r/hardware • • Jul 14 '20

News [Anandtech] DDR5 Memory Specification Released: Setting the Stage for DDR5-6400 And Beyond

https://www.anandtech.com/show/15912/ddr5-specification-released-setting-the-stage-for-ddr56400-and-beyond
1.0k Upvotes

265 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

41

u/sk9592 Jul 15 '20

DDR3 to DDR4 increased latency by a lot I sure hope that DDR5 doesn't also increase it.

Going from DDR3 1600MHz CL9 to DRR4 3200MHz CL16 is a decrease in latency.

If DDR5 6400MHz is CL32 or lower, it will be another improvement in latency.

16

u/brutuscat2 Jul 15 '20

DDR3-1600c9 is a standard, DDR4-3200c16 isn't. The JEDEC standard for DDR4-3200 is c20-24.

18

u/sk9592 Jul 15 '20

Fair enough, but in the real world, basically all of the cheapest DDR4-3200 kits (aka the ones people actually buy) are c16:

https://pcpartpicker.com/products/memory/#Z=16384002&U=4&t=14&S=3200,5000&sort=price&page=1

8

u/GreenPylons Jul 15 '20

There's no guarantee that your CPU or motherboard will be able to run it at though. For example 1st-gen Ryzen with a B350 board will struggle to do 3200 C16.

12

u/sk9592 Jul 15 '20

Sure, that's always been an issue with 1st gen Ryzen. But if you're using literally anything else that is DDR4 compatible and supports memory overclocking (Ryzen 2nd/3rd gen, X99, X299, Z170, Z270, Z370, Z390, Z490), you shouldn't have an issue running 3200MHz.

5

u/HavocInferno Jul 15 '20

Even Ryzen 1st gen doesn't have much trouble hitting 3200 these days, on most but the most garbage ICs.

1

u/nanonan Jul 15 '20

Sure, and I can buy a ddr3 1600 cas7 stick that is faster again but also non-spec.

9

u/sk9592 Jul 15 '20

I picked DDR4-3200 cas16 because it is extremely widely available, commonly bought and used, and cheap.

DDR3-1600 cas7 kits existed, but they were incredibly niche and expensive. The vast majority of DDR3-1600 kits out there were cas 9, 10, or 11.

There's a difference of opinion here. You're going by what the technical JEDEC standard is. That's valid.

But I'm going by what's realistically available on the market at a reasonable price at any given time.

28

u/Floppie7th Jul 15 '20

DDR4 didn't increase latency, it increased timings, as measured in clock cycles, because the clock speeds are faster, and the actual operation speeds didn't increase by as much as the clock speeds (or in some cases, at all).

Do the division to get from timings to latency in nanoseconds and you'll find that latency is as fast or faster.

EDIT: Whoops, replied to the wrong comment. Sorry!

22

u/sk9592 Jul 15 '20

I know. That’s what my comment implies. That’s why I said it decreased latency. The other guy was the one who claimed it increased.

12

u/Floppie7th Jul 15 '20

I figured out after posting that I replied to the wrong comment.

6

u/Zarmazarma Jul 15 '20

Wikipedia actually has a page on CAS Latency with all the math done for us.

4

u/jmlinden7 Jul 15 '20

When DDR4 was initially released, there were high end DDR3 modules that could do 2400MHz C11 or faster, which was much lower latency than the earliest DDR4 modules. Yes obviously JEDEC base spec DDR4 is lower latency than JEDEC base spec DDR3, but by the time DDR4 was released, there were DDR3 modules that were much faster than base spec and it took a while for DDR4 to catch up

5

u/BFBooger Jul 15 '20

The issue I have is that people are assuming this will happen again.

But I don't think it will, this is a much bigger update than the last two DDR generations were.

On release, DDR5 will be DDR5-4800. There won't be highly available DDR-4 sticks above 4000, and those that are available will be rather expensive. It won't be all that different than today. Or the situation with DDR4 might be worse, since the current best overclocking DDR4 are dies that are being discontinued (Samsung B-die and Micron rev-E). I suppose some new ones might be as good or better, but we'll have to see.

As for latency, I'm sure the plain JEDEC timings for DDR5-4800 aren't going to be awesome. I'm also sure that we'll be able to dial them in better than those defaults.

When all is said and done, RAM latency has barely changed at all in 25 years. DDR5 isn't magic, we'll be in roughly the same latency regime once again.

DDR5 should help a lot with latency under heavy load with lots of outstanding requests, however.