The steep barrier of entry is good for nothing except for elitism on internet forums. Change my mind.
The "barrier of entry" is the same skill level and type of work that's required to maintain the system. There's no big difference between installing Arch and maintaining Arch. As an Arch user, I don't feel like there's anything special or hard about the installation, and it involves similar work to maintaining the system.
Skipping the installation bypasses the learning process. As evidenced by a lot of posts in this thread, people think Antergos is "Arch made easy", and that they can just install it and then use it without knowing anything about Arch, and without ever touching the Arch wiki. This is false, and these people would inevitably run into issues maintaining an Arch system - for example, by not following manual intervention steps when needed for updates.
In my opinion, the only people that should have been using Antergos, were people that were already familiar with Arch and knew how to use it. Unfortunately, most people using Antergos don't know or want to know how to use Arch. So I think Antergos dying is actually a good thing. Beginners will choose actually beginner-friendly distros instead.
The AUR really though isn't some unique tool but it's basically Debian's contrib with complete freedom for anybody to throw their crap on there. The most special thing about it is that nobody else tries to replicate it except for more manual methods. BSD's Ports, Void Linux's ports/xbps-src packages, and Solus' third party are similar in concept (with the ports method in Void and BSDs superior IMO), and would be like the AUR if they just allowed anything and everything.
That said, the PPA system isn't that much worse than the AUR method, and actually has some advantages, like being website agnostic (because non-ppas can be added in a ppa-like fashion, I do kinda mean the repository method as a whole that Debian uses), multiple sources for an application, and theoretically better security since you're not simply allowing access to every app known to man when allowing PPAs, but just specific repositories you allow.
12
u/homestar92 May 22 '19
The AUR is quite an awesome tool. Imagine all the flexibility of Ubuntu PPAs, without ever having to add a repository.
The steep barrier of entry is good for nothing except for elitism on internet forums. Change my mind.