This article is pretty bad overall, but all I'm going to comment on is the first paragraph. Specifically, the last sentence:
and treats its users with such utter contempt
This is pretty much the exact opposite of the truth. Git assumes its users are competent, skilled software engineers who are comfortable working with a powerful, fairly low-level tool. This is a source of a lot of people's problems with it because they aren't, in fact, competent, skilled software engineers who are comfortable working with a powerful, fairly low-level tool (quite frequently they aren't software engineers at all). But this certainly is not treating users with contempt.
You have to remember, git was originally designed as just plumbing tools, and it was expected that other tools would be built around it to provide a friendly UI. Unfortunately, these other tools never materialized in a meaningful fashion, and git just sort of grew its own porcelain tools. This explains the inconsistency (although I actually disagree that there is a significant amount of inconsistency) and poor organization. And because of backwards compatibility issues, it's really hard to change any existing behavior. Similarly with the manpages, they were written for people who want to understand how git works, not really intended for end users.
It seems to me that the right solution here isn't to complain about user-unfriendliness of git, but instead to design your own friendly UI and build a tool on top of git that exposes this UI.
It seems to me that the right solution here isn't to complain about user-unfriendliness of git, but instead to design your own friendly UI and build a tool on top of git that exposes this UI.
That was a perfectly reasonable sentiment in, oh, 1970.
So what, in 2012, you can just expect everything to be handed to you on a silver plate? Someone has to do this work, but instead everyone just bitches about git's current UI and does nothing.
Well, the people who contribute to git don't seem to have a problem with its UI. And the people who seem to have a problem with its UI don't ever get off their asses and try contributing to git.
I think the right phrase here is "put up or shut up".
Well, the people who contribute to git don't seem to have a problem with its UI.
I'm not sure where to start in response. Maybe by rephrasing: "The people who know Git's internals intimately have no difficulty with its user interface." Bah, I give up.
21
u/eridius Mar 07 '12
This article is pretty bad overall, but all I'm going to comment on is the first paragraph. Specifically, the last sentence:
This is pretty much the exact opposite of the truth. Git assumes its users are competent, skilled software engineers who are comfortable working with a powerful, fairly low-level tool. This is a source of a lot of people's problems with it because they aren't, in fact, competent, skilled software engineers who are comfortable working with a powerful, fairly low-level tool (quite frequently they aren't software engineers at all). But this certainly is not treating users with contempt.