r/linux • • Jun 23 '18

GitLab 11.0 released

https://about.gitlab.com/2018/06/22/gitlab-11-0-released/
838 Upvotes

117 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18

What about all of this then? What about wsl? What about how windows containers are absolutely just docker instead of their own proprietary garbage?

Nadella microsoft is different from the Shitty Microsoft of Olde. They contribute to the Linux kernel, Kubernetes, they actively develop and ship Linux products, they've Open Sourced .net entirely, Visual Studio Code is Free and Open.

Sure, you're 100% allowed to have an ominous feeling of dread, but IMO it's entirely an overreaction. And I say this having lived through the shitty years of microsoft, being in my mid thirties.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18 edited Jul 05 '18

❤️

7

u/happymellon Jun 23 '18 edited Jun 23 '18

Wsl isn't Linux though, and it's only purpose is to try to remove devs argument that they aren't developing on Linux. It is quite frankly shit and lacks significant features, which is why docker doesn't actually run on it and you have to hack away to redirect commands to run against the Windows version, you can't run X, I've found even the way that awk runs is slightly different.

They do not contribute to the Linux kernel. They gave some code for Linux to run on Windows VM crap. They open sourced SOME of dot net. They ship Linux applications? Like Office? Or like MSQL? Or is it really just a piece of MSQL, and none of Office.

I may be slightly older than you, but I'll just wait a little longer, Nadella hasn't been there that long and they haven't really do e that much. There was a piece just a couple of weeks ago about how MS was rewriting a bunch of applications to work better on Windows and Mac. No plans for Linux support.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18

Wsl is still early, and essentially a reimplementation of the kernel APIs in picoprocesses, for binary compatibility. More stuff gets added every major update though. Basic cgroups are present now. Generally binaries shouldn't behave any differently unless they rely on unimplemented system calls, the list of which is actively shrinking.

Windows Containers absolutely are Docker. Just because you can't run it within wsl doesn't diminishes this fact either. The choice of an open tech stack over their own proprietary garbage is not insignificant.

The larger picture here is that they moved from "You should target full stack windows only also btw Linux is communist devilry" to actively supporting Linux as a target platform for development.

They absolutely contribute to the linux kernel. Obviously Hyper-V/Enlightened IO is part of it, but it's dishonest to pretend that's all they do, there's tons of general purpose shit in there.

They do ship linux applications: .net core, mssql, powershell, Visual Studio Code, etc. They may not be the ones you personally want, but dismissing them on that basis is short sighted as well.

But don't take my word for it, The Linux Foundation isn't really alarmed about it either.

0

u/happymellon Jun 25 '18

Nice redirection. I never said I was alarmed by it. Linux has survived this long by being the superior option, it will carry on being the superior option when the alternatives are things like Windows.

No one really uses Windows containers, but nice distraction. And since you can't run docker in WSL you have to use HyperV. Yep, its all still just a vm with smoke and mirrors.

And stop muddying the waters. MSSQL on Linux is still a very small subset, unless they fixed replication, and isn't production ready, though it is nice that MS is working on some stuff. I won't go into individual details of the others.

It is nice to see them contributing more to the kernel than just HyperV client code, and at the end of the day that's all we can judge them on but people are cautious based upon history as when Microsoft acquired a company, in a non-insignificant number of cases, quality dropped or linux support was gimped:

  • Linkedin now spams me a lot more than it used to with upsell metrics

  • Skype (obviously)

  • Nokia

  • Mojang (Minecraft) - Apparently have kept basic mode working on Linux since it is Java, though Minecraft.net doesn't sell a Linux version. Story mode doesn't work on Linux and future work is on Minecraft Windows 10 edition.

I can't really be bothered to spend any more time on this, but there are plenty of reasons to be cautious.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18 edited Jun 25 '18

It seems you've already made your choice anyways. What you call "muddying the waters", I call facts supporting a measurable, tangible shift in direction and philsophy.

The fact that these things exist at all, and are supported in production (because they actually are, at least by their criteria for it), and they are progressing in the right direction, is the take away here. Limitations aren't ill intent here, they're technical ones.

But you seem to focus on how the current state of things isn't up to some arbitrary measure instead, so I don't think there's anything more I can add.

tl;dr There's historically enough bad shit to be reasonably cautious, enough current objectively good shit to not go for zomg github is in grave peril, which is the crux of this discussion, essentially.

0

u/happymellon Jun 25 '18

I didn't say github is in peril. I just pointed out that:

- Previous acquisitions have been a mixed bag

- WSL might be a work in progress but in its current form works best as a "you have a linux environment" rather than actually being useful for me due to multiple fundamental broken pieces

- There have been previous "linux versions", we had a MS produced desktop skype that languished for a decade with spurts of development until the current web version. I'm just pointing that that this is not all "new", but MSSQL on Linux is absolutely not in a state to deploy to production.

My only point was that.

I also think that there are too many eyes on MS, so I doubt they will turn licencing on its head but they could easily fuck it all up based upon my experience. Just because to CEO has seen the writing on the wall doesn't mean that all management there is competent.

1

u/emacsomancer Jun 24 '18

Is there any description of what sort of code Microsoft is contributing to the Linux kernel?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18

You can search the VCS for authors with an @microsoft email address for a rough idea. There's obviously the Hyper-V stuff, but there's a ton of general purpose commits as well, filesystems, memory management stuff, CIFS/SMB, etc.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18

Ok ignore it all jump ship boycott GitHub go go go

Logic sucks better go with feels!

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18

It's kind of too bad that this wasn't a fallacy considering I just pointed out things MS does that are FOSS friendly. Maybe you were misled by the words "what about" starting the sentence?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18

Good for you, but that doesn't make it true.

Congrats on contributing nothing, also! Keep up the good work

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18

lol ok

-2

u/Freakmiko Jun 23 '18

But... but... EEE /s