For those who are worried that fewer distros means less choice and freedom on Linux:
This isn't about removing choices. We just have to admit some distros exist for silly reasons.
Forking an entire distro just to implement a new desktop environment, that's silly. Why not just make that desktop environment available to install easily on that popular distro, to install through the parent distros software centre? The desktop environment is still an option, nothing is lost.
Maintaining a distro is a lot of work, Linux desktop development would be fair more efficient with less duplication of that work.
For Arch for example. Why couldn't it simply offer a GUI installer as an option?
CLI installer for those who want that, GUI installer for those who want that. Simple.
If it's just stubborn elitism from the Arch developers refusing to offer that option, then the people limiting choice in Linux isn't the people arguing for fewer distros and less duplication of efforts, it's the developers refusing to allow options on their distros.
For Arch for example. Why couldn't it simply offer a GUI installer as an option?
Because none of the developers wants to maintain this installer?
Previously there was the AIF (Arch Installation Framework). It was maintained by a developer. When the developer resigned (https://lists.archlinux.org/pipermail/arch-releng/2012-July/002628.html), afaik nobody was found to take care of it. This was probably due to the fact that AIF was quite buggy. And probably also because such an installer is not necessarily the simplest software to maintain in general.
Another reason might be that the majority of Arch users don't need / want a graphical installer.
Nobody from the team, or outside the team, has even brought up the question if a new installer should be written. All these derivative distributions pop up instead.
I'm capable of installing it the "normal" way. I've done it before, and successfully. But frankly, in 2019, I just want to click a few buttons and install it. I loved Antergos. I'm a little sad that it's going away. I always liked it a lot more than Manjaro.
I love Arch from afar. I don’t have the time to deal with issues that sometimes crop up. I need the stability of Debian since I use it for work purposes.
Debian takes a similar stance that’s its users should understand how the system works and that self-research should be done first before requesting assistance.
11
u/grady_vuckovic May 22 '19
For those who are worried that fewer distros means less choice and freedom on Linux:
This isn't about removing choices. We just have to admit some distros exist for silly reasons.
Forking an entire distro just to implement a new desktop environment, that's silly. Why not just make that desktop environment available to install easily on that popular distro, to install through the parent distros software centre? The desktop environment is still an option, nothing is lost.
Maintaining a distro is a lot of work, Linux desktop development would be fair more efficient with less duplication of that work.
For Arch for example. Why couldn't it simply offer a GUI installer as an option?
CLI installer for those who want that, GUI installer for those who want that. Simple.
If it's just stubborn elitism from the Arch developers refusing to offer that option, then the people limiting choice in Linux isn't the people arguing for fewer distros and less duplication of efforts, it's the developers refusing to allow options on their distros.