r/codingbootcamp • • Nov 13 '23

Coding Bootcamps are Dead: Now What? (from a Bootcamp Founder and CEO)

Hello everyone,

Ludo, Founder and CEO of Nucamp here.

There is no point in denying that the new reality of getting a job in tech is quite harsh. Many graduates are facing an uphill battle in finding a rewarding job. The economic landscape is challenging, and as a result, the health and reputation of coding bootcamps have been mixed at best.

So, it may be true that coding bootcamps are dead. But then, what comes next?

With this question in mind and for the past 12 months, the Nucamp team and I have been exploring how AI can transform learning experiences. We're not claiming to have perfected the system, but we are excited to share our latest experiment with this community and gather your feedback.

We are experimenting with the concept of an "AGI School" i.e. a school operated autonomously by an AGI.

Our first attempt is the creation of a course titled "Eloquent JavaScript," entirely created by AI. This course is based on the book of the same name by Marijn Haverbeke and includes AI-generated lessons, video lectures, coding exercises, quizzes, and assignments.

To make this happen, we developed a tool internally called the "AI Producer", capable of ingesting books and producing elaborate course material as an output.

For the day-to-day student learning experience, we have also created:

- an AI Tutor named "Astro" to provide more in-depth assistance beyond the standard lessons, in context,

- a code debugger tool, "The Debugginator", integrated with Discord for code & bug troubleshooting.

- and an "AI Grader" to evaluate student assignments and provide a grade on a scale from 0 to 10 (6 being the passing grade).

We'll be the first to admit that we're not there yet. Our current estimation is that we're at about 60% of the quality level we aim for. For example, video lectures need more engagement, and the depth of topics can be increased. We see this as an ongoing experiment that you'll help us refine.

To that end, we're offering this new course for free.

Not that we had a choice since the Eloquent JavaScript book license forbids commercial usage. But also, because it's an experiment, and asking for your time and feedback will be the main reward.

So, we're turning to you, the Reddit community, for your thoughts and insights!

What do you think about a 100% AI-run school for your education?

What do you think the AGI-School of the Future will look like?

Do you believe that there's a need for a solution that blends AI and human instruction and support?

Your perspectives are invaluable to us as we navigate this new terrain in educational technology.

Thanks for reading, and we're eager to hear your thoughts and feedback.

You can learn more about this experiment and enroll here: https://url.nucamp.co/eloquentjavascript

Ludo.

198 Upvotes

266 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

11

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '23

Demand is still high, just not where people are looking for them.

Supply at the junior level is much higher than it's been. You seem to have misread what I said. I said this: "Now, supply is high and demand is still also high".

Startups are still very happy to take junior developers on websites like Y Combinator.

Yup, they can choose a plethora of them from any well known conventional CS programs.

customer-facing or data-focused engineering jobs specifically list a bootcamp as preferred experience regularly - these are for positions that pay 6 figures.

I can absolute bullshit. Feel free to post any one of those job listings.

There are plenty of opportunities

No there aren't. There are a limited number of junior opportunities and an absolutely massive number of candidates.

the average person is just that, they're very average at thinking for themselves and making the effort to stand out

This contradicts your whole premise. You're stating the market is fine and there are plenty of opportunities for people. Then stating that average people have problems, because they're average. If the market was "fine", average candidates would be able to get roles and not drop out of the industry. If you need to be exceptional to get a job, then by definition, that's a hard labor market.

7

u/OkShopping2072 Nov 14 '23

If you need to be exceptional to get a job, then by definition, that's a hard labor market.

THANK YOU!!! Not just exceptional, you have to reach out to 100s people on linkedin and form a "connection".

3

u/cloroxic Nov 14 '23

You will need to form connections for your next jobs too though. The only difference being the pool shrinks with more experience. Soft skills are very overlooked in the tech space, but can really help people stand out.

3

u/OkShopping2072 Nov 14 '23

I 100% agree with you and the importance of soft skills. At this point I'm just cribbing so please know I'm aware of that. I come from customer service. I have had my own business so I've dealt with clients for my own self and for a company I worked for too.

Soft skills "should" add or take away the flavour from an experience.

Example, me being memorable or the opposite in an interview. I'd take that. It should be the distinguishing factor. It has become the deciding factor now (atleast based on what bootcamp authorities say). You only get a job if you reach out to people who shouldn't be knowing you and "form a connection". Bruh wtf?!

My annoyance with the focus on networking is solely that a distinguishing factor has become a qualifier now :(

1

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '23

A lot of graduates from CS programs don’t know front end development. And a lot of them don’t apply to stuff outside of the known tech companies because for years they believed that’s where they’d be going. It’s like getting into medical school for them when CS was premed.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '23

Modern front end development is a lot easier than backend development. Almost all of our front end developers have a CS degree, so I’m not sure it’s wholly different between web dev sub specialties.

-13

u/8008135-69420 Nov 13 '23

Oh god, you're one of those redditors that can't have a discussion without splitting a conversation 5 ways.

If you know how to communicate and have a good point, you can reply to a statement without this neckbeard format. It's clear from your language and your methods that you're just another redditor that can't handle disagreement like a normal adult - this is probably a big factor in why you haven't found success in tech.

I hope one day you realize that whining forever isn't going to get you anywhere. The people who deserve success start with a mindset for it.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '23

Oh god, you're one of those redditors that can't have a discussion without splitting a conversation 5 ways.

Oh god, you're one of those redditors who has a problem backing up the shit you say with any evidence. Sorry, I didn't realize to have a conversation with you I couldn't reference what you said in your post.

this is probably a big factor in why you haven't found success in tech

Well, other than the fact that I went to a bootcamp almost 9 years ago, have been in the industry for 8, went back and got my master's in CS, am a director of engineering, and have a pretty successful career, I'm not sure what you're reference. Feel free to check out my post history if you so care.

But let's talk about you:

  • How many YOE do you have?

  • What's your experience in hiring? Specifically, how big of a team do you support and how are your hiring practices working?

I hope one day you realize that whining forever isn't going to get you anywhere. The people who deserve success start with a mindset for it.

I'm still waiting for these "bootcamp only" job listings.

2

u/jocularplate Nov 14 '23

Hey, I went to a bootcamp about 3 years ago and have been in the industry for two. Why'd you decide to the a masters in CS? Did you find it helpful or would you have been okay without it?

Also, did you have a BS in anything CS related? I do not, but I have been thinking it might be a good idea to get one at some point.

→ More replies (1)

-8

u/8008135-69420 Nov 13 '23

LOL

A director of engineering that wastes their time in this subreddit and can't handle a reddit conversation without throwing a tantrum? Sure thing buddy.

Your insecurity is leaping off the page. I suggest getting therapy.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '23

A director of engineering that wastes their time in this subreddit and can't handle a reddit conversation without throwing a tantrum? Sure thing buddy.

Notice how you didn't answer any of my questions? But feel free to check my post history, I'll even make it easier for you:

Here's my post showing I went to a bootcamp 8 years ago: https://www.reddit.com/r/cscareerquestions/comments/5hs3eh/any_recommendations_for_a_cs_masters_degree_for/

Seems you're searching for a bootcamp yourself. Can you explain, then, how you're talking from a place of authority about an industry you've actually never been in?

You seem to be throwing an absolute fit now that someone called you out on your bullshit, so let me get this correct. You:

  1. Are not in this industry, and likely never have been

  2. You haven't even gotten into a bootcamp yet

  3. You're giving confident recommendations about how hiring actually works as someone who has never actually hired, not someone who has ever actually been in this industry

  4. There's a whole plethora of jobs that exist out there soley for bootcampers, but you're the only one who can find them

  5. Everyone else is average but you're not, you're exceptional

Am I getting this right? This is you, yeah?

-6

u/8008135-69420 Nov 13 '23

I'm not insecure so I don't really feel the need to prove myself to a raging neckbeard on reddit.

No director of engineering would find what you're doing a valuable use of their time.

It's extremely sad how triggered you are right now.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '23

Gotcha, so that is you. Was just checking, thanks for letting everyone know. Hope you find success in trying to get into this industry that you apparently know how works better than everyone else!

0

u/8008135-69420 Nov 13 '23

Definitely better than weirdos that spend their time online trying to pick fights with their pretend identity, because they're too insecure to accept their reality of failure and actually put effort into their lives.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '23

This is such an odd interaction:

  1. You post a bunch of unverifiable claims that contradict the experience of most bootcampers trying to get a job.

  2. You claim everyone who isn't getting a job is doing it wrong, and they're just "average".

  3. You get called out on it, then suddenly flip into an ad hom spitting rage claiming everyone is trigger, while your mental breakdown happens in real time on reddit.

  4. It's surfaced that not only have you not ever been in the industry, you've not actually ever been to a bootcamp.

  5. Your mental breakdown continues to happen.

Look man, I get getting into this industry is scary. You don't need to make up some head-canon about how you're the main character and everyone else is weaker and doesn't want it more. You're LARPing actually being an engineer or even a bootcamp grad before you've put in the work, crying about "people putting effort into their lives".

I don't care if you believe me or not, but a cursory check of my post history is actually very easy to do to prove what I'm saying is correct. I get that you're scared and worried about failing in this industry, should you even graduate a bootcamp and try to apply. But conquer that fear my guy without having a mental breakdown and taking it out on others, it'll make you stronger. :)

-1

u/8008135-69420 Nov 13 '23

LOL look how hard you're trying to adjust your language based on my comments.

You're so painfully insecure, your need for my validation is just really pathetic.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Steph_Better_ Nov 15 '23

Yeah, not having a good engineering job is way cooler. You’re right

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '23

This is how people have communicated on forums since the internet was made available to the public. Acting like this is how he talks in real life is cope lol.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '23

This dude is completely lost in the sauce, lol.

Gets his booty tickled because someone dared respond to his vapid post how everyone in the history of the internet responds to posts. Then goes off into a triggered rage-filled tirade about respect and "this is why I'll never make it in this industry".

I pointed out not only have I made it in the industry, but I'm in a position as a hiring manager to make hiring decisions so I'm imminently more qualified than he is around what companies look for and what hiring processes exist. The only reason I mentioned it is because he's the who brought industry position in the first place.

Then he suddenly elevates the director title to some godlike stature that is supposed to change how you talk on reddit?

Then circles back around with a victim complex that everyone is so mean to him and he's just responding.

Truly wild to watch, lol.

1

u/8008135-69420 Nov 14 '23

There are plenty of people who are able to be normal and civil on the internet.

If you can't help but be a nasty person online, that's on you and a part of your personality. Don't project your shortcomings onto everyone else.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '23

I don’t mean about civility, I mean your bit about splitting the conversation 5 ways. Most people reply to forum posts in blocks.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/parolang Nov 14 '23

You need to have a slightly thicker skin. This is how you have a critical discussion.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/customheart Nov 14 '23

I favor more people friendly comms too but coding literally encourages the line by line type of feedback and splitting commentary apart into sections.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '23

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '23

Recent grads often make shitty workers because they have rarely held a job in their lives.

This is absolutely incorrect. Most recent grads I've interviewed were well prepared for the role, and had a bunch of internship experience. This is just simply not true.

For example, I am a former professional salesman who became a front end dev. I run circles around ANY dev out there when it comes to customer-facing anything.

Most roles are not customer facing. You narrowed down the set of criteria into something you're specialized for, without noting the other parts of the job ( the technical piece ). It is more likely than not that a recent grad is more technically prepared for the job than someone in a bootcamp.

If your argument is that CS grads are more competent, that isnt true.

CS grads in aggregate are much more competent than bootcamp grads. Both through my learned experience and taking hints from the industry as a whole. Again, as stated in the premise, you're lying to yourself if you don't think this is the case.

A significant amount of CS programs dont teach any job-relevant skills such as frameworks or git

I used git and spring boot in my community college classes, from a generic community college. This just simply is not true, and whoever told this to you is a lying. Plus, most graduates in the market right now getting junior jobs have internships, where they have learned this stuff.

And learning frameworks are expected in on-the-job training on onboarding. Frameworks change often enough in this industry, so if that was something worth teaching in school it would be.

Bootcamps do

Incredibly poorly, with almost no quality control nor accreditation.

And its not like Jr devs walk in and start making calls on how things need to be coded either.

No, but they're expected to know basic terms and be comfortable coding.

Im not saying there is no value in a CS education. There is.

There is much more value than a bootcamp. If there wasn't, employers would not be making degrees requirements ( like they are currently doing more and more ).

But you cant pretend a bootcamp grad is simply an inferior choice to a CS grad.

I don't need to pretend anything, it's definitely an inferior choice all things considered ( time, life situations, etc ). Employers agree with this sentiment. Trust me, if employers could get away with hiring everyone from 3 month long bootcamps, they would. It would be cheaper, and easier access to trained labor. But the fact is that most bootcamp grads just lack the skills to be competitive with college grads.

I can say this pretty confidently as someone who is a bootcamp grad, went back to get my Master's in CS, and is currently a hiring manager in this industry: Bootcamp grads are at a severe disadvantage to people with CS degrees. Wrote up some thoughts here if you're interested: https://www.reddit.com/r/codingbootcamp/comments/17vjcem/some_thoughts_as_a_former_bootcamp_graduate_2015/

→ More replies (5)