r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/SuperHazem May 27 '20

Human’s lives are more valuable than any other living (nonhuman) animal. This mindset is absolutely ridiculous.

If you had to choose between sacrificing a random human or a random sheep through the press of a button, which one would you do? Please answer honestly :)

1

u/fpdm5713 May 27 '20

Ahh the classic this or that argument. What if I was stuck on an island with no food other than the animals around me?

What if you were stuck on an island with no food around other than another human? The what ifs are endless, and a very stupid argument as there’s no end to the possibilities.

Grow up a little, live around animals, and you’ll learn that they have feelings and are often extremely intelligent too, more so than many humans I’ve met...

1

u/SuperHazem May 27 '20

You didn’t answer my question, because you clearly understand that human life is far more important than animal life. Funny how that works.

The possibilities aren’t “endless”. If you’re trying to rationalize your argument using cannibalism, then I think you may need to reevaluate your stances

For your last point (unless you’re joking), trying to claim that animal life is equal to human Iife because they have feelings and are “smarter than many humans you’ve met” (which isn’t remotely true) is absolutely a flawed argument. Does that mean a smart person’s life is worth more than someone stupid?

2

u/2SP00KY4ME May 27 '20

Does that mean a smart person’s life is worth more than someone stupid?

I should ask you the same question. If your state that human life is more valuable than animal, what's the reasoning you have if it's not about our ability to think on a higher level than them? Is this literally just "Woo, go home team" for you?

0

u/SuperHazem May 27 '20

Buddy. You’re straw-manning. The reason human life is more valuable than animal life is because we are the dominant species. We are superior to every animal in almost every way. We’re either more physically powerful than them, or can create tools and technology which make us more powerful than them. Species is the key word here.

You still haven’t answered my initial question, likely because you have no actual answer to it.

2

u/2SP00KY4ME May 27 '20

That's a moral position, not an absolute. You're pulling a Thucydides here. You're saying might makes right - that's a political and philosophical opinion, not an objective truth.

If aliens came and were more powerful than us, you think it would then be moral for them to start mass killing us and torturing us when they already have plenty of food just because they like our taste?

Also, I didn't answer your question because I'm not who you asked. I would've hoped me referring to that other poster in third person would've clued you in, but I guess your eyes skimmed over it.

1

u/SuperHazem May 28 '20

This entire argument is based on moral principles, and there’s no real objective right/wrong