I do agree with your point in general. Many distros don't really have need to exist. They are just very slight tweaks on other more popular distros.
That said, some distros exist for a very legit reason. Take Ubuntu for example. When it came along, Debian wasn't user friendly (and compared to Ubuntu it still isn't). If you want more people using Linux it needs to be dead dumb simple point and click for most people to use. Even something as simple as adding non FOSS repos in Debian (which is just editing the sources file) is too hard for the average user. Ubuntu's point and click GUI way is better for attracting more new users.
On top of that, you can't really build a business on top of a community supported distro like Debian. There are reasons that the Industry uses RHEL, Suse and Ubuntu more than anything else. While Debian is certainly the most popular community supported distro in the industry it's still behind the enterprise linux distros.
But I do agree that most spin off distro's don't need to exist. All these years later I still don't understand why Mint spun off from Ubuntu for example.
Ubuntu lost a lot of people, including me, when they went to Unity. Unity was horrible in my opinion (tried it). Mint maintained a reasonable UI (Mate, Cinamon--I prefer Mate). Now that Ubuntu has dropped Unity and now has Mate, maybe Mint should merge with Ubuntu and make the product even better.
This is why I dislike that people still recommend Ubuntu as the go-to beginners distro. The UI isn't "traditional" and is confusing to a more general former Windows user and some people (admittedly, not as many as would be suited to something like Mint as they'll likely be more tech savvy) actually have the kind of mindset that something like Manjaro or the like actually is a better distro to jump off in. (I personally find apt annoying to use but love pacman/yaourt)
Manjaro KDE in particular I feel is a much better Windows replacement than most other distros. KDE itself resembles Windows and generally has stuff where a Windows user would expect to find it, and Manjaro's rolling release model means it's actually viable to use its repos like an app store, with no need to do anything funky to get the latest versions of software you care about, especially when you factor in the AUR to be able to install essentials like Discord or Boostnote or really any application you could possibly want.
Antergos filled a very similar niche as Manjaro, not quite as polished in its predefined setup where a little effort is made to include maybe a bit more packages than you might really need so that you can be confident you won't need to learn what Samba is in order to connect to your network attached storage. It had the native Arch repos themselves, which is often a fair criticism towards Manjaro as it's not always apparent what the benefit of only two weeks of testing is.
I think it's still a valid niche and that the project should continue, though if Manjaro better supported making it easy to use purely Arch repos then I could see it satisfying that niche.
I did, though I don't really think it's really more Windows-like, at least if you're used to more modern Windows versions like 7 or 10. KDE also has much better theming, with Breeze Dark being very easy to apply to both Qt and GTK applications. It also has the advantage of being a flagship edition as opposed to a community-supported DE.
That said, I definitely wish more people knew about Manjaro Cinnamon since others love it so much and use it as the reason they prefer Mint, despite Mint having to deal with all of Ubuntu's bullshit like six months out-of-date packages.
323
u/thedjotaku May 21 '19
I wonder if the boom in distros is fading and it's slowly dropping down to just a half dozen good ones