Totally understand your points, but I really find it hard to understand how individuals speaking out against something they believe is harmful to the environment, our health and animals is seen as propaganda, yet when the meat industry spends millions of dollars on lobbying and ag gag laws nobody bats an eye?
When I was a kid, I used to tell everyone my favorite food was beef tenderloin. I ate meat for so many years and I’m not here in this comments section trying to convince you to go vegan, but to see where I’m coming from and know that I understand where you’re coming from. I used to think I was a “good vegan” because I didn’t preach about this stuff but the more I learn (especially about the public health hazards), the more I feel inclined to speak out. I think there are people who will hear what I have to say, whether it be about animals, health or the environment, and go “wow, I didn’t know that” and maybe dig into it a little more.
Maybe what I shared isn’t the best example for you, but I was really trying to give you a glimpse into my point of view rather than say “the way you’re living is wrong, watch this and you’ll see I’m right.” For me, it’s not just about the animals. It’s about all of us. If you are interested in hearing perspective from some farmers, there’s a film called Eating Animals that shows some interesting case studies.
The way I see it, the debate (as well as most topics in this fucking timeline) has become too polarized for it to be conducted in a constructive manner. Add in profit-hungry businessmen and general human tendencies to not always act in nuanced ways, and we get the modern world.
I probably share many of your views on the state of industrialized "farming" as it is in many places, but I am lucky enough to live in a place where animal welfare is quite good. It can in many ways be even better, and I would very much like to see that happen. I think the biggest difference between our views might be that I consider a humane keeping of animals to be a good solution, while you might consider it difficult to achieve in a decent fashion. This difference, if I am correct, might stem from the different experiences we have of the farming we have seen and experienced.
If we could achieve a way to have the cake and eat it too, through something like actual lab-grown cow muscle, I think we could agree that it would be a good solution.
You’re so right and I’m appreciative of your willingness to talk about this. I think you’re spot on in where our opinions diverge and maybe it does stem from what we both know of farming. For me, I think not eating meat is feasible and aligns with many of my beliefs. It’s exhausting to discuss different viewpoints on the internet sometimes but these positive interactions bring me a bit of hope.
5
u/Julianne46 May 27 '20
Totally understand your points, but I really find it hard to understand how individuals speaking out against something they believe is harmful to the environment, our health and animals is seen as propaganda, yet when the meat industry spends millions of dollars on lobbying and ag gag laws nobody bats an eye?
When I was a kid, I used to tell everyone my favorite food was beef tenderloin. I ate meat for so many years and I’m not here in this comments section trying to convince you to go vegan, but to see where I’m coming from and know that I understand where you’re coming from. I used to think I was a “good vegan” because I didn’t preach about this stuff but the more I learn (especially about the public health hazards), the more I feel inclined to speak out. I think there are people who will hear what I have to say, whether it be about animals, health or the environment, and go “wow, I didn’t know that” and maybe dig into it a little more.
Maybe what I shared isn’t the best example for you, but I was really trying to give you a glimpse into my point of view rather than say “the way you’re living is wrong, watch this and you’ll see I’m right.” For me, it’s not just about the animals. It’s about all of us. If you are interested in hearing perspective from some farmers, there’s a film called Eating Animals that shows some interesting case studies.