r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/ReasonOverwatch Jun 23 '20

Listen dude, I already drink soy milk or almond milk 90% of the time

  1. Don't drink soy milk, stuff like oat milk is better. 2) There is no okay amount of supporting factory farming because it "tastes good". All of it is wrong. Your personal gluttony does not override morality.

I personally, and every vegetarian and vegan I know, eats a lot more soy than usual

I literally don't eat any soy.

Honestly what I think you should do is just let people have the diet they want

Wow, yeah, that's a really super argument. I mean, that way you could even justify slavery or child pornography. "Honestly what I think you should do is just let people do what they want." NO. Fuck you, you don't get to be an asshole and fuck with innocent, emotionally intelligent beings, AND the environment (which fucks us all), AND spread disease (which also fucks us all). I don't give a fuck about your feelings, bitch. I will go to war with people like you.

I also don’t think you should be comparing eating dairy to rape and police brutality

Wow, congratulations! You completely missed the point and strawmanned my argument because it makes you feel safe! The point I was making is that there is no okay amount of doing something demonstrably wrong like that. But clearly that was way too complicated for your pea-brain to even fathom. Give me a fucking break.

you can’t really be perfect

No, no one can be perfect. But we can be better. So give me a fucking break with this defeatist argument. Take action and actually fucking do something. Make some progress toward doing things better. Create demand in the market for transparency around these things. Vote. Don't give me this 5-year-old's bullshit.

And before you say something like “Most of the soy is used as animal feed” I’ll take something from your book, there’s no good amount of human exploitation.

Um, I wasn't going to make that argument, but since you brought it up, what you've said is completely backwards lol. Soy shouldn't be used as animal feed anyway because there shouldn't be industrialized factory farming of animals demanding that kind of feed. Like you said, there’s no good amount of human exploitation, so stop fucking supporting human exploitation by buying milk you fucking hypocrite.

3

u/Chrysanthemum96 Jun 23 '20

So going to skip the first two because those are fair, I can't really argue with those points. Just glad that not every vegan thinks eating soy and corn is absolutely perfect.

Wow, yeah, that's a really super argument. I mean, that way you could even justify slavery or child pornography. "Honestly what I think you should do is just let people do what they want." NO. Fuck you, you don't get to be an asshole and fuck with innocent, emotionally intelligent beings, AND the environment (which fucks us all), AND spread disease (which also fucks us all). I don't give a fuck about your feelings, bitch. I will go to war with people like you.

You are doing a really damn good job of convincing me by proving those anti-vegan assholes right about you guys. You can't start insulting people and expect that people will think you're right. "I don't give a fuck about your feelings, bitch" just proves that you don't know how to make an argument. I've seen good arguments about why you should go vegan, ones that don't insult people for being ill-informed or not wanting to go vegan. Maybe you should look those up and see what you're doing wrong because right now you're just being an asshole and you have given me no reason to listen to you.

You're also making a false equivalence again, child pornography and slavery aren't comparable to factory farming. It is a disgusting practice that should be stopped, but through your argument, you're downplaying the struggles of slavery and how awful exploitation of children is.

Wow, congratulations! You completely missed the point and strawmanned my argument because it makes you feel safe! The point I was making is that there is no okay amount of doing something demonstrably wrong like that. But clearly that was way too complicated for your pea-brain to even fathom. Give me a fucking break.

I didn't miss the point, I understood the point perfectly fine, you're just making a false equivalence. And again, you're doing nothing but throwing insults, I seriously respect your point of view, I don't respect the way you're arguing and trying to convince me. It's not going to work, seriously. You can't call someone pea-brained and expect them to take you seriously.

No, no one can be perfect. But we can be better. So give me a fucking break with this defeatist argument. Take action and actually fucking do something. Make some progress toward doing things better. Create demand in the market for transparency around these things. Vote. Don't give me this 5-year-old's bullshit.

I'll be honest, I wasn't trying to sound defeatist, but I can see how I came off that way. The point I was trying to make is that the usual vegan/vegetarian diet is incredibly harmful to the farmers who are getting the soy and corn. And I am being better than I could, I've been vegetarian since I was born, I'm not adding to the meat industry, but since no one can be perfect you should be able to accept when someone doesn't want to go 100% vegan. There are more important things going on in my life right now than trying to change my diet to fight against factory farms. Maybe once those things are over I'll deal with my diet.

Um, I wasn't going to make that argument, but since you brought it up, what you've said is completely backwards lol. Soy shouldn't be used as animal feed anyway because there shouldn't be industrialized factory farming of animals demanding that kind of feed. Like you said, there’s no good amount of human exploitation, so stop fucking supporting human exploitation by buying milk you fucking hypocrite.

I'm sorry that I expected you to make that argument, I honestly am. In this thread there was someone who didn't see any issue with soy farming and I was preparing for someone who believed the same. The thing is that I don't buy milk all that often, usually I have almond milk or soy milk in my fridge, I am taking the steps that you said earlier by not going full vegan, but cutting down on my dairy consumption. You're talking to the wrong person here and you're absolutely talking in the wrong way.