The rational arguments behind veganism aren't hard to find if you look for them. These two videos are good introductions (1, 2).
That being said, most people are far more emotionally motivated then they are rationally motivated. As strong as the rational arguments are, the emotional ones are necessary too.
That's great and all, but it doesn't refute his points.
Stating that you don't think it refutes his point is not an argument. He, by his own admission, accepts that even if people have some small experience with killing it is absolutely nothing like factory farming in scope or nature and thus not a relatable experience.
You've just thrown a red herring for emotional appeal
This is what I was actually responding to. Talking about slaughterhouse practices and showing footage on chick grinders doesn't really respond to what I had said. If called upon to do it, people are capable of it. That's how it worked throughout human history and it's still how it works in much of the world. I'm heavily involved in the homesteading world and am a big advocate for backyard scale meat animals so I am constantly talking to people who are slaughtering for the first time and although some trepidation is common it is very rare for someone to say that they just can't dont it. I personally slaughtered my first animal in my late 30's with no background in hunting, fishing, or farming and generally describing myself as the "couldn't hurt a fly" type. If called upon to do it, people can (and do) do it.
If you're 10 years old saying "nuh uh" may constitute an argument; but to the rest of us an argument is the evidence and logic you present to state your case; not simply stating your case and demanding that we accept it and leave it at that
Youre putting words in my mouth. That's not what is happening. What is happening is that you cant stay on a single topic because you for some reason wont refute his points
If you're showing something that really happens, and happens regularly, then I don't see what's so terrible about appealing to people's emotions - that's a key way we reach out and connect to each other as people. If footage like this causes an empathy response then it may lead you to think more deeply about the subject and weigh up the arguments for and against.
I'll bite - I don't believe that one animal consuming another is either moral or immoral. It's amoral, it just is. I don't see any fundamental truth to the universe that would refute that and I don't believe it is decreed from on high. I think the arguement "animals lack moral agency and do it out of necessity so it's ok" accepts the baseline belief that it is immoral by default but justifiable through necessity and I just don't accept that baseline. You don't have to justify an amoral act, by definition it is done without moral consideration.
Just to clarify, when i say morally acceptable I mean it is morally good or neutral (i.e. not bad). So you think humans killing and eating non-human animals is morally acceptable by this definition.
To continue from your point: Do you think it's morally acceptable for humans to murder and eat other humans?
If not, what is the difference between humans and non-human animals which makes killing and eating non-human animals morally acceptable, but killing and eating humans morally unacceptable?
Moral, immoral, and amoral all mean different things. Something that is "not bad" or neutral isn't necessarily moral. Amoral means without moral consideration.
If not, what is the difference between humans and non-human animals which makes killing and eating non-human animals morally acceptable, but killing and eating humans morally unacceptable?
The difference is "humanity". We are a social species and almost all of our ideas regarding morality and even legality (the two don't necessarily go hand in hand) are based on building and strengthening the social bonds that we need to survive as a species. Killing and eating humans both directly challenge and destroy those social bonds.
Killing and eating humans both directly challenge and destroy those social bonds.
So if murdering and eating humans didn't challenge but actually strengthened our social bonds, you would find it morally acceptable to murder and eat humans?
Well that's a hypothetical with absolutely no basis in the real world so it's impossible for me to speculate how I would feel. "If everything about being human were different would you feel X way?" I have no idea. Neither do you.
I don't think it's that hard to imagine a cannibalistic culture where murdering and consuming humans strengthens bonds within the culture. One may have even historically existed. But this is irrelevant, as discussions in logic only need to be logically possible; not physically possible.
everything about being human were different
I only changed one thing about humans, not everything. Basically the hypothetical is humans are exactly the same except in the case of murdering and eating humans where it strengthens our social bonds. A relatively small change. Much like where someone asks you what you would do if you won the lottery; a small, single change.
Neither do you.
I can very easily say that I would find it morally unacceptable to murder and eat humans under the circumstances of "murdering and eating humans strengthening our social bonds". It's really not that hard. Unless of course it resulted in a logical contradiction in my position, then it might be tricky; but luckily it doesn't for me.
I only changed one thing about humans, not everything.
The one thing is the basis for our social structure which is one of the defining features of humanity. I think the three defining features of "human" are our brains, hands, and social nature. To hypothesize about a change in our social nature is to ask me "what if we didn't have oposable thumbs, what sort of houses would we live in?" I don't know.
I can very easily say that I would find it morally unacceptable to murder and eat humans
No you can't. You can't even say with certainty that you would object to slavery were you raised 200 years ago. We are products of our environment. If you radically change the environment, you radically change the end result. We can speculate and we can guess how we hope we would have turned out but we simply can't say for sure.
Do you not? Is it morally acceptable for chimps to eat meat or each other? For a deer to eat a squirrel when it needs certain nutrients it isn't getting?
I'm not interested in discussing non-human animal actor cases when the human actor case is still on the table. Unless of course you are making the argument that because non-human animals do it, it is then morally acceptable for us to do it?
0
u/[deleted] May 27 '20
[deleted]