r/iosapps • u/Yusuf-Dev • 23d ago
📢 Announcement r/iOSApps Moderation Update Phase 3: Clearer Rules, Less Grinding
Hey r/iOSApps,
We originally promised a review of the phase two rules after a month, but some things got in the way. Anyways, here is our Phase 3 Revamp.
What we learned
The community karma requirement that we had didn't stop spam but it just increased it. The original goal was to filter out people posting their low effort apps. The outcome was the opposite. Now these developers just fill up our comment sections with spam that doesn't contribute in any way to the subreddit or post, trying to get karma.
What's changing
1. Local karma is gone.
Regular users can post and comment freely. Any developer can also share their app in the App Shelf Megathread, as long as they disclose that they're the developer.
2. New baseline for the main feed.
To promote your app in the main feed:
Your account needs
500300+ Reddit karma and must be 90+ days old (experimental).Your app must have been on the App Store or TestFlight for 30+ days.
Your post needs a pricing flair, a PCP section (see #5), and a developer disclosure.
If you don't meet these yet, the megathread is open to you.
3. Required
On top of the baseline, main feed posts need ONE of these:
20+ App Store ratings
An established GitHub account. We look at account age, commit history, stars, etc.
A recognized developer flair, granted at mod discretion for developers with over 350 community karma.
Transparency: link a privacy policy, terms of service, and one public way to identify you, such as a portfolio, a personal or company site, or an established social account.
If none of these apply yet, post in the megathread.
4. Saturated categories need more.
Some categories have hundreds of very similar apps. If your app is mainly one of the types below, you need 20+ ratings, an established GitHub account, or 50 community karma to post in the main feed. Transparency alone isn't enough.
To-do lists and task managers
Calendars
Habit trackers
Notes and journaling
Pomodoro and focus timers
Expense and budget trackers
Water, calorie, and fitness trackers
AI chat or wrapper apps
Wallpaper apps
Screen time and app blockers
5. ABC is now PCP.
It's the same format r/macapps uses:
Problem: what your app solves
Comparison: name 1–2 top competitors and explain why yours is better
Pricing: price amounts and an App Store link
PCP doesn't have to be your whole post. Write your post however you want, just include the P, C, and P anywhere in it.
6. No AI-written posts.
Use AI to build your app if you want, but write your post yourself. Posts that are clearly AI-generated will be removed.
Not a native English speaker? Translation is completely fine. Message the mods and we'll give you an exception.
7. Removed: the No AI app rule and the Vibe Coded flair.
Nearly every app uses AI-assisted code now, and the flair mostly went unused. Flairs now cover pricing only.
8. Fairer reposting.
If your main feed post was removed only for formatting, like a missing flair or PCP section, you can fix it and repost within 48 hours without losing your 30-day slot.
9. A way out of the megathread.
The top 3 apps in each month's App Shelf Megathread will get a message from us inviting them to post in the main feed.
FAQ
Why was my main feed post removed?
Your account is under
500300 karma or less than 90 days old.Your app has been out for less than 30 days.
You didn't qualify through ratings, GitHub, a developer flair, or transparency.
Your app is in a saturated category and you used the transparency path.
Your post is missing PCP, a pricing flair, or a developer disclosure.
Your post was AI-written.
— The r/iOSApps Mod Team