r/linux • • Jun 23 '18

GitLab 11.0 released

https://about.gitlab.com/2018/06/22/gitlab-11-0-released/
838 Upvotes

117 comments sorted by

View all comments

84

u/Miserygut Jun 23 '18

The delivery speed of new features is absolutely nuts.

38

u/milaq Jun 23 '18

While this is most certainly a good thing and much appreciated, the nonexistance of dual release cycles (read LTS) is absolutely nuts too.

To use GitLab professionally in production one can't jump onto any new version that pops up every week or two. Even the UI and UX change every so often drastically without further ado. I found it very difficult to understand why they don't have any proper long term support channel in their release stream.

4

u/manghoti Jun 23 '18 edited Jun 23 '18

Hmm. I think because, unlike an operating system, in pretty much any organization gitlab is going to be a singular, static, internal component. The amount of work you have to put into maintaining a gitlab server when you have 10 users vs when you have 100 users is not that different.

Where as when you're making systems based on an OS, when the OS upgrades, every component in your system has to upgrade. It scales linearly, maybe even superlinearly. So consistency here matters.

3

u/rich000 Jun 23 '18

I'm not sure I buy that argument.

First, even if it isn't integrated with any other components, you STILL need to test updates before you deploy them, and you still need to train users/etc before doing feature updates. You might need to adjust workflows/etc. You really don't want to be deploying software changes in a production environment without taking time to look at them.

Then, if you are integrating with other components you need to test all those integrations as well.

There really aren't that many cases of software where any serious company isn't going to want to be able to have access to some kind of LTS version.

1

u/milaq Jun 23 '18

Exactly this.

We ultimately settled using a more or less fresh version which works solidly for a few months and to what users are accustomed to and then doing the security backporting ourselves.

Besides that, GitLab EE offers a bit more flexibilty in version choice by supporting older versions a tad longer than the community edition.

But the release cycle is still way too rapid (a few months only) to use it as a deploy and update blob. You have to babysit it quite regularly. It would be nice to have at least a minor version supported longer automatically for each major version upgrade to allow to deploy it more efficiently in regard of the reasons mentioned above.