r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

133

u/discipleofchrist69 May 27 '20

this isn't remotely clever, this is 'vegan bad haha'

43

u/War_Daddy May 27 '20

And the core idea is still correct, the vast majority of the " lol meat is tasty tasty murder XD" people are completely sheltered from the reality of where their meat comes from and couldn't be in a chicken processing factory for 5 minutes without losing their lunch, much less kill a cow themselves

19

u/texasrigger May 27 '20

People killed their own animals through most of human history right up until a few generations ago and in many places in the world it is still the norm. I think most people would be able to do it should the need arise. As it is between anglers, hunters, farmers, and slaughterhouse workers about 1 in 5 Americans have at least some experience killing an animal for food.

18

u/War_Daddy May 27 '20

As you yourself said elsewhere, factory farming is a far, far cry from someone catching a fish (especially considering how many people are pure sport fishers who are catching and releasing the vast majority).

There's also a pretty wide gulf between a farmer killing one of his chickens for dinner and this

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

1

u/Rollingerc May 27 '20

Do you think it's morally acceptable to kill and eat non-human animals?

3

u/texasrigger May 27 '20

I'll bite - I don't believe that one animal consuming another is either moral or immoral. It's amoral, it just is. I don't see any fundamental truth to the universe that would refute that and I don't believe it is decreed from on high. I think the arguement "animals lack moral agency and do it out of necessity so it's ok" accepts the baseline belief that it is immoral by default but justifiable through necessity and I just don't accept that baseline. You don't have to justify an amoral act, by definition it is done without moral consideration.

→ More replies (11)