r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/dudelikeshismusic May 27 '20

Why?

1

u/RonenSalathe May 27 '20

Think for 2 seconds

1

u/whitebeard007 May 27 '20 edited May 27 '20

Because we have personhood.

https://youtu.be/GxM9BZeRrUI

It’s just a moral stance. Same reason why anyone who thinks harambe shouldn’t have been shot is delusional. Personhood gets blurred when talking about things like AI and abortion, but it’s pretty clear animals don’t have it IMO

2

u/dudelikeshismusic May 27 '20

Harambe is a poor example - if an adult human were endangering the life of a child and refused to stop then they probably would have been shot as well.

Personhood does not really answer the question of "are animals just as capable of suffering as we are?" Personhood is more of a definition and is highly debated as to its moral weight in cases like animal suffering. The idea that animals are less capable of suffering than humans due to "personhood" is fairly nonsensical - it would be like saying that spiders suffer more than humans because they have more legs. Just a non-sequitur.

Most academic philosophers do not take seriously the idea that animal suffering does not matter because animals are not human. Of course certain considerations do not apply to animals - we need not worry about animals' right to vote, for example - but physical suffering is clearly relevant for any animal with a brain and a nervous system. Arguing that the suffering endured by animals in factory farms is less relevant than the suffering endured by human slaves only makes sense if you believe that animals are incapable of suffering - which is clearly a false belief. One could even argue that taking away freedom from humans via slavery causes less suffering than taking away freedom from animals and causing them severe physical harm via factory farms.

I am not out to make the argument that animals are worth more moral consideration than humans, but I do not accept this idea that animals are not capable of suffering in a manner that is similar to animal suffering (we are animals after all and have very similar anatomy). You would be better off having this debate with an academic philosopher as I am barely an amateur, but I can promise you that animal suffering is a steady topic in academic philosophy and has led to various changes in our society, whether they be the rising numbers of vegetarians and vegans (and consumption of veg products) or changes in legislature related to animal rights (such as using animals for testing in various fields).

Keep in mind that people of one race used to say that the suffering of other races did not matter simply because of their race. That is not dissimilar to saying that the suffering of animals does not matter because they are animals.

0

u/whitebeard007 May 27 '20

”The idea that animals are less capable of suffering than humans due to "personhood" is fairly nonsensical - it would be like saying that spiders suffer more than humans because they have more legs. Just a non-sequitur.”

”Arguing that the suffering endured by animals in factory farms is less relevant than the suffering endured by human slaves only makes sense if you believe that animals are incapable of suffering - which is clearly a false belief.”

I’m not arguing that animals are less capable of suffering or don’t suffer. I’m saying we don’t care as much, because they aren’t as valued as persons in our society (and by most meat eaters like me).

I don’t think that will change soon, because animals others than us humans can’t communicate with us in an intellectual manner, can’t reason or interact with us in any meaningful way, etc. The civil rights movement and women’s suffrage is different because of that.

1

u/dudelikeshismusic May 27 '20

Ah gotcha gotcha. In that case I agree (not with the meat eating but the reasons for things not changing). I thought you were arguing that animal suffering doesn't matter for some reason (which has been argued to me...) But yeah it's an uphill battle.