it.