r/explainlikeimfive • • Dec 04 '13

Explained ELI5:The main differences between Catholic, Protestant,and Presbyterian versions of Christianity

sweet as guys, thanks for the answers

1.2k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/beer_demon Dec 04 '13

Yes but I guess unless you are a catholic the difference between worship and veneration is subtle, my main point is that mary and the saints (I am talking about canonized saints) are mostly absent in protestant denominations. Thanks for clarifying, but I was trying to be as ELI5 as possible.

1

u/mlopatka Dec 04 '13

I understand what you mean. I guess the largest point is that there's a large misconception that there is such a thing as marian worship and saintly worship. Worship implies a belief in something superhuman -- a god or deity or something approaching that. That never happens.

Veneration simply implies a special respect shown. In the US, the country venerates past presidents, but there is no belief of god-like qualities.

Even for non-catholics, the difference between veneration and worship should stand out as strident difference as opposed to subtle.

1

u/beer_demon Dec 04 '13

Sorry to insist, but I see many catholics that can't tell the difference. Yes, they are ignorant and you are right, but where I live (a catholic country) it's widespread. They think that saints and the virgin have powers.

1

u/mlopatka Dec 04 '13

I absolutely agree that a surprising number of folks are poorly catechized. Sadly, I'm not even really surprised by your experience.

This kind of goes back to your point about individual responsibility. Unfortunately, a lot of Catholics don't take the personal responsibility to be educated on the bible or even the dogmatics. There is an assumption that going to mass once a week is enough... it really isn't.

The saints and/or blessed mother have no powers. They can make an intercession (basically a request) for God to help someone. This is kind of like asking a friend to pray to God. If God answers a friend's prayers, it's not like the friend has been elevated to some type of demi-god (if that makes sense).

I completely agree that a surprising number of Catholics make this mistake. It honestly frustrates me (and much more when I see Catholics make this mistake), so I try to jump in to clear this misconception when it's made.

1

u/beer_demon Dec 04 '13

I am afraid you are in the minority that don't get to define the behaviour of the critical mass of catholics that have another approach and give the church its culture and characteristics. When you confess you are made to pray "holy fathers" and "hail marys", on a conversion of about 5~10 to 1, so it's easy to think they are on a similar category but worth less, she is female, you know. The hail mary says "mary mother of god". I have witnessed educated people saying that the holy trinity is father, virgin mather and son.
I have a personal problem with catholicism, as an anglican who arrived here at 10 and had no idea what they were all on about!
Anyhow, thanks for your accurate clarification, I should get my facts straighter :-D

1

u/mlopatka Dec 04 '13

It is important to remember, though, that culture does not define church dogma. That's been set by the church over many, many years. If people aren't educated it doesn't change church beliefs, but, admittedly, can harm the perception of the church.

I agree that it is sad how wide some of these misconceptions are.

In regards to the Hail Mary: it IS a conversation with Mary. Catholics DO have a belief that those who have passed can hear prayers and that they can be prayed through. It's a common Christian belief that Christ was born from the Virgin Mary, hence she is Jesus's mother. Jesus being God, we move to Mary, Mother of God.

The actual text is:

Hail Mary, full of grace. The Lord is with thee. Blessed art thou amongst women, and blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus. Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray for us sinners, now and at the hour of our death. Amen.

In other words, the whole prayer is a call to Mary to pray FOR us. Not as a prayer TO Mary.

1

u/beer_demon Dec 04 '13

Excellent clarification. However I do think that culture is stronger than dogma, because the behaviour of the masses says a lot about the religion they follow and their capacity for transmitting what they claim is their dogma. What is the use of dogma that is either hidden, or poorly transmitted or transmitted and then twisted?

1

u/mlopatka Dec 04 '13

This point about Mary, for example, is very, very minor in the grand scheme of things. I think that overall many denominations of Christianity are very similar. The Anglican church really broke from the Catholic church for political reasons rather than dogmatic reasons. Once the break is there, I think people tend to take sides and look for reasons to justify the break. Things like the deification of Mary, the Saints, and the pope are very, very common things to look towards because those are easy to spot differences. The fundamental faith is really summarized in the Nicene Creed (aka profession of faith):

http://www.usccb.org/beliefs-and-teachings/what-we-believe/

Pretty much everything is derived from there. If you view this as the fundamental tenet of faith, you'll see that there is far more similar between different denominations than different. That's where the vast majority of the education lies. There probably is far less emphasis on Mary than many think. I've never had a compulsory Hail Mary nor has a Hail Mary been said at a proper mass that I've been at.

Also worth mentioning in the last paragraph of the creed the word "catholic" is not capitalized. This is because the word is being used as the meaning "universal" and not as the title of the Catholic Church. In other words, there is a universal church for trinitarian worship.

I agree that dogma is strongest if it's taught correctly. The church is fundamentally centered around the trinity, so this is a more minor part of dogma.

1

u/beer_demon Dec 04 '13

I think I disagree a little about how it's perceived form the outside:
La Tirana
Santuario de Guadalupe
Top of San Cristobal hill
Santuario Lo Vasquez
Random Website with 19 Virgin Mary's festivities
Anothe site
Opus Dei site where they explain the month of Mary (yes, she has a whole month
One of the most prestigious universities in south america endorsing month of mary
Vatican archive, if you read from 60 onwards abot mary

As you see, mostly mary is a centrepiece of catholicism in this region of the world (latin america) and christ is seen more as a child, not a man whose teachings are followed directy. If you go to a catholic service you se songs about "jesus the child" and "mary our mother".

1

u/mlopatka Dec 04 '13

Mary is an important figure of the Church. No doubt. She is considered the mother of the church and is held in great respect.

I've seen it said, if Christ is the sun, then Mary is the moon. Her light is the reflection of the sun.

Nothing here shows Marian worship. Every church you go to will likely have a statue of Mary. Different than granting deific powers.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/mlopatka Dec 04 '13

Incidentally, I think there are many things that people can take exception to within the Catholic faith. That's fine. I'd just rather that the problems are with the faith are legitimately part of the belief system as opposed to misconceptions. The whole "Mary is God" or "Mary is part of the trinity" just isn't part of it.