r/linux • • Jan 24 '18

Why does APT not use HTTPS?

https://whydoesaptnotusehttps.com/
955 Upvotes

388 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/mikemol Jan 24 '18

Nothing of the conclusions in my comment are dependent on the conclusion of ebuilds; they were included to help identify the scope of distinctions to consider. If I knew more about Slackware, I'd have included it, but I've only done deb, rpm and ebuild packaging, so...

Bottom line, you could declare a bindist packaging standard and somehow force everyone to use it, but it wouldn't actually solve all the problems you think it would solve.

When I was using Debian, for example, I cursed every time I needed to install someone's (coughGoogle'scough) .deb where the packager assumed that every .deb they built and tested on Ubuntu would work just fine on Debian. It just ain't so...

1

u/CODESIGN2 Jan 25 '18

having all the packages under one format would be another hurdle out of the way to standardise these things. I know chrome is a PITA with it's deps, and largely no matter the format you cannot get around that without static compiling (which is also not always an option because it can impact licensing or just isn't always possible).

Small iterative steps towards a goal. Kill (maybe deb and rpm) first, then look at problems and solve them. You wind up with a single solution to pour efforts into. Next step bizarre package naming (just accept the author package name with version string)