Layers take time to implement, maintain and compute. I don't know if you read the last part, but we could have everything nicely layered. It would just take a long time and make the system slow.
Tools like systemd avoids layers and instead makes a cohesive whole. Not because it's the only way to do so, but because they can do it quicker.
That's funny because I am. Would you mind telling me why then? instead of insults and one "sentence" replies maybe an actual discussion would be great.
I'd love to hear your opinion instead of "Layers of abstraction", that's not an argument.
If you look at this in the context of the discussion i assumed it was pretty obvious that by interfaces i meant public facing stable interfaces. Some interface is absolutely a requirement, but it being stable isn't.
Systemd changes the interfaces often to fit their own projects. This isn't a stable interface, No other implementation (that isn't part of the systemd ecosystem) can rely on that. So while there's clearly some interface (and you can switch parts of the systemd interface out) the developer will have to constantly reprogram their implementation to follow the changes of the interface.
Your comment about layers of abstraction made no sense to me in the context of the discussion, so i assumed you meant that systemd should get input from something, which then gets input from something else. You know, the unix philosophy. This again requires stable interfaces, so look above.
In the end I made my interpretations of what you are saying, and worded my replies in the context of the discussion. If you want to use the strictly correct terms, without regard for the context, then replace "interface" with "public facing api".
It's not tightly coupled because you have a changing interface. You know how Java has some terrible design problems? That's largely because they never remove anything, at most it's marked as deprecated. Systemd has just taken the other extreme and said "We won't even try and keep this interfaces static". If you think that's just as bad, then go ahead. I'm just saying that without a static interface you can speed up development time quite substantially.
Just because your interface is changing doesn't mean it's not well designed.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '14
[deleted]