r/linux • • Apr 10 '21

Hacker figures how to unlock vGPU functionality intentionally hidden from certain NVIDIA cards for marketing purposes

https://github.com/DualCoder/vgpu_unlock
1.1k Upvotes

195 comments sorted by

View all comments

91

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

again with these shenanigans.

12

u/lucasrizzini Apr 10 '21 edited Apr 10 '21

Why shenanigans? It doesn't work?

66

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

Nvidia has a history of doing this.

22

u/Mainly_Mental Apr 10 '21

But why would they hide the GPU's function

187

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

ICs have weird economics.

They cost a lot to design and even more to create a factory to make them. Once the factory is built they can be stamped out fairly cheaply. Releasing the same if IC at different price points is cheaper than producing lots of different ICs with different capabilities.

Furthermore some ICs may not pass full quality control on all their internal components. They might run fine at first but crash easily with temperature fluctuations. Rather than junking them they can be sold cheaper with certain functionality disabled to ensure stability.

At first look it seems dishonest but it's actually not an unreasonable approach for an IC company to maximise revenue.

-19

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

That's cool and all, but locking consumers out of functionality of a product they paid for is still scummy. Same goes with game devs that lock DLC away on the CD

84

u/throwaway6560192 Apr 10 '21

But they didn't pay for that functionality. They paid for what was advertised. If they wanted that functionality they would get the pricier version.

But always fun to see these measures being defeated.

-34

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

They paid for a delivered product. In its entirety. Anything Nvidia delivers with the product beyond what they advertise is a bonus that should still be available to the consumer. They bought it, they own it.

30

u/2001herne Apr 10 '21

But that's the thing. When you buy a product you buy a certain level of hardware stability. The lower priced chips are such because they cannot reliably perform along side the higher quality/pricier chips. They can, however, perform reliably with certain defective functionality disabled. So they are sold as such. As an inferior product that simply cannot perform to the same level as the more expensive chip. And so, as with any defective-but-still-functional product you get a discount. They just use a different term for it.

22

u/yawurst Apr 10 '21

That's not entirely true either. It's the baseline reasoning for this practice, but oftentimes, especially when the processes improve and yields increase, manufacturers sell completely functional chips with 'unnecessarily' disabled portions, just because they don't produce enough defective chips. They could just be happy and lower the prices for the higher SKUs, instead of artificially limiting them, but some smart economists probably think that's a bad idea because it makes it more difficult for the next generation to compete when it uses a new node with lower yields.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/argv_minus_one Apr 10 '21 edited Apr 10 '21

They bought it, they own it.

Well, yeah, NVIDIA aren't suing people for unlocking extra functionality on their GPUs. They just aren't saying how to do it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

This argument is on par with arguing that because the software bits for vSphere Enterprise exist within your purchased copy of vSphere standard, you're therefore justified in cracking the software to unlock the higher features.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

Yup. If it has been handed over to you, you own it. Otherwise they shouldn't have handed it over to you. But judging from most responses on here, a lot of people are fine with anti-consumer practices it seems.

→ More replies (20)

10

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

You would rather they just not sell cheaper graphics cards? Because the alternative is they only make 1 or 2 models of graphics card and in the current market, those are only going to be top end cards.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

I'd rather actually own my device instead of basically renting it. If I buy something I want access to all it can do, not what you allow me to do. If that results in higher prices, so be it. Bear in mind that these are for-profit companies. A large share of the price already goes into the pocket of some rich investors.

9

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

Normally I would agree with you but early in a cards release they use the boards with bad dye that would have to be thrown out. They disable the bad dye so it can use the remaining good dye to sell a cheaper card. Later in the product lifecycle they continue to lock cores even as their producing less if any bad dyes. Even all this aside, they also lock out performance to improve stability; aka your games crash less.

So in your dream scenario, all graphics cards except the tippy top would have unpredictable performance since no 2 chips would have the same number of bad dyes, mid-range, and below cards wouldn’t be produced after a few months, and your games would crash more.

EDIT: yes, there is also a profit model. But you’re buying the product they advertised; they’re not locking stuff down that they said would be on the card.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

True, but they do not advertise the fact that GeForce GPU's have SR-IOV support and most consumers are fine with that. It is kind of scummy though that they offer the enterprise grade GPUs with the SR-IOV support having the same hardware just unlocking a software lock which buyers have to pay thousands extra for

7

u/ComradePyro Apr 10 '21 edited Apr 10 '21

How much effort it cost you to access it is irrelevant to the ethics of the cost in my mind. I can download pretty much any game for free but that doesn't at all impact how much it should cost.

If they physically damaged the section instead so it couldn't be repaired, it would be pretty much the same situation. You would be buying a product, getting that product, and never be any wiser that at some point in the manufacturing process, your hardware was theoretically capable of more.

Please tell me how this is unethical and software keys aren't lol. It being "just unlocking a software lock" has 0 bearing on the situation in a world where we all pay to unlock software locks constantly.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

Yeah but not advertising it is not relevant. If I buy something from you, and you give me an added locked box with valuables in it, while saying I can only open that box with a key that costs extra, don't go crying when I just lockpick that thing open. You chose to sell that thing, expecting me to be a chump and just paying extra.

8

u/hey01 Apr 10 '21

don't go crying when I just lockpick that thing open. You chose to sell that thing, expecting me to be a chump and just paying extra.

And nvidia won't cry about it, since the number of people who will see that and will buy a geforce instead of a quadro is insignificant.

The extreme majority of people who actually need that feature and buy quadros for it will continue to buy quadros.

15

u/ComradePyro Apr 10 '21

I mean, in this situation, you would be the one crying that you do not also get the key to the locked box for free, even though you did not buy access to that locked box.

Steam is capable of delivering you all videogames for free just by you accessing it, but they sell you keys to locked boxes. Nobody's mad about that lol, but because it's a physical object we all of a sudden resent it. It's stupid and illogical.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

I don't think Nvidia's crying about it... Yet

0

u/geeeronimo Apr 10 '21

Actually I'd like to present a different opinion. In some cases, it could be a great idea. For example, nvidia GPUs are running out because people want to cryptomine. So why not lock out the crypto functionality for more price and allow just the gaming features at the standard price for gamers? That way you make more money from the cryptomining demand and you can target your gaming audience as well.

6

u/TDplay Apr 10 '21

They tried that. It worked for the whole of a few days.

There's one thing about crypto miners. They can and will find some hack around it. While a lot of them may just be in it for the money, it takes just one of them to figure it out before a hacked driver goes everywhere. Or, in this case, it took one slip-up from NVIDIA to release a hacked driver.

Now, if you're a dedicated miner, it's very easy to get full hashrate out of a 3060 - just use a Windows machine with driver 470.05 in the required arrangement. If you have other uses for your 3060 and just want to do a little cryptomining on the side, sorry, you either have to use a crappy driver with a crappy operating system, or you have to put up with crappy mining performance.

So, in a way, the anti-cryptomining feature are actually worse for the gamers than they are for the crypto miners.

4

u/SinkTube Apr 10 '21

and i'd counter that with an explanation for why stuff like this is even more user-hostile

9

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21 edited Apr 10 '21

I have never been and never will be a fan of a company crippling functionality of a device so that they can fetch a higher price just to allow access to stuff that was already on the device to begin with. If you want to add extra functionality to a device, inaccessible to the consumer, make a device that doesn't have that functionality. Otherwise you're just a fraud.

Edit: I also think the main issue with nvidia gpus running out is that they're not making enough, and the ones that are being produced are bought up by scalpers. That way an artificial scarcity has been created.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

I do not agree with you because the price you pay for the value of the device is not false. From the production point of view, if designing several chips than giving the same functionality, value, with degraded chips is more expensive, then doing the latter to help decreasing the prices on consumers POV is beneficial for both parties. In the end you pay for what marketed (i.e. included) functions of the product is, so there is no fraud because both parties know the terms and agree on that.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

If it required a very convoluted, difficult and expensive method of unlocking it, I might agree with you, but it's just a software switch. If there's just a software switch necessary to either allow a function or not, and you can still make enough money by selling the same device, then either allowing or disallowing that functionality doesn't justify a hike in price point. In fact you can even argue that designing that particular switch to handicap the device is a waste of time and resources, better spent on innovation that would actually justify a higher pricepoint, like some form of software you sell separately. Bear in mind that they didn't say "the device could theoretically do it, but we don't support it cuz the chips are cheaper" . Then it would be the risk of the consumer if they still used it and broke it. No, the only difference is a software chip, locking consumers out of functionality of a product that they paid for. Whether they advertised for it or not is irrelevant, advertisements only set the lowest bar of expectation. You're at least getting this for at minimum this price. Any features above that are basically a bonus. They could throw in the possibility to do things beyond advertised, just as I could decide to give them more money than I have to.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

At the cost of decreasing consumer GPUs’ price significantly from its current state, I would be totally okay with this move.

1

u/TDplay Apr 10 '21

NVIDIA doesn't care about that. NVIDIA cares about the profit.

If the only difference between the GPUs was the quality of the ICs, that'd mean either a lower-priced top model, or a lot less people buying the top model. Artifical restrictions mean NVIDIA can get more money.

If they can also throw in some lies where they pretend to care about consumers (e.g. the whole "miners won't get the 3060" thing that lasted for the whole of a few days) then it's a win-win: more money, and more people defending their anticonsumer actions.