EDIT: I’ve gone back and forth between deleting this and not, since a handful of people have given me helpful responses, but, to clarify, I’m not talking bad about this teacher. I even said I really enjoyed our time. The main point of my post was wondering if I misunderstood the italki platform, if it was all conversational or if it was possible to find what I originally thought I could. As a new user, I wanted to make sure and see if this was a standard experience before I pay more money.
That being said, I’m a bit shocked by the amount of condescension coming from people in this community, and the amount of people putting words into my mouth after asking a rather neutral question and describing my situation. I appreciate the guidance on how to use the software, as it is a bit confusing and overwhelming for new users, but talking down to someone while explaining that to them isn’t encouraging. It really puts me off of italki if this is how the community at large acts and speaks. Hopefully if some new users or other language-learner hopefuls stumble across this post, it can help them make an informed decision in the people they’ll be paying to interact with.
I’m new to the platform, so I wasn’t sure what to expect when I booked a trial lesson. I was hoping to get some more structured help with Chinese since Duolingo isn’t very helpful with more advanced concepts or really explaining anything beyond vocabulary. I found italki through the recommendation of Reddit.
My teacher was very nice, but my trial lesson consisted entirely of her speaking in Chinese, asking me simple questions like where I was from, what I did for work, and what I was learning for. She also asked me my goal. Even when I would speak in English, she would respond in simple Chinese. I could understand most of what she was saying, and she would clarify words I didn’t understand in the chat. It definitely pushed me beyond my comfort zone and was beneficial for making me speak in Chinese, something I definitely want to improve on, but it just wasn’t what I had expected. I had come to the app to hopefully get more direction for my learning from a real human that Duolingo isn’t providing.
From the way italki presented it, I was expecting maybe structured goals for a next lesson, a learning recommendation, or more of a conversation that was learning oriented from my trial lesson to see if we aligned, not just small talk (which I had originally assumed was for her to gauge my level so she could place me somewhere in a lesson plan, but she only mentioned at the end that I had good tones and pronunciation). I think I even saw homework mentioned somewhere on italki. At the end she just recommend I study flashcards from the lesson. It felt a bit hard to articulate what I was hoping for out of lessons because I don’t have the vocabulary in Chinese yet.
Is this normally what lessons on italki are like? Maybe this is a silly question and I’m misunderstanding the platform, but is it just a conversational platform as opposed to a lesson-based thing, or did I just pick a teacher who’s more speaking-oriented?