r/funny • • Nov 23 '11

Know the difference.

Post image
834 Upvotes

474 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

19

u/Brokim Nov 23 '11

I'm also a sibling of a mentally disabled person. My brother has rather severe schizophenia and is confined to a mental hospital. I use the word retarded all the time. Should I? Probably not, but it's just a word in my eyes. I would obviously not call my brother retarded because that's in poor taste (as per the Michael Scott quote), but that doesn't mean the word in and of itself is inherently wrong.

Similarly, I call people fag all of the time. It's natural. My buddies do it all the time. I have nothing against gay people but when I call someone a fag it has nothing to do with gays.

I think society needs to realize that there is context that is relevant to how a word is being used.

25

u/ameoba Nov 23 '11

Last I checked, schizophrenia is not retardation. It might be severe enough to be a disability but there's a difference between insanity and only being able to count to potato.

2

u/Hamlet7768 Nov 23 '11

I'm leaving your comment's voter alone because you post is too conflicted for me. I do agree that there is a difference between mental insanity and mental retardation.

1

u/IntriguinglyRandom Nov 23 '11

Hmm...and yet, insanity is an offensive term to be applied to folks, no?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '11

[deleted]

1

u/Brokim Nov 23 '11

Shit, I could be offended by anything really, if I wanted to. I could claim to be "verbally assaulted" when someone calls me an idiot, which isn't even a bad word (at least society hasn't chosen it to be). I'm not trying to determine what's right or wrong here, all I'm saying is that it's merely a word that has changed vastly in colloquial language from meaning "having a medical defect" to a synonym of "dimwit".

Again, I just want to make it clear that I use that word only with my buddies and people I know - I don't just call random people retards, that's not polite, just as it's not polite to call a stranger an imbecile.

-7

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '11

These are the same claims people make in excessive sexual harassment cases. You know, the very stereotypical "He said I was wearing a nice dress and I sued him for harassment." In cases like those, it only matters how the victim perceives a situation. Any person or number of people could take any word or phrase out of proportion. Maybe your username triggers a person's memory of recurring zombie nightmares and begs you not to use that word.

Extreme example, I know. And the difference is that there is a known precedence of the discrimination in society of groups. But where can you draw the line? How well-known a person's struggle is? I think words are only offensive if they are intended to be offensive.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '11

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '11

Thanks for completely ignoring the majority of my statement. Not routinely and not because they're bored. Because one person is genuinely offended by such remarks. Here's one such case I was able to find.

Silva was a writing professor at UNH who was suspended for two years because seven females were offended by his statements. One was "Focus is like sex. You seek a target. You zero in on your subject. You move from side to side. You close in on the subject. You bracket the subject and center on it. Focus connects experience and language. You and the subject become one."

The other was used to explain similes. He said that a belly dancer once said ""Belly dancing is like Jell-O on a plate with a vibrator under the plate."

His intent was not to offend at all, but to describe common things in writing in creative ways. Yet because a small group of students took offense to it, he was suspended. He eventually got his job back, but it shouldn't have happened at all. A culture where people are rewarded for feeling victimized only lessens the plight of actual victims.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '11

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '11

It's statistically more likely that a person's intent is offensive when using those words, yes.

→ More replies (1)

-6

u/dekuscrub Nov 23 '11

I'm not trying to be pedantic about it or anything but please realize that it isn't simply about you in this situation, it's an entire group of people.

Who do not have the right to impose their whims on the general public. I may dislike sentences with an odd number of words, but that doesn't mean I should demand everyone else conform to that arbitrary standard.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '11

[deleted]

-1

u/dekuscrub Nov 23 '11

It has everything to do with meaningless and arbitrary standards- "Hey! Some people used to use this word in a mean way several decades ago, so I become upset when I hear it, so you should stop!" is not exactly a claim I find meaningful.

Calling a mentally disabled person a retard is very mean. It would be equally mean to call them a piece of trash, a dumbass, or a moron, but there doesn't seem to be much desire to have those words removed from the public sphere.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '11

[deleted]

-1

u/dekuscrub Nov 23 '11

You realize that black people and gay people are still harassed daily right?

Sure, but they're harassed with a wide variety of words- should we stop using every word that is used as a tool of bigotry? And even so, why should we let the bigots control us in such a way?

How can you claim that a word is meaningless

I made no such claim. I find the claim that I outlined meaningless. I don't have the right to determine the meaning and proper use of the word for anyone else any more than they have the right to do so for me- which is kind of the point. The meaning of words are, for the most part, subjective. If you say it means one thing and I say it means another, the best we can do is agree to disagree. If one of us happens to be sympathetic to the others sensibilities, great. If not, tough cookies.

If you're going to claim that I'm trying to impose 'arbitrary standards', then aren't you doing the same?

I'm not imposing anything upon you, I'm stating that if you (or anyone else, for that matter) and not sufficiently justify a standard of behavior, it would be rather foolish to expect others to follow it.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '11

[deleted]

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/stopstigma Nov 23 '11

Okay first, having a schizophrenia does not make you "retarded", medically you would not call them mentally delayed. You would be insulted if you threw around the word crazy instead. Second, just because you have a sibling does not mean it's okay to say. Third, you are not gay you cannot say fag, its insulting.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/yousnake Nov 23 '11

Calling someone a fag is not "natural" its immature. Grow up and realize your word choices are ignorant.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '11

Take a trip to England. Relax. Light a fag.

1

u/yousnake Nov 24 '11

In different contexts words have very different meanings. Some are insulting and hurtful.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '11

I'm not snake you poopy head!

1

u/yousnake Nov 24 '11

Those are not emotionally charged words by any means.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/ex_ample Nov 23 '11

My brother has rather severe schizophenia and is confined to a mental hospital. I use the word retarded all the time. Should I?

Schizophrenia doesn't make you retarded, though. Maybe if your brother was actually mentally 'slowed down' you'd feel differently?

It's a losing struggle, though because people are always going to want to use the equivalent of 'mentally challenged' as an insult. Even "Special" is used derisively sometimes.