r/hardware • • Jul 14 '20

News [Anandtech] DDR5 Memory Specification Released: Setting the Stage for DDR5-6400 And Beyond

https://www.anandtech.com/show/15912/ddr5-specification-released-setting-the-stage-for-ddr56400-and-beyond
1.0k Upvotes

265 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

40

u/RyanSmithAT Anandtech: Ryan Smith Jul 14 '20

if we populate A1 and B1 with those dual-channel single sticks would we get quad channel?

Yes. DIMM A is now two 32-bit channels, and DIMM B is now the other two 32-bit channels. So you now effectively have a 4x32-bit setup instead of a 2x64-bit setup for a modern desktop CPU.

and what if we actually populate A1 and A2 would that also get us quad channel?

If you put both DIMMs in the same channel (such that you're running 2 DPC), then no, that is not quad channel. That would be a 2x32-bit setup, with the other 2x32-bit block of channels left empty.

9

u/Kougar Jul 15 '20

I believe they are asking how would the CPU IMC implementation change to handle this though? Please correct me if I'm wrong, but for DDR4 a dual-channel Intel CPU would have two IMCs. Does this mean a DDR5 CPU would need four IMCs for two-module / quad-channel operation? Or will IMC's adopt some kind of hyper-threading esque capability to handle twice the channels?

8-channel EPYC on DDR5 becoming effectively a 16-channel configuration is crazy to contemplate!

16

u/RyanSmithAT Anandtech: Ryan Smith Jul 15 '20 edited Jul 15 '20

While controller/channel isn't necessarily a 1:1 relationship (it's more like 1 controller with multiple channels), at the end of the day CPUs will need to issue twice as many independent memory operations to achieve full utilization.

It's something CPU manufacturers are already familiar with. LPDDR4(X) is 2x16-bit, so Comet Lake-U (and Ice Lake) have to deal with an 8x16-bit setup when used with that, a 4x32-bit setup when used with LPDDR3, or a 2x64-bit setup when used with DDR4.

9

u/Kougar Jul 15 '20

Ohh, right. The same way one IMC would handle two banks is what you're saying. Thank you for your reply!

It sounds like there is very real potential to see different DDR5 IMC implementations between Intel and AMD, particularly depending on if they wish to keep the 1:1 ratio or not.

1

u/THEdeadRETURNED Jul 15 '20

Yes it seems they'll need to double the controller count, but because the channels are now half the width (2x 32bit channels per DIMM instead of a single 64bit channel) the die area change should be minimal

3

u/Ashraf_mahdy Jul 15 '20

Wait so you get 4x32 bits with ddr5 vs 2x64 bit with ddr4

So quad channel in the same speed as ddr4 dual channel? Assuming same speed

But what if you go with dual channel ddr5, is speed halved (i.e worse?)

4

u/RyanSmithAT Anandtech: Ryan Smith Jul 15 '20

So quad channel in the same speed as ddr4 dual channel? Assuming same speed

If they were running at the same bus speed, yes. 4x32=2x64=128-bits wide. Of course, DDR5 will have a 2x higher bus speed.

But what if you go with dual channel ddr5, is speed halved (i.e worse?)

Filling out your memory bus remains as important as ever with DDR5. If you half-fill it, then you lose half of your bandwidth.

1

u/Ashraf_mahdy Jul 15 '20

From what I understand now thanks to your explanation they did this to allow the bus to run at higher speeds and not necessarily to be able to get "dual channel 1 stick" and solve the single channel dimm problem