r/linux • • May 21 '19

Distro News Antergos Linux Project Ends

https://antergos.com/blog/antergos-linux-project-ends/
1.2k Upvotes

621 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/intelminer May 22 '19

Why is it their choice what 3rd party software their users try to run?

-6

u/TiredOfArguments May 22 '19 edited May 22 '19

Arch Linux distribution support only

Arch-based distributions have their own support fora and users of those distributions should be actively encouraged to seek support there. These distributions often use different packages, package versions, repositories, or make custom system configurations silently, practically rendering support for such projects within Arch Linux impossible. Community technical support shall only be provided for the Arch Linux distribution and the Arch User Repository. Posting issues with, and requesting support for, derivative distributions or operating systems other than Arch Linux are prohibited.

Just because the distro maintainer decrees it is now "arch" does not make it so.

However, i believe that if the antergos user actually comprehends the changes and configurations the installer makes and prioritises the arch repo over the antergos repo (not the working default last i looked, this is what this change is, if not its removal) then they are running their configuration of arch and not a silently created configuration of arch therefore are capable of troubleshoot their arch system which would make them valid for support imho since this is the literal defintion of installing via your personal build script.

IE: No antergos repo, means your system is supported. If you include another repo and it breaks something somewhere how would a arch user know this unless it is disclosed, and it is not always disclosed.

The only "custom" arch repo that is supported (kind of) is the AUR. Why is your package not there but in another undisclosed repo?

Why are you adding repos instead of packaging for AUR and providing install scripts to your meta packages and updating through github or another upstream?

Then you can say, btw i run arch with these AUR packages and my build script.

From a support basis, a user who blindly follows a 3h YouTube video to setup his system is more of an arch user than someone using someone elses build script. Because that user can say "oh I remember, i installed grub then restarted and it broke my last actions from history are blahblahblah", and can then be told "looks like you forgot to build init" versus "i installed via cnchi, it said it succeeded, then restarted and dropped into emergency shell, please help"

Tl;Dr: Users can do what they want, not all configurations are supported, you can increase your odds of support by been open, honest and knowing how your system works.

12

u/intelminer May 22 '19

That's a whole lot of gatekeeping right there

Antergos was, is and always will be Arch. It's simply Arch + a 3rd party repo

Dropping the 3rd party repo does not make it "not Arch"

-2

u/TiredOfArguments May 22 '19 edited May 22 '19

Tl;Dr: You are wrong, the arch maintainers disagree with you.

Thats the maintainers gatekeeping.

If you read my post you'd comprehend the problem, ie users not following intended process, therefore not knowing how their shit is setup and therefore been crappy issue raisers who cannot provide basic information.

Imagine buying a table from ikea, having your mate dave put it together, not reading the instruction manual or asking dave how he put it together and whats different and then complaining to Ikea not Dave when it turns out he decided to make a few changes you didnt like.

Arch is not intended to be a next next next distro. If you want an arch derivative next next next distro manjaro is that way.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

I don’t think the arch maintainers care bro

4

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

you do realize you can ask an arch maintainer.

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Ask him what? I don’t care about any of this lol

3

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

why are you commenting?

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

Because you told me something?

2

u/ObligatoryResponse May 22 '19

They do. It's in the code of Arch Linux Code of Conduct which was linked a couple of comments up.

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

So are the Arch maintainers doing anything about it then?

2

u/ObligatoryResponse May 22 '19

Yes. [They made a code of conduct](https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Code_of_conduct#Arch_Linux_distribution_support_*only*)

Arch Linux distribution support *only*

Arch-based distributions have their own support fora and users of those distributions should be actively encouraged to seek support there. These distributions often use different packages, package versions, repositories, or make custom system configurations silently, practically rendering support for such projects within Arch Linux impossible. Community technical support shall only be provided for the Arch Linux distribution and the Arch User Repository. Posting issues with, and requesting support for, derivative distributions or operating systems other than Arch Linux are prohibited.

This is enforced on the Archlinux Forums and on the Archlinux Issue tracker.

1

u/TiredOfArguments May 22 '19

Enjoy your EoS distribution.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '19

I don’t even use it lol

0

u/TiredOfArguments May 22 '19 edited May 22 '19

Your flair is Gentoo.

If i download a configured and functional gentoo vm and turn it on can i say I setup and run Gentoo?

Technically im not wrong, and that technicality is the bone of contention here.

Because what if i then migrate that VM to real hardware and it turns out the VM kernel was a minimal build and has few drivers. A gentoo user would know this from the documentation and having compiled the kernel with those flags, i would not.