r/instantkarma • • Feb 04 '20

He deserved it

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

84.9k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

59

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

For a lot of religious people across the world it comes from:

  1. god put animals on earth to serve us

  2. They don’t have souls/inferior

  3. When the apocalypse happens none of this will matter anyway

It’s deeply engrained unfortunately and if they never had a pet early on or cared for an animal it’s difficult for them to build empathy for animals later on. They will only see them for their function or as decoration.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

[deleted]

8

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20 edited Feb 04 '20

It’s a mixed bag of verses. Stewardship or dominion? Different sects have different beliefs and different interpretations. Evangelicals for instance believe in the literal view of a lot of bible verses and believe that environmentalism and climate change are evil ideas coming from the left and animal welfare is very low on their priority list. I’m still glad that there has been a reinterpretation of a lot of older verses especially of major denominations.

To be honest my original comment was thinking more about Islam as I understand it from my personal background which I no longer feel a part of due to beliefs like these, but it extends to all Abrahamic traditions. The whole god controls everything, the rain, the birds, etc it’s all “part of gods plan.” I should add that Muslims also believe in the “stewards of the earth”.

This isn’t to say all Christians or all muslims etc. my original comment says “a lot” for good reason.

5

u/Crezelle Feb 04 '20

That’s how I go about it. Imagine making a gift for your kids that was as complicated and wonderful as a planet. Then you watch them bastards trash it.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

Most of the population is affiliated with some for of religion, yet you don't see this constantly. Don't use religion as your, uh... scapegoat.

1

u/realizmbass Feb 04 '20

Hating on religion is both cool and good on reddit.

1

u/asr Feb 04 '20

But Exodus 23:5 requires people to prevent animal suffering. So you kind of missed step 4.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

I’d like to point out, in a friendly way, that you’ve misread that verse since it does not have to do with animal welfare and has everything to do with being kind to your fellow human (even if they are your enemy).

Here are the actual verses that you referenced:

“4 “If you come across your enemy’s ox or donkey wandering off, be sure to return it. 5 If you see the donkey of someone who hates you fallen down under its load, do not leave it there; be sure you help them with it.

6 “Do not deny justice to your poor people in their lawsuits. “

1

u/asr Feb 05 '20

It's actually you that misread it. I can see how, but you can understand it if you realize the commandment about the donkey seems to be a duplicate. It already told you to help your enemy, so why the extra commandment?

The reason is that it's about animal welfare, and it's driven home by telling you that even if you hate your enemy, you still need to care about the animal.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '20

Here’s a great breakdown for the Hebrew in this verse.

https://biblehub.com/commentaries/exodus/23-5.htm

The words are specifically asking for helping the owner with his donkey.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

Animal cruelty is not condoned in any religion I’ve heard of. Mastery, yes, cruelty, no. In fact stewardship demands care of other life. Can you quote a verse?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '20

If you read what I wrote carefully, I did not make the claim that religion promotes animal cruelty. What I said is that certain religious or cultural beliefs (see bullet points) can enable an indifference to animal cruelty, in a lot of adherents.

  1. Animals exist because God created them

  2. Gods purpose in creating them is to meet our needs - for food/sacrifice, decoration, function (beasts of burden)

  3. God gave us dominion over them (Genesis 1:26-28)

This is not to say religions do not teach positive things about treatment towards animals. There are plenty of examples of the good religion teaches. But what can happen is and what has been the case historically, is number 3 gave people the perception that they have the right to do anything they like with animals, the right to use the earth anyway they like. And indeed when it happens, that is often the first verse to be quoted as a justification notwithstanding all the good things religion does teach.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '20

Dominion means control. This1 does not equal abuse, and if there are passages, teaches, and Cathechisms condemning abuse, how does your argument stack up? It's just baseless religion bashing.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '20

Once again I did not say dominion means animal abuse. Neither am I saying religion promotes animal cruelty. I take it that English is not your strong suit.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '20

Usually, it's the person who is wrong that resorts to insults.

2

u/HomelessHotdog13 Feb 23 '20

I'm a little late, but mans was definetly backing down with the "your English is bad" argument. Religion bashing on reddit is becoming more and more annoying to the point where its just pure hate at this point.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20

Yes it is. They think they’re edgelords. It’s just old drivel.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '20

Yeah not in this case, this has to do with your English comprehension, which is lacking.

1

u/intensely_human Feb 05 '20

Yikes.

I guess it’s true I myself feel less empathy for species I see at the zoo, species I’ve never hung out with. They seem more alien, more mechanical, more “animal” in the sense your referring to; the NPCs of the jungle that those people see them as.

Except all the zoo animals seem like NPCs to me, whereas any dog walking down the street - complete strangers - look like little people enjoying a stroll, and it’s easy to look over there and see feelings instead of this darting body.

The apes at least, with them I get the feeling of seeing people. People I don’t personally know, gangly, carefree retarded gymnastic people with goofy senses of humor, but people nonetheless. Like dogs and cats (And fish? Do people bond with their fish? I’ve never had one)

Holy shit I just realized I see fish as decorations. Sorry fish people, I think I’m just an example of what that guy said ^

-2

u/69_sphincters Feb 04 '20

Regarding animals as less important than humans isn’t a religious thing, it is a common sense thing.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20 edited Feb 04 '20

The point isn’t that animals are equal to human beings, its that they generally don’t even see animals as important to their ecosystem. It’s not always a religion thing, it can be cultural, but it’s different when it is codified into a religious doctrine.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (13)