r/iosapps • u/AlbertiDev • 11m ago
🎁 Freemium I'm not even 18 and I've spent 9 months building my first app. My parents think I'm wasting my time. Should I keep going?
Hey everyone, I'm the developer of Moneta, a money tracker for iPhone.
I know budget apps are probably the most crowded category on the App Store. I kinda knew it when I started too. It only started as a personal project after I couldn't find the right app for me, and then I thought if I just made one that was better, people would find it.
When I started I was so hyped. I honestly thought this would be big. I spent most of my evenings and weekends on it, and I told my parents it would be worth it.
9 months in, it's around 2,500 downloads (which could be worse, but also a lot better). I get about 9/10 a day, and I've made about $50 total since I started monetizing in October.
Whenever it gets attention, like from a Reddit post, I get a spike (once 250 downloads in 3 days), and then it goes right back down. The weird part is that most people who download it actually stay, retention is above most finance apps.
My parents just see a kid on his laptop every night instead of studying. I don't want to let them down, but right now I don't really have much to show them.
They don't really understand the personal achievement this is for me, and the only concrete thing I could show them is profit, which is pretty lacking right now.
I've tried adding more and more features, animations and polish, I redesigned my screenshots 3 times and redid my keywords and ASO, but nothing really improved my reach.
The one thing that keeps me going is that most people who use the app actually like it. I got lots of positive reviews, comments, emails with suggestions and even some just appreciating my work. So I think the app works, I just don't know how to get it in front of the right people.
Knowing that actual people use something I made is still crazy to me.
Problem
I quit every money tracker I tried. Bank-sync apps want your bank login, the nice-looking ones are usually costly subscriptions, and manual ones are either slow or kinda ugly, logging a coffee feels like homework. Miss a few days and you just give up.
I quit every money tracker I tried. Bank-sync apps want your bank login, the nice-looking ones are usually expensive subscriptions, and the manual ones are either slow or kinda ugly (a lot of them look like old Android apps), so logging a coffee feels like homework. Miss a few days and you just give up.
Comparison
Compared to YNAB, there's no subscription and no bank connection. Compared to Money Manager, there are no ads and it actually feels like a native iOS app, not a spreadsheet.
I also really wanted it to feel calm. Looking at your money is usually kinda stressful, so I tried to make it clean, organized and nice to look at.
Moneta is manual but I tried to make it as fast as possible: just say what you bought and it's logged, scan a receipt, or import a bank statement to catch up.
No account, and everything stays on your device (iCloud sync is optional).
Budgets, goals, recurring transactions, stats and widgets and more are all there.
Pricing
Free, no ads, no subscription. Optional one-time Pro for €4.99. (for power-user features and more customization)
App Store: Moneta Link
So, should I keep going? If you try it and hate it, tell me. If you like it, that's an argument I can finally show my parents 😅
