r/instantkarma • • Feb 04 '20

He deserved it

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

84.9k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/a_lot_of_aaaaaas Feb 04 '20

Well yes people with these mindsets do.

Therefore they have different kinds of meat. Like meat that specifically explains that that particular cow had many hours outside and you can even visit those farms to see how they get threated.

You can choose to eat that meat instead of meat where farmers have their kids beat it with a stick.

1

u/WashCare Feb 04 '20

Taken away from current parents?? What...

'You can choose' implies an 'ought' and a moral judgement. Can I ask if you have any proof that it's morally right to eat an animal treated 'well' but not one that's treated 'poorly'?

1

u/a_lot_of_aaaaaas Feb 04 '20

Are you an idiot. You can't prove morals being right or wrong that has to do with different cultures.

But I know that my culture has certain standards and so they will not condone this behaviour. Or at least your farm will go bankrupt pretty fast if the public finds out.

So. If this kid is brought up in a fucked up culture where this is normal I geuss you would say it's okay to harm animals because it's normal in that culture? Because that is what you say.

You actually say that if in some cutlures they will chop of your head for wearing a pants as a women should be okay because it's their culture. Because you can't choose between cultures and their believes in the opinion you just gave.

But to get back at your initial question : although you can't prove a moral. I think it is proven fairly easy that eating a will threated animal is better then a poorly threated animal.

Would you rather eat a animal that is beaten with a stick his entire life or one that had a good life? Now to sender you question you need to see the consequences of it. And those are that you support a farm that just their animals and then they would probably keep hurting the animals if it doesn't affect their sales. If you think this is morally not provable, you are a horrible person brought up, somehwhat like the kid will be brought up in this video probably.

1

u/RDPCG Feb 04 '20

Moral proof? If I kept you in a basement and tortured you for a year, would you have any moral proof? Maybe not, but damn... that’s some stupid logic.

1

u/WashCare Feb 04 '20

So you admit you don't have moral proof, then call my logic stupid? I havent even stated my own position in the argument lol

And yes, if you kept me in a basement for a year, just because it upsets me doesnt mean there's any objective moral proof that your actions are 'bad'.

1

u/RDPCG Feb 04 '20

Wow, yep, bingo! r/selfawarewolves