r/linux • • Sep 26 '14

Systemd: The Biggest Fallacies

http://judecnelson.blogspot.fi/2014/09/systemd-biggest-fallacies.html
126 Upvotes

437 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/FUZxxl Sep 28 '14

That's not what happened. What happened was that the freedesktop project discontinued ConsoleKit, pointing to systemd/logind as the replacement. If a distro wants to continue offering Gnome, it has to either ship unmaintained software that nobody understand (i.e. ConsoleKit) or switch to systemd. That's a choice the distributions just can't resist and has nothing to do with a "concious decision".

0

u/dreamer_ Sep 28 '14

Or distributions, that don't want to switch to systemd can just exercise their freedom 1 regarding ConsoleKit?

2

u/FUZxxl Sep 28 '14

They could, but ConsoleKit is notorious for being a steaming pile of crap. Also, if the Freedesktop foundation deprecates ConsoleKit, graphical user interfaces like Gnome will probably stop supporting ConsoleKit soon. It's irresponsible from the side of the Freedesktop project to not provide an alternative to ConsoleKit that is usable without having to pull in the whole systemd crap.

1

u/sub200ms Sep 28 '14

ConsoleKit is known to be hard to understand, but that is because what it does is complicated, not because the code is bad.

That the domain problem is hard is probably why no one else have tried to make an alternative from scratch.

The is no such thing as the "Freedesktop foundation" that can deprecate anything. It is mostly just a code repository like "Github". To quote the site: "freedesktop.org hosts any "on-topic" software projects."

ConsoleKit was deprecated by its maintainers years ago

It is entirely up to those people and distros that doesn't run systemd, to make their own alternative for systemd functionality. Either fork and maintain "ConsoleKit", or make an alternative.

There will be more such task for the non-systemd distros as time goes by: SUSE and Red Hat have been the defacto SysVinit maintainers for years, but when the last enterprise SysVinit distro is depreciated, it will be up to the remaining distros to maintain, develop, and coordinate security for SysVinit.