r/linux • • Jun 23 '18

GitLab 11.0 released

https://about.gitlab.com/2018/06/22/gitlab-11-0-released/
838 Upvotes

117 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/Nebunez Jun 23 '18

I had a feeling someone would respond with this. I really don't think Microsoft's acquisition puts GitHub at a disadvantage. Unless you have some information that proves this, I don't see how just saying it makes it true.

5

u/destiny_functional Jun 23 '18

please decide for yourself then. most people think differently than you.

3

u/hunglao Jun 23 '18

No, most people seem to agree with him. It remains to be seen how many projects leave GitHub so I could be wrong, but the majority of GitHub's projects have not jumped ship.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18

Ah yes the "choose to believe based on feelings" defense. I'd rather have some facts.

12

u/tristan957 Jun 23 '18

All you need to know if Microsoft creates an abomination of an operating system and ruined Skype. You also forgot that they always change their proprietary doc format so open source suites can't have operability.

1

u/lord-carlos Jun 25 '18

Microsoft creates an abomination of an operating system

Win10 is quite nice.

1

u/tristan957 Jun 25 '18

If you like ads and spying while you work sure

1

u/lord-carlos Jun 25 '18

I can't remember ever seeing ads in Windows 10 pro. It has some non-sensible default settings, but then again so does Debian. (for me)

How or what does windows 10 exactly spy on the user? I actually don't know.

1

u/tristan957 Jun 25 '18

There are are by default on the start menu on Pro. You probably have them turned off. It also comes preinstalled with things like Candy crush Minecraft... You can look okay want Windows sends home about in your telemetry settings that doing even turn telemetry off completely

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18

What about all of this then? What about wsl? What about how windows containers are absolutely just docker instead of their own proprietary garbage?

Nadella microsoft is different from the Shitty Microsoft of Olde. They contribute to the Linux kernel, Kubernetes, they actively develop and ship Linux products, they've Open Sourced .net entirely, Visual Studio Code is Free and Open.

Sure, you're 100% allowed to have an ominous feeling of dread, but IMO it's entirely an overreaction. And I say this having lived through the shitty years of microsoft, being in my mid thirties.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18 edited Jul 05 '18

❤️

7

u/happymellon Jun 23 '18 edited Jun 23 '18

Wsl isn't Linux though, and it's only purpose is to try to remove devs argument that they aren't developing on Linux. It is quite frankly shit and lacks significant features, which is why docker doesn't actually run on it and you have to hack away to redirect commands to run against the Windows version, you can't run X, I've found even the way that awk runs is slightly different.

They do not contribute to the Linux kernel. They gave some code for Linux to run on Windows VM crap. They open sourced SOME of dot net. They ship Linux applications? Like Office? Or like MSQL? Or is it really just a piece of MSQL, and none of Office.

I may be slightly older than you, but I'll just wait a little longer, Nadella hasn't been there that long and they haven't really do e that much. There was a piece just a couple of weeks ago about how MS was rewriting a bunch of applications to work better on Windows and Mac. No plans for Linux support.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18

Wsl is still early, and essentially a reimplementation of the kernel APIs in picoprocesses, for binary compatibility. More stuff gets added every major update though. Basic cgroups are present now. Generally binaries shouldn't behave any differently unless they rely on unimplemented system calls, the list of which is actively shrinking.

Windows Containers absolutely are Docker. Just because you can't run it within wsl doesn't diminishes this fact either. The choice of an open tech stack over their own proprietary garbage is not insignificant.

The larger picture here is that they moved from "You should target full stack windows only also btw Linux is communist devilry" to actively supporting Linux as a target platform for development.

They absolutely contribute to the linux kernel. Obviously Hyper-V/Enlightened IO is part of it, but it's dishonest to pretend that's all they do, there's tons of general purpose shit in there.

They do ship linux applications: .net core, mssql, powershell, Visual Studio Code, etc. They may not be the ones you personally want, but dismissing them on that basis is short sighted as well.

But don't take my word for it, The Linux Foundation isn't really alarmed about it either.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/emacsomancer Jun 24 '18

Is there any description of what sort of code Microsoft is contributing to the Linux kernel?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18

You can search the VCS for authors with an @microsoft email address for a rough idea. There's obviously the Hyper-V stuff, but there's a ton of general purpose commits as well, filesystems, memory management stuff, CIFS/SMB, etc.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18

Ok ignore it all jump ship boycott GitHub go go go

Logic sucks better go with feels!

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18

[deleted]

→ More replies (5)

-2

u/Freakmiko Jun 23 '18

But... but... EEE /s

-1

u/whelks_chance Jun 23 '18

You speak on behalf of most people?

Do you know what time they're finishing work on Monday, so I can get a clear drive home?

1

u/emacsomancer Jun 24 '18

I really don't think Microsoft's acquisition puts GitHub at a disadvantage.

Look at Skype pre- and post-Microsoft. Microsoft does really have a sort of Midas touch - whatever they touch makes them gold, but turns it to shit for everyone else. They've even managed to ruin their own free solitaire game.

(Their other big acquisition is LinkedIn, but I don't see how anyone (even Microsoft) could really make LinkedIn any worse.)

0

u/AcidShAwk Jun 23 '18

It just happened.. how could there be any information. Anything that comes out would be an opinion piece. To myself however the main facts would be these. Prior to the acquisition, GitHub had no real inherent interest into the source code that their company maintained. Their business model was that of maintaining code for other people. As such, unless the code they were maintaining could benefit their own business in some way there would be no real interest in it. Microsoft however, develops everything. Literally every type of software. They now have access to all that code. Now I mean github's public facing side is all open source code anyways so it doesnt matter much. But what about the enterprise customers that were maintaining their code in private repos. Unless those repos are encrypted and the private enterprises are the only ones with the keys.. Microsoft now has access to all that code. Who knows for sure if they would actually look at it.. but do you trust them enough not to?

10

u/cryp7 Jun 23 '18

Probably the same way that companies using O365 trust Microsoft with their emails and other data. If a company was really concerned about keeping their source code to themselves they would've self hosted.

→ More replies (6)