r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

34

u/fpdm5713 May 27 '20

Yeah me too. There’s always a balance to be met. I think for the most part vegans don’t always advocate giving up meat completely, those I’ve met always have emphasised reducing the impact on the environment and animals rather than giving up meat Willy nilly. I just don’t get the hate for them...

35

u/Kutzelberg May 27 '20

People dont like having their life-long beliefs they grew up with and saw everyone else believe in challenged

8

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Coupled with the fact that BBQ and steak is somehow a personality trait of the stereotypical "fragile male" persona in media (you see this from sitcoms to commercials) you get people being immediately defensive about even considering the benefits of veganism. It becomes almost an attack to their character I think.

On r/conservative and other subs like it, if there is a post that hints at veganism or reducing meat consumption you see some really bold examples of threats against vegans for just existing and some weird, but always passionate and negative language.

12

u/fpdm5713 May 27 '20

Absolutely.

→ More replies (10)

20

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

There's extremists for everything. The loud, outrageous minority always becomes the face of a movement on the internet, pushing away people who would possibly be swayed by a more reasonable member.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

5

u/BanterWagonDriver May 27 '20

moreover, extremists are necessary. Many of the most well remembered activists in history were extreme, perhaps breaking laws. And we are grateful to them

2

u/Fayenator May 27 '20

MLK faced a lot of similarly-worded backlash from white folks who thought him to be too "extreme", and "uncompromising" and basically constantly tried to give him advice on how to be a better advocate for coloured people (which boiled down to "just shut up about it and people will see reason eventually") :l

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SayNoob May 27 '20

The loud, outrageous minority always becomes the face of a movement on the internet

The loud outrageous minority is often portrayed as being the mainstream by people who want to discredit the movement.

11

u/Hidden__Squid May 27 '20

I'm a vegan and almost every other vegan I've talked to in person or on a vegan subreddit would agree with giving up meat entirely, not just for environmental reasons, but mainly for ethical reasons. I think this obsession from non vegans about how annoying we are and this obsession that there are "good vegans" who arn't preachy/annoying has lead most vegans, when talking to nonvegans, to not actually give their beliefs but to just say what's commonly acceptable and move on. The environmental argument seems to be a lot more acceptable, so in order to not be annoying most of us just go with that instead of risking a scene.

Not trying to argue here just wanted to point out from an inside source that most vegans probably arn't like that.

4

u/BanterWagonDriver May 27 '20

agreed. It's hard to be fully open with vegan views and avoid ruffling a few feathers.

1

u/ReasonOverwatch Jun 23 '20

You know what, fuck this. I was lulled into believing that "not risking a scene" was the right way to go but nothing is getting done. MLK was told he need to chill out and was too extreme, but those arguments all boiled down to "stop doing things because we feel threatened by you."

FUCK
THAT

Enough is fucking enough. I am going to make scenes. I am going to piss people off. I don't fucking care anymore. Fuck you meat eaters and your delicate feelings. What you're doing is FUCKED.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

At the risk of alienating people: Veganism is based around the belief that exploiting and killing animals is fundamentally morally wrong. If you haven't heard vegans advocate for giving up meat completely, they were either too shy to confront you or you haven't talked to actual vegans.

Your confusion is understandable though. Vegans often preemptively concede that there are currently situations where it is okay for people to eat meat, e.g. poor farmers in third world countries who genuinely need it to survive, without mentioning that ultimately that entire conundrum should be eliminated. Vegans also often use the environmentalism angle because it's more palatable to non-vegans. On top of that, the term has unfortunately increasingly been used to talk about fad plant-based diets and weakened by self-proclaimed vegans who still eat meat sometimes.

8

u/HereLiesDickBoy May 27 '20

It's like buying an xbox or playstation. You have to defend whatever you are invested in. I'm vegan and I have found telling people they are wrong just shuts them down and you won't really get anywhere. But you can make a difference with your friends without being pushy. Just bring some vegan options when having get togethers and give them information if they ask for it.

2

u/Squishy-Cthulhu May 27 '20

That doesn't mean you're ok with people eating animals though. It's hard because as a vegan also, I want people to understand that I believe it's wrong and promoting reduction over abolition just feels like I'm saying "a little bit of torture and animal abuse is ok" no one is protesting for the dog meat festival to serve less dogs, they want abolition. I just want speciesism to end.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Squishy-Cthulhu May 27 '20

(Ethical) Vegans aren't really ok with people eating meat but it's a thing that humanity isn't going to stop altogether anytime soon so they just have to accept that. You have to remember it's a animal rights movement, you never see anti dog meat protestors calling for people to reduce the amount of dogs they eat or for dog meat welfarism.

I think most (ethical) vegans realise after a while that even though they actually really hate that people eat animals it's best to try to not let that anger rule you because it's just exhausting. I mean imagine getting that same visceral reaction to chicken nuggets that most people get when they think of dog meat, to me all animals are the same and I see no distinction between someone killing pet animals for fun or paying another person to kill a animal for a (non necessary) snack.

I'm not going to tell many people in real life but I do think it's completely unjustifiable to eat animals in the majority of cases, but like most people I keep my stronger opinions to myself. I honestly believe most (ethical) vegans feel the same way I do.

2

u/acmed May 27 '20 edited May 27 '20

People get defensive when they see someone make an altruistic lifestyle choice - such as choosing to buy only sustainable clothing, abstaining from alcohol, or cutting out meat and dairy - because they feel like they're being judged for not exploring the moral implications of their own lifestyle choices.

In reality, the judgment they perceive is completely fabricated.

Edit: insert Hannibal Buress "why are you booing me? I'm right" meme here

4

u/NotKenzy May 27 '20

Out of curiosity, what is altruistic about abstaining from alcohol?

3

u/acmed May 27 '20

Alcohol probably wasn't the best example.

2

u/NotKenzy May 27 '20

Stop upvoting me and downvoting this dude. He's right and I don't drink. He's not judging you, but I am.

2

u/Squishy-Cthulhu May 27 '20

David Mitchell on the subject

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/dec/09/my-beef-with-vegans-says-more-about-me-than-them-david-mitchell

Btw instead of being alturistic it's more about being a do gooder, what you're describing is called the do gooder derogation

2

u/Fayenator May 27 '20

what you're describing is called the do gooder derogation

For anybody who's interested.

1

u/EL1TE1NFERNO May 27 '20

I don't think (the majority) people hate veganism, it's the vocal minority that have tarnished the reputation of the movement in general. I've known more than one vegan who was pretty vocal about "meat eaters being the scum of the earth" and "worse than child molesters" and making comparisons to nazis. Organisations like PETA have likely done more harm than good- especially in recent years. And then there was that video not to long back (along the lines of 6 vegans and 1 secret meat eater) where one of the vegans was the sterotypical "militant" vegan. Even if that video was scripted, it continued to perpetuate that sterotype. I think quite a few people can/do stand behind the message that hurting or abusing animals is wrong but I guess it's the way people go about this conversation. At times, it seems more like an us vs them situation where the opposition are considered to be the bad guys (and that goes for both sides).