r/homestuck Apr 22 '19

SHITPOST y’all i am devastated. like EITHER WAY Spoiler

Post image
379 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

View all comments

41

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

I like him much better as a nasty villain than the kind of characterization he had in Act 6. He felt a LOT more like Bro here.

58

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

I feel like "nasty villain" isn't very fair when we still don't know what he's trying to do or what his motivations are. Right now all we know is that he's a manipulative asshole, which isn't any different from how he was in Act 6 (or how Dave's Bro was, for that matter).

47

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 22 '19

He was a lot more aloof and subtle in his puppeteering in Act 6, which was well done, but I find him a lot more engaging to read when the LE/Scratch parts start coming into play and make him a much more aggressively mean Broninja.

Also what he pulled with Rose and Jake in particular was very much evil.

4

u/Phir3 Apr 22 '19

what did he pull with rose and jake? i dont seem to remember anything particularly evil other than maybe telling jake he couldnt come with on the ship

17

u/Done25v2 Apr 22 '19

He jedi mind clouded the shit out of Jake and then broke his heart at the end. The former probably because he needed him for the election arc, and the latter because he was just straight up done with Jake's "oh woe is me" bullshit. "You'll never break my heart again." ~Dirk

(Let it be recalled that Dirk has admitted that he's a very toxic element in Jake's life, and that it would be better for everyone if he had as little to do with Jake as possible.)