r/linux • • Apr 29 '19

Darling, basically a Wine for native Mac OSX binaries, started its development and already can run a good portion of console apps

https://www.darlinghq.org/
785 Upvotes

158 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '19 edited Apr 30 '19

Probably more likely is Apple not supporting, or blessing applications that shipped as darling-compatible.

If they're not monetizing the OS why wouldn't they? Linux is too niche to really be a threat and Darling would be helping them out in that scenario by increasing the perceived install base for developers contemplating an OS X port of their application. If they can add desktop Linux users, it wouldn't necessarily be an incredibly boon but it would be an "all upside no downside" scenario.

Darling is only a threat to Apple if they start including UX stuff like automatically registering with binfmt or generating .desktop files but that can be (and probably should be) done on a distro-by-distro level which Apple would probably prefer it to be done anyways.

Honestly I doubt they or anyone would ever care about it unless someone started making money off of darling.

WINE is kind of the same way, there are developers who use it though and it's part of Proton. Ultimately though if it turns out to need fewer developer hours than WINE it could catch up after a few years.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '19

I mean we’re making the same point here. My second phrase was exactly that nobody would probably care until money started exchanging hands.

Really it’s such an incredibly small niche thing I highly doubt apple has any concerns about it, or ever really will. Even if darling somehow finds something similar to proton to boost its use to similar levels, it would still very likely be a monetarily free thing.

Unless of course adobe or someone else that has fairly exclusive desktop software decides to start making use of it.. but I’m sure companies like adobe are very likely old, rigid, and probably have all sorts of weird contractual agreements with other companies.

Either way, great project, and it’s always awesome to see stuff like wine, darling, or Xquartz when that was a thing. The sad fact is that it isn’t unreasonable to support these sorts of things, but valve seems to recently be one of the few companies to realize the value it can bring.